Civilsdaily

Subject: Indian Society

  • U.P., Rajasthan, M.P. top in cases of atrocities on Dalits: report

    Why in the News?

    According to a recent government report, 97.7% of atrocities against Scheduled Castes in 2022 were concentrated in 13 states, with Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, and Madhya Pradesh reporting the highest numbers.

    What are the finding as per report?

    • Concentration of Cases: Approximately 97.7% of atrocities against Scheduled Castes (SCs) were reported from 13 states, with Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, and Madhya Pradesh having the highest incidents. For Scheduled Tribes (STs), 98.91% of cases were also concentrated in these states.
    • Statistics on Atrocities:
        • For SCs, there were 51,656 reported cases, with Uttar Pradesh alone accounting for 23.78% (12,287 cases).
        • Other significant contributors included Rajasthan (8,651 cases, 16.75%) and Madhya Pradesh (7,732 cases, 14.97%).
        • For STs, a total of 9,735 cases were registered, with Madhya Pradesh reporting the highest at 30.61% (2,979 cases).
    • Investigation and Charge-Sheeting:
      • Among SC-related cases, 60.38% resulted in charge sheets, while 14.78% concluded with final reports due to reasons like false claims or lack of evidence.
      • For ST-related cases, the charge-sheeting rate was slightly higher at 63.32%, with similar conclusions for final reports.
    • Conviction Rates: The conviction rate for atrocities under the Act has declined to 32.4% in 2022 from 39.2% in 2020, indicating a concerning trend in legal outcomes for victims.
    • Special Courts and Infrastructure: Out of 498 districts, only 194 had established special courts to expedite trials related to these cases, highlighting a significant gap in judicial infrastructure.

    What are the protection for SCs in Indian law?

    The Indian legal framework provides several protections for SCs under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989:

    • Prohibition of Atrocities: The Act defines various forms of atrocities against SC members, including social exclusion, bonded labor, forced manual scavenging, and physical violence.
    • Legal Recourse: Victims can report crimes to the police or the National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC), which has the authority to investigate complaints and ensure legal protections are enforced.
    • Punishments for Offenders: Offenders can face imprisonment ranging from six months to five years along with fines for committing atrocities against SC members.

    What are the intiative taken by government to empower SCs in economical and social term?

    • Reservation Policies: The Constitution mandates reservations for SCs in government jobs and educational institutions to enhance their representation and opportunities.
    • Financial Assistance Programs: Various schemes provide financial support for self-employment and skill development among SC communities to improve their economic status. Example is the National Scheduled Castes Finance and Development Corporation (NSFDC).
    • Establishment of Protection Cells: SC/ST Protection Cells have been set up across states to address grievances and ensure the enforcement of protective laws.For instance, in Karnataka, these cells have been actively involved in monitoring atrocities against SCs/STs and conducting surveys in atrocity-prone areas
    • Awareness Campaigns and Training Programs: The government conducts awareness campaigns to educate SC communities about their rights and available legal protections. For example,“Bharat ke Sathi” campaign.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthening Legal and Judicial Mechanisms: Establish more special courts and fast-track mechanisms in all districts to ensure timely justice for victims of atrocities, alongside improving conviction rates through effective investigation and prosecution.
    • Empowering SC Communities Through Socio-Economic Initiatives: Expand skill development, financial assistance programs, and awareness campaigns to improve economic independence and social integration of SC communities, ensuring better enforcement of their rights and protections.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q Whether the National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) can enforce the implementation of constitutional reservation for the Scheduled Castes in the religious minority institutions? Examine. (UPSC IAS/2018)

  • [14th September 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Being ‘trans’ is being human

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) in India can be most effective when its tasks are adequately supported by other mechanisms that ensure the accountability of a government. In light of above observation assess the role of NHRC as an effective complement to the judiciary and other institutions in promoting and protecting human rights standards. (UPSC CSE 2014)

    Q The multiplicity of various commissions for the vulnerable sections of the society leads to problems of overlapping jurisdiction and duplication of functions. Is it better to merge all commissions into an umbrella Human Rights Commission? Argue your case. (UPSC CSE 2018)

    Prelims:
    In India, Legal Services Authorities provide free legal services to which of the following type of citizens?
    1. Person with an annual income of less than Rs. 1,00,000
    2. Transgender with an annual income of less than Rs. 2,00,000
    3. Member of Other Backward Classes (OBC) with an annual income of less than Rs. 3,00,000
    Select the correct answer using the code given below:
    (a) 1 and 2 only
    (b) 3 and 4 only
    (c) 2 and 3 only
    (d) 1 and 4 only

    Mentor’s Comment: Transgender rights are human rights because all people deserve to be treated with dignity and respect, regardless of their gender identity or expression. Transgender individuals face high rates of discrimination, violence, and marginalization worldwide, which violate their fundamental human rights.

    Transgender rights in India and around the world have seen significant advancements, but challenges remain. Legal recognition is crucial for ensuring equal rights, yet many transgender individuals still encounter discrimination and social stigma. Continued advocacy and awareness are necessary to improve the lives of transgender people globally.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    There are ongoing global discussions about the legal rights and recognition of transgender individuals.  Recognizing and affirming transgender identities are a part of the broader human condition.

    ‘Transgender’ is an umbrella term for people whose gender identity or expression differs from the sex they were assigned at birth. The right to self-determine one’s gender identity is considered a fundamental human right.

    The Evolving Landscape of Transgender Rights:

    • Legal Recognition of Gender Identity: Some countries like Argentina, Denmark, and Malta allow individuals to change their legal gender through self-declaration, without requiring surgery or medical intervention.
      • In 2014, the Indian SC affirmed the rights of transgender people to determine their own gender identity and be recognized as “third gender”.
      • Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 protects transgender people from discrimination in areas like education, employment, and healthcare. 
    • Discrimination and Violence: Transgender people face high rates of discrimination, violence, and marginalization worldwide.
      • For example, in the U.S., some states passed laws in 2022-23, restricting transgender rights, such as limiting access to gender-affirming healthcare or banning transgender athletes from participating in sports consistent with their gender identity.
    • International Human Rights Frameworks: The Yogyakarta Principles outline how international human rights law applies to issues of sexual orientation and gender identity.
      • The United Nations has called for the decriminalization of gender identity and the prohibition of discrimination based on gender expression.
    • Present societal attitudes: Public views on transgender issues are complex and evolving, with some arguing progress is too slow while others feel the pace of change is too rapid.
      • Increasing visibility and representation of transgender people in media and culture has helped raise awareness and acceptance.

    Need to understand Gender Identity:

    • Gender vs. Sex: ‘Sex’ refers to biological attributes like chromosomes and reproductive organs. For instance, someone with XY chromosomes is typically assigned male at birth.
      • ‘Gender’ involves how individuals identify and express themselves, which can differ from their assigned sex. For example, a person may be biologically male but identify as non-binary.
      • Hence, Gender identity is the internal sense of being male, female, both, neither, or anywhere along the gender spectrum. It may or may not align with the sex assigned at birth.
    • Gender Expression: This refers to how individuals express their gender through clothing, behavior, and appearance. For example, a person may dress in a way that is traditionally associated with the opposite gender.
    • Recognition and Rights: Some countries allow individuals to change their legal gender easily, while others impose strict requirements, such as surgery or medical evaluations.
      • Some cultures too recognize more than two genders, such as the hijra community in South Asia or Two-Spirit identities among some Indigenous peoples in North America.

    How Science can help us?

    • Bringing awareness: Science fiction can help us examine current societal issues by placing them in unfamiliar contexts. For example, in the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode “The Measure of a Man,” a trial questions whether Data, an android, is property or a person.
    • Need for Data Outlook:  The court must decide if data can be dismantled for research without his consent. A key argument is that data should be seen as a person with rights, not just as a machine.
      • The verdict will reflect who we are as a society and could affect personal freedoms for many.

    Conclusion: The real issue lies with those who question the humanity of transgender individuals. To be transgender or gay is a natural part of being human while analyzing their bodies to judge their humanity is a dehumanizing act.

  • Policy paralysis, a weakened public health sector

    Why in the News?

    Primary care remains underdeveloped, while the private sector has seen significant growth in secondary and tertiary care.

    What are the major necessities in Public Health? 

    • Diseases of Poverty: This includes health issues predominantly affecting the poor and vulnerable populations, such as tuberculosis, malaria, undernutrition, maternal mortality, and illnesses caused by food and water-borne infections like typhoid and diarrheal diseases. 
      • Addressing these needs is critical not only from a health perspective but also as a matter of human rights.
    • Middle-Class Health Concerns: The second category focuses on health issues related to environmental pollution, including air and water quality, waste management, and food safety. 
      • These issues are often exacerbated by inadequate infrastructure and poor market regulations, leading to chronic illnesses and road traffic accidents.
    • Curative Care Needs: The most visible public health needs are those related to curative care, which is divided into three levels: primary, secondary, and tertiary care. 
      • The poor often rely on public primary health care for affordable services, while secondary care remains historically neglected. 
      • Tertiary care is primarily addressed through government schemes like the Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (PMJAY) under Ayushman Bharat, aimed at providing coverage for serious health issues.

    How do the private hospitals become a real beneficiary in present times? 

    • Limited Coverage: India’s health insurance primarily covers only hospitalisation expenses, leaving out outpatient and primary care services. This benefits private hospitals as they can monopolise high-cost medical treatments, while the larger uninsured population faces commercialised care at market rates.
    • Weakening of Public Health Sector: The government’s shift in focus from strengthening public sector health care to outsourcing via insurance schemes like PMJAY indicates a failure to build adequate secondary and tertiary public health services.  

    Threats to Public Healthcare:

    • Neglect of Secondary and Tertiary Care: The inadequate investment in strengthening secondary- and tertiary-level health care in the public sector, leads to a reliance on private hospitals.
    • Transformation of Primary Health Centres (PHCs) and Sub-centres: The conversion of sub-centres and PHCs into Health and Wellness Centres (HWCs) has undermined their original role in preventive and promotive health care.  
    • Loss of Trust in Public Healthcare: Due to overcrowding, poor infrastructure, and inadequate funding, public health institutions are losing credibility. Coupled with the commercial interests of private providers, this creates a dual crisis of access and quality in the healthcare system.
    • Rebranding of Health Centres: The recent renaming of HWCs as “Ayushman Arogya Mandirs” raises concerns about cultural relevance and secularism in public health institutions, especially for non-Hindi-speaking populations, further undermining trust in the system.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthen Public Healthcare Infrastructure: Invest in enhancing secondary and tertiary care facilities in the public sector to reduce dependence on private hospitals.  
    • Integrate Health Insurance and Primary Care: Expand health insurance coverage to include outpatient and primary care services, and ensure that public health centers retain their focus on preventive and promotive care.  

    Mains PYQ:

    Q Public health system has limitation in providing universal health coverage. Do you think that private sector can help in bridging the gap? What other viable alternatives do you suggest? (UPSC IAS/2015)

  • State changes in Rape law

    Why in the News?

    Due to the ongoing protest in Kolkata, the WB Assembly has unanimously passed a Bill mandating the death penalty for rape cases where victims die or are left in vegetative states.

    Features of West Bengal’s Aparajita Bill:

    • Death Penalty: The Bill mandates the death penalty for individuals convicted of rape if the victim dies or is left in a permanent vegetative state. It also introduces the death penalty as the maximum punishment for all rape cases.
    • Amendments to Existing Laws: The Bill amends the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, and the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012, to strengthen penalties for sexual offenses.
    • Special Task Force and Courts: It establishes a district-level Aparajita Task Force for investigating rape cases and mandates the creation of Special Courts to expedite trials, aiming to complete investigations within 21 days.
    • Increased Penalties for Repeat Offenders: The Bill enhances punishments for repeat offenders, replacing simple life imprisonment with rigorous life imprisonment.
    • Privacy Protections: It introduces penalties for unauthorized disclosure of a victim’s identity and for publishing information related to court proceedings in rape cases.
    • Focus on Speedy Justice: The Bill aims to reduce the time frame for investigations and trials, emphasizing a victim-centered approach to minimize trauma.

    How Bengal’s Aparajita Bill differ from the Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra laws?

    Dimensions West Bengal (Aparajita Bill) Andhra Pradesh (Disha Bill) Maharashtra (Shakti Bill)
    Scope of Death Penalty Death is mandatory in cases of rape leading to the victim’s death or vegetative state Death penalty for the rape of minors below 16, gang rape, and repeat offenders Similar to Andhra Pradesh, it introduced the death penalty for heinous cases, such as acid attacks and severe rape cases, but it also does not mandate death in all instances.
    Special Institutions Aparajita Task Forces and Special Courts in every district specifically for rape cases, ensuring expedited legal proceedings with strict timelines. Propose Special Police Teams and Exclusive Special Courts for dealing with crimes against women, along with a registry for offenders. Formation of special courts but also emphasizes digital cooperation
    Timeframes for Legal Processes: Investigation time is 21 days (extendable to 15 more), and trials must be completed within 30 days post-chargesheet. Investigation time is  seven days and mandates trials be completed within 21 days. Completed within 15 working days after an FIR is filed, with an extension of up to 7 days if the investigating officer provides written reasons for the delay and the trial must be completed within 30 working days from the date of filing the charge sheet.
    Amendments to POCSO Introduces the death penalty for penetrative sexual assault under the POCSO Act. Amended the POCSO Act to include death penalties, particularly for heinous offenses, but do not make it mandatory in all cases. Same as Disha bill
    Use of Digital Platforms No available No available Unique features penalizing social media platforms and intermediaries that fail to provide requested data for investigations.

    Why President’s Assent is essential?

    • Criminal law falls under the Concurrent List of the Indian Constitution, meaning both state and central legislatures can legislate on the subject. However, state laws require the President’s approval to take precedence over existing central laws.
    • Without presidential assent, the provisions of the Aparajita Bill, as well as those from Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra, cannot be enforced, rendering them ineffective despite being passed by the respective state assemblies.

    Conclusion:

    The state should launch public awareness campaigns and involve stakeholders to build broad-based support, emphasizing the Bill’s objectives of enhancing victim protection and delivering speedy justice to encourage timely presidential approval.

  • [5th September 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Sub-classification verdict through Ambedkar’s ideals

    [5th September 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Sub-classification verdict through Ambedkar’s ideals

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q Whether National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) can enforce the implementation of constitutional reservation for the Scheduled Castes in the religious minority institutions? Examine. (UPSC IAS/2018)

    Q What are the two major legal initiatives by state since Independence, addressing discrimination against Scheduled Tribes (ST)? (UPSC IAS/2017)

    Q ‘Constitutional Morality’ is rooted in the Constitution itself and is founded on its essential facets. Explain the doctrine of ‘Constitutional Morality’ with the help of relevant judicial decisions. (UPSC IAS/2021)

    Mentor comment: The recent verdict of the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court upholding the legality of the sub-classification of Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs) for the purpose of reservations has already created an avalanche of reactions, both positive and negative. The positive reactions are coming from die-hard, self-proclaimed progressives who are enamored with any phraseology that appears to favor the downtrodden, irrespective of the long-term impact of the decisions ensconced in that phraseology. The negative reactions are coming from the population that constitutes SCs, who stand accused of grabbing a disproportionate share of reservations. These population constituents are mainly arguing that sub-classification is not constitutionally permitted.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    The Supreme Court of India, in a landmark 6:1 majority judgment on August 1, 2024 in the State of Punjab & Ors. vs. Davinder Singh & Ors., upheld the permissibility of sub-classification of Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes for reservation purposes, overruling the previous EV Chinnaiah judgment.

    What are the main arguments against the sub-classification of SC/STs?

    • Homogeneity Concerns: Critics argue that sub-classification undermines the uniform status of SCs and STs.
      • The ruling aligns with B.R. Ambedkar’s ideas of fraternity and mutual respect among these communities. However, some believe that it oversteps the previous varna system.
    • Potential for Inequality: There are fears that sub-classification could exacerbate existing inequalities
      • For example, the concept of a “creamy layer,” refers to the more privileged individuals within these groups who may not need reservation benefits.
    • Judicial Precedent: Previous Supreme Court rulings, such as in the E.V. Chinnaiah case, have held that SCs form a homogeneous group and that sub-classifying them for reservations violates constitutional provisions, particularly Articles 14 and 341.
    B.R. Ambedkar’s Fight for Social Justice:

    Dr. Ambedkar dedicated his life to achieving social and civil justice for the most oppressed groups, especially former untouchables.
    • High Caste Dominance: His efforts were often met with resistance from the traditional Hindu caste system, which did not adequately support his calls for cultural rights. Ambedkar pointed out that they should eliminate their internal divisions while fighting against untouchability.
    • Anti-caste Movements: He organized important movements, like the Mahad Satyagraha and the Kalaram temple entry movement, to challenge the discrimination faced by Dalits.

    Other learnings from History:
    • The present SC’s sub-classification judgment is a reflection of years of grassroots activism and demands by marginalized Dalit communities like Valmikis, Musahars, Madigas, and Arunthathiyars.
    • It is a testament to the ongoing struggle for justice led by organizations such as MRPS, Mang movements in Maharashtra, and the Valmiki movements in North India.

    Criticism and Support for Sub-Classification of Scheduled Castes

    • Criticism and Causes: Some Dalit leaders fear sub-classification could diminish their political leverage and fragment the Dalit constituency, weakening the collective Dalit movement.
      • For example, ‘Bharat Bandh’ called by some North Indian Dalit organizations was seen as a misstep that could affect the collective identity and mobilization of Dalit castes.
    • Support and Causes: The debate around sub-classification has largely been resolved in South India, with most Dalit organizations supporting the demand for sub-categorization among SCs.
      • Sub-classification could strengthen the collective identity of SCs, furthering the Ambedkarization process by including those on the margins. 
      • It aligns with the principles of equitable representation based on numerical strength, as leaders like Kanshiram advocate.

    Conclusion:

    Embracing this judgment with the spirit of fraternity, as Ambedkar envisioned, will be crucial in achieving a more just and inclusive society. The movement needs to broaden its focus beyond traditional reservation policies, advocating for extension to the private sector and pursuing land redistribution.

  • [pib] Measures taken by Govt. for LGBTQI+ Community

    Why in the News?

    The Department of Social Justice and Empowerment has invited inputs to ensure that policies and initiatives regarding the LGBTQI+ community are inclusive and effective.

    Who are the LGBTQ+?

    • It is an umbrella term used to refer to lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer and intersex.
    • LGBTQI+ people represent a subset of individuals among the broader category of sexual and gender diverse individuals.
    • Sexual orientation, gender identity and expression (SOGIE) is diverse and spans cultures across the world.

    Various policy initiatives for LGBTQI+ Community:

    Policy/Scheme Details
    Supreme Court Judgment on Section 377 (2018) • Decriminalized consensual same-sex relations by ruling that Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, which criminalized such acts, was unconstitutional.
    • Affirmed the right to privacy and equality, marking a historic victory for LGBTQI+ rights in India.
    Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act (2019) • Grants legal recognition to transgender individuals, prohibits discrimination in education, employment, and healthcare, and mandates the establishment of a national and state-level transgender welfare board.
    • Ensures protection of transgender rights, and access to welfare benefits, and facilitates legal recognition and equality.
    National Portal for Transgender Persons (2020) • An online platform launched by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment for applying for a transgender certificate and identity card.
    • Streamlines the legal recognition process, enabling transgender individuals to obtain official documentation more easily.
    SMILE Scheme (2021) • “Support for Marginalized Individuals for Livelihood and Enterprises” Central Sector scheme.
    • Provides financial assistance and support for the livelihood and enterprise development of marginalized individuals and beggars, including members of the LGBTQI+ community. 

     

    PYQ:

    [2023] Explain the constitutional perspectives of Gender Justice with the help of relevant Constitutional Provisions and case laws.

  • Himachal Bill raises women’s marriage age  

    Why in the News?

    The Himachal Pradesh Assembly passed a Bill on tuesday to increase the minimum marriage age for women from 18 to 21 years.

    Why did the Himachal Pradesh Assembly pass the Bill?

    • For Empowerment: The bill aims to provide them with more opportunities for education, career development, and overall personal growth.
    • For Health and Well-being: The Bill addresses the adverse health impacts associated with early marriage and motherhood, emphasizing the importance of allowing women to mature physically before starting a family.
    • For Social Justice: The bill aims for equal opportunities and ensures that women are not deprived of opportunities due to early marriage. 

    What is the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act (PCM) Act?

    • The PCM Act, 2006 is a significant piece of legislation in India aimed at preventing child marriages and protecting the rights of children.
    • Under the Act, a “child” is defined as a male who has not completed 21 years of age and a female who has not completed 18 years of age.

    What are the new proposed Amendments to the PCM Act?

    • Uniform Marriage Age: The Bill amends Section 2(a) of the PCM Act, redefining a “child” as any male or female who has not completed 21 years of age, eliminating the previous gender-based distinction.
    • Overriding Clause: The Bill amends Section 2(b) to include a clause that gives the new marriage age an overriding effect over any other law, custom, or usage, making it universally applicable in Himachal Pradesh.
    • Extension of Annulment Period: The Bill increases the period for filing a petition to annul a child marriage from two years after attaining majority to five years, allowing both men and women to annul their marriage until they turn 23.

    How will the Bill’s amendments to the PCM Act come into force?

    • Concurrent List Consideration: Marriage is a subject under the Concurrent List, allowing both the central and state governments to legislate on it. However, the Bill introduces amendments to a central law, making it potentially “repugnant” to the PCM Act.

    Note:

    • In the legal context, “repugnant” refers to a situation where a law enacted by a state legislature conflicts with or is contradictory to an existing central law on the same subject.
    • Article 254(1): If there is a conflict between a central law and a state law on a subject listed in the Concurrent List, the central law will prevail, and the repugnant portion of the state law will be considered void.
    • Governor’s Assent: As the Bill amends a central law, it must be reserved for the President’s consideration under Article 254(2) of the Constitution after being passed by the state Assembly and receiving the Governor’s assent.
    • President’s Approval: The Bill will become law only if the President of India gives her assent. This process ensures that the state’s amendments are consistent with the Constitution and central laws.

    Way Forward: 

    • Align with National Law: Coordinate with the central government to harmonize the amended marriage age with national legislation, ensuring legal consistency.
    • Community Awareness: Implement targeted awareness campaigns to educate the public on the benefits of delaying marriage, emphasizing women’s education and health.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q Empowering women is the key to control the population growth.” Discuss. (UPSC IAS/2019)

  • Crime, health-worker safety, and a self-examination 

    Why in the News?

    • The recent brutal rape and murder case in Kolkata has sparked widespread calls for the death penalty for the accused.
      • The Justice J.S. Verma Committee, formed in response to the 2012 Delhi gang rape, recommended against the death penalty for rape, even in the rarest of rare cases, arguing that it would be a regressive step.

    Deeper problem in the Health Care Sector: 

    • Healthcare Violence: The protests by resident doctors stem from a series of violent attacks against medical personnel. This violence often arises from disgruntled patients and their families who perceive poor healthcare services.
    • Corruption in Healthcare: The World Health Organization estimates that corruption claims nearly $455 billion annually, which could otherwise extend universal health coverage globally.
      • In India, this corruption manifests in various forms, including bribery and sextortion, further undermining the healthcare system’s integrity.
    • Ineffective Responses: Traditional responses to healthcare violence, such as enhancing security and legal measures, have proven inadequate. These knee-jerk reactions fail to address the root causes of the violence.

    What does the Justice K. Hema Committee report say on the Culture of Assault?

    • On Sexual Assault and Consent: Instances of sexual assault are not isolated events but are rooted in societal practices that undermine women’s autonomy and consent.
      • The National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,516 cases of rape in India in 2022, indicating a significant prevalence of sexual violence against women.
      • The Justice Hema Committee report emphasizes that rape is a manifestation of a culture that views women as objects rather than individuals with rights.
    • On Workplace Harassment: The Vishaka guidelines established in 1997 aimed to protect women from workplace harassment, leading to the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2013, which mandates the formation of Internal Complaints Committees (ICC).
      • The report argues that ICCs are inadequate for the film industry due to potential biases and influence from abusers, advocating for an independent government forum to address these issues.

    Need to Rethink Violence in Healthcare:  

    • Understanding the Multi-faceted Nature of Violence: Violence in healthcare settings is not limited to patient assaults on healthcare workers, it also includes institutional and managerial violence. This encompasses horizontal violence among healthcare providers and the systemic issues that create a hostile work environment.
    • Implementing Comprehensive Safety Measures: While immediate responses such as improving security and legal protections are necessary, they must be part of a broader strategy that includes training healthcare workers on conflict resolution, mental health support, and creating a culture of safety within healthcare institutions.

    About Justice J.S. Verma Committee Recommendations

    Recommendations on

    Explanation
    Rape • It recognized rape as a Crime of Power, not just passion.
    • Expand definition to include all forms of non-consensual penetration.
    • Remove marital rape exception; marriage should not imply automatic consent. (European Commission of Human Rights in C.R. vs U.K)
    Sexual Assault • Broaden definition to include all non-consensual, non-penetrative sexual acts.
    • Penalty: Up to 5 years of imprisonment or fines.
    Verbal Sexual Assault • Criminalize unwelcome sexual threats.
    • Punishable by up to 1 year in prison or fines.
    Sexual Harassment at Workplace • Include domestic workers under protections.
    • Replace internal complaint committees with Employment Tribunals.
    • Employers to compensate victims of sexual harassment.
    Acid Attacks • Propose a 10-year minimum punishment, separate from grievous hurt.
    • Establish a compensation fund for victims.
    Women in Conflict Areas • Review AFSPA; exclude government sanction for prosecuting sexual offenses by armed forces.
    • Appoint special commissioners to monitor offenses.
    Trafficking • Comprehensive anti-trafficking laws beyond prostitution.
    • Protective homes for women and juveniles overseen by High Courts.
    Child Sexual Abuse • Define ‘harm’ and ‘health’ in the Juvenile Justice Act to include both physical and mental aspects.
    Death Penalty • Opposed chemical castration and death penalty for rape.
    • Recommend life imprisonment.
    Medical Examination of Rape Victims • Ban the two-finger test; victim’s past sexual history should not influence the case.
    Reforms in Case Management • Set up Rape Crisis Cells, increase police accountability, allow online FIR filing.
    • Encourage community policing and increase police personnel.

    Need for a Comprehensive Approach:

    • National Task Force: Improving hospital security and infrastructure alone may not be sufficient to address the problem. The national task force constituted by the Supreme Court should devise a comprehensive road map to prevent and arrest medical corruption, particularly in the public sector.
    • Need Expertise: The task force should include experts from public health, medico-legal, and other allied fields, along with the participation of the larger governing and administrative community.

    Note: Recently some states have taken steps to empower women. For example, the Himachal Pradesh Assembly passed a Bill on Tuesday to increase the minimum marriage age for women from 18 to 21 years.

    Mains PYQ: 

    Q Appropriate local community level healthcare intervention is a prerequisite to achieve ‘Health for All’ in India. Explain. (UPSC CSE 2018)

    Q We are witnessing increasing instances of sexual violence against women in the country. Despite existing legal provisions against it, the number of such incidences is on the rise. Suggest some innovative measures to tackle this menace. (UPSC CSE 2014)

  • [27th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The heavy shackles of fear and vigilance

    [27th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The heavy shackles of fear and vigilance

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q Judicial Legislation is antithetical to the doctrine of separation of powers as envisaged in the Indian Constitution. In this context justify the filing of a large number of public interest petitions praying for issuing guidelines to executive authorities. (UPSC IAS/2020)
    Q What are the continued challenges for Women in India against time and space? (UPSC IAS/2019)
    Q ‘Women’s movement in India has not addressed the issues of women of lower social strata.’ Substantiate your view. (UPSC IAS/2018)
    Q Is the National Commission for Women able to strategize and tackle the problems that women face at both public and private spheres? Give reasons in support of your answer. (UPSC IAS/2017)

    Mentor comment: The brutal rape and murder of a woman doctor in Kolkata has reignited discussions about women’s safety in India. This incident highlights the pervasive violence women face, including sexual harassment and domestic abuse, while also emphasizing the often-overlooked psychological impacts of such violence. Despite the immediate physical consequences drawing public attention, the long-term psychological effects remain largely unaddressed and difficult to measure.

    Let’s learn!

    __

    Why in the News?

    The brutal rape and murder of a woman doctor in Kolkata has reignited discussions on the long-term psychological effects remain largely unaddressed and difficult to measure.

    What are the Psychological impacts of violence on women in India?
    • Mental Health Disorders: Women who experience violence are at a higher risk of depression, anxiety, PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder), and suicidal tendencies.  A significant percentage of women about 12% report severe psychological distress linked to domestic violence.
    • Substance Abuse: Many women resort to alcohol or drugs as coping mechanisms, often accompanied by feelings of shame and low self-esteem.
    • Health Disorders: Victims may develop eating disorders, sleep disturbances, and psychosomatic symptoms, manifesting psychological trauma as physical ailments.
    • Long-term Effects: Chronic stress, loss of trust, and ongoing fear significantly impair women’s quality of life and social engagement.

    An ingrained state of Alertness within women:

    Women in India often live in a constant state of alertness due to inadequate societal and state protection. This heightened awareness becomes ingrained and is often perceived as normal, which results in the following aspects:

    • Impacts on Freedom: The need to assess threats restricts women’s freedom to explore, take risks, and enjoy simple pleasures, affecting career choices and personal relationships.
    • Intergenerational Effects: The burden of vigilance is passed from mothers to daughters, reinforcing the notion that women are solely responsible for their safety.
    • Dissonance in Living: Women face a conflict between advocating for empowerment and adapting their behaviors for safety, creating a disparity between how they live and how they wish to live.

    Impact on Society

    • When women prioritize safety over exploration, they are denied the full spectrum of human experiences, depriving society of their potential contributions.
    • Due to this, the emotional strain, psychological fatigue, and loss of joy and freedom that women carry are significant and often unrecognized.
    • Acknowledging the burden of perpetual vigilance as a form of violence, it is essential for creating an equitable society where everyone can live, thrive, and contribute equally, free from safety concerns.
    Most Disadvantaged Section: Marginalized women face intensified discrimination and greater dangers due to intersecting factors of caste, class, and religion, often lacking institutional support and navigating environments rife with exploitation and abuse, unlike their more privileged counterparts.

    How can we redefine Safety to Prioritize Women’s Freedom and Empowerment?

    • Shift the Burden of Safety: The responsibility of a safe environment should lie with society and the state.
    • Invest in Gender-Sensitive Infrastructure: Developing safe and accessible public transportation systems is crucial for women’s mobility and economic empowerment. It includes well-lit streets, secure waiting areas, and the presence of female staff and security personnel.
    • Improve Legal Frameworks and Implementation: Laws and policies must be aligned with international standards. This requires capacity building for law enforcement, the judiciary, and service providers, as well as legal literacy programs for women.
    • Challenge Harmful Gender Norms: Addressing patriarchal attitudes and gender stereotypes, is crucial for creating a more equitable society. This involves engaging men and boys in gender equality initiatives, promoting positive masculinities, and challenging the normalization of violence against women.
    • Increase Women’s Participation in Decision-Making: Need to increase women’s representation in leadership roles in government, civil society, and community-based organizations.

    Conclusion: Women should not have to choose between their safety and their freedom. State and societal measures should not restrict women’s freedom any further under the guise of ensuring safety.

    https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/the-heavy-shackles-of-fear-and-vigilance/article68569659.ece

  • [26th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Reality of reel life, exploitation as a structural problem

    [26th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Reality of reel life, exploitation as a structural problem

    PYQ Relevance:
    Q Judicial Legislation is antithetical to the doctrine of separation of powers as envisaged in the Indian Constitution. In this context justify the filing of a large number of public interest petitions praying for issuing guidelines to executive authorities. (UPSC IAS/2020)
    Q What are the continued challenges for Women in India against time and space? (UPSC IAS/2019)
    Q An apparel manufacturing company having a large number of women employees was losing sales due to various factors. The company hired a reputed marketing executive, who increased the volume of sales within a short span of time. However, some unconfirmed reports came up regarding his indulgence in sexual harassment at the work place. After sometime, a woman employee lodged a formal complaint to the management against the marketing executive about sexually harassing her. Faced with the company’s indifference in not taking cognizance of her grievance, she lodged an FIR with the Police. Realizing the sensitivity and gravity of the situation, the company called the women employee to negotiate. In that she was offered a hefty sum of money to withdraw the complaint and the FIR and also give in writing that the marketing executive is not involved in this case. Identify the ethical issues involved in this case: what options are available to the women employee? (UPSC IAS/2019)

    Mentor comment: India faces significant challenges regarding sexual harassment and violence against women, deeply rooted in societal norms and systemic issues. Despite legislative measures like the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act of 2013, the prevalence of sexual violence remains alarmingly high. Justice K. Hema Committee report, released by the Kerala government on August 19, 2024, highlights severe issues of sexual exploitation and gender discrimination faced by women in the Malayalam film industry. Initially submitted in 2019, the report reveals a culture of harassment, including the “casting couch” phenomenon, where women are pressured to exchange sexual favors for roles. It also addresses inadequate facilities and the absence of basic rights for women in the industry. 

    Let’s learn!

    __

    Why in the news?

    The Justice K. Hema Committee report has sparked significant public debate and led to calls for reforms, including the establishment of an Internal Complaints Committee to address issues of sexual exploitation and gender discrimination faced by women effectively.

    What does the Report say on Culture of Assault?

    • On Sexual Assault and Consent: Instances of sexual assault are not isolated events but are rooted in societal practices that undermine women’s autonomy and consent.
      • The National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,516 cases of rape in India in 2022, indicating a significant prevalence of sexual violence against women.
      • The Justice Hema Committee report emphasizes that rape is a manifestation of a culture that views women as objects rather than individuals with rights.
    • On Workplace Harassment: The Vishaka guidelines established in 1997 aimed to protect women from workplace harassment, leading to the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2013, which mandates the formation of Internal Complaints Committees (ICC).
      • The report argues that ICCs are inadequate for the film industry due to potential biases and influence from abusers, advocating for an independent government forum to address these issues.

    Lack of registration of crimes vs. Question on the Principle of Survivor Anonymity:

    • Nipun Saxena vs Union Of India (2018): The SC explained the importance of penalization of the disclosure of the name and the identity of the survivors of sexual offenses as mandated in Section 228A of the IPC, which is now reiterated in Sect 72 and 73of the BNS.
      • The provision’s objective is to protect survivors from hostile discrimination and future harassment.
    • Puttaswamy Judgement (2017): The Right to Privacy is integral to the Right to Life under Article 21 of the Constitution. Further, our criminal justice system initiates prosecution against the accused on behalf of the victim but it becomes quite difficult to prove a crime without the victim’s cooperation.
    • Right to Livelihood: Survivors fear potential retaliation from the abuser and the rest of society, in terms of refusal to give them work, and being branded as ‘problem-makers’.
    CASE STUDY – #MeToo Movement:The accusations against Harvey Weinstein in 2017 sparked the global #MeToo movement, highlighting issues of sexual harassment and assault in various industries.

    Need for Structural Reforms:

    • Acknowledgment of Challenges: The report aims to empower Indian women by raising awareness about workplace discrimination.
      • The findings in the Hema Committee report should lead to significant structural reforms in the Malayalam film industry, with government leadership being crucial.
    • Comprehensive Solutions Required: Issues such as inadequate sanitation and workplace bias must be thoroughly studied and addressed to improve conditions for women.
      • The report emphasizes the unique difficulties faced by women in lower-tier roles in the film industry, beyond just lead actresses.

  • How to ensure dignity for the terminally ill?  

    Why in the News?

    The Supreme Court of India denied permission to the parents of Harish Rana, a 32-year-old man in a vegetative state for 11 years, to remove his Ryles tube which is a device used for feeding.

    • A Ryles tube, also known as a nasogastric (NG) tube, is a medical device used for various purposes related to nutrition and gastric management. It is inserted through the nose, passing through the nasal cavity, down the esophagus, and into the stomach.

    Recent Supreme Court Judgment:

    • The Bench headed by CJI D.Y. Chandrachud observed that the Ryles tube is not a life support system and therefore could not be withdrawn.
    • This decision has stirred legal and ethical debates, as the Supreme Court’s 2018 judgment permits the withdrawal of life support in terminal cases under the concept of “passive euthanasia.”
    • Passive euthanasia involves the withdrawal of medical treatment with the intention of hastening the death of a terminally ill patient. 
    • The Supreme Court initially legalized this practice in 2018, allowing patients to create a “living will” to refuse life-sustaining treatment when they are unable to communicate their wishes.

    Ethical Challenges:

    • Question of whether the decision benefits the patient: The judgment raises concerns about whether the decision benefits the patient, as prolonging life in such a condition may increase suffering.
    • Prolonged suffering: The principle of not causing harm is challenged since keeping the patient in a vegetative state with artificial feeding may lead to prolonged suffering for both the patient and their caregivers.
    • Against Right to Life and Death: The patient’s rights to a dignified life and death may be compromised which is addressed in various judgments like Common Cause v. Union of India (2018). This judgment recognised the right to die with dignity as part of the right to life under Article 21.
    • Autonomy: The patient’s right to choose, which is central to the concept of dignity, has been overlooked. The judgment did not consider the wishes of the patient or their family in determining the course of action.

    Need for Legal Clarity:

    • Distinguishing Euthanasia from Withdrawal of Life Support: There is a pressing need to legally clarify the difference between euthanasia and the withdrawal of futile life-sustaining interventions.  
    • Involvement of Medical and Ethical Experts: The decision-making process in such sensitive cases should involve palliative care physicians and ethical experts to ensure that medical and ethical considerations are fully addressed.
    • Advance Care Planning: Promoting Advance Medical Directives and Advance Care Planning is crucial to empower individuals to have control over their end-of-life decisions, ensuring that their rights to a good quality of life and death are respected.
    • Systemic Reforms: The judgment highlights the need for systemic reforms to avoid forcing families into legal battles and to ensure that patients’ rights are safeguarded with appropriate legal frameworks.

    Conclusion: The recent Supreme Court judgment highlights the urgent need for legal clarity, ethical considerations, and systemic reforms to protect patient rights and ensure dignity in end-of-life decisions.

    Mains question for practice:

    Q Discuss the need for legal clarity and systemic reforms to uphold the dignity and rights of patients in end-of-life decisions. (150 words) 10M

  • The tyranny of inequality  

    Why in the News?

    A recent study by Thomas Piketty and colleagues highlights a dramatic rise in wealth and income inequality in India over the past few decades, with a sharp increase particularly from 2014 to 2022.

    The analysis from ” Gallup World Poll (GWP) Survey (2019-23)” for India  

    Note: The GWP measures corruption through individual perceptions, asking respondents whether they believe corruption is widespread.
    • Income Inequality: The survey data indicates a significant rise in income inequality, with the top 1% controlling over 40% of total wealth in India, a stark increase from 12.5% in 1980.
      • The top 1% of income earners now receive 22.6% of the country’s total pre-tax income, up from 7.3% in 1980.
    • Rent-Seeking Behavior: The persistence of rent-seeking behavior among wealthy investors, which diverts resources from productive uses to securing unwarranted gains from government entities.
    • Judicial Trust and Corruption: Trust in the judiciary can play a significant role in curbing corruption. Higher trust correlates with lower perceived corruption levels.
    • Mutual Fund vs Fixed deposits: Speculative investments, such as mutual funds, largely drive income inequality, while savings in fixed deposits and post offices help curb it.
    • Inequality promotes corruption: The study finds that higher income inequality causes widespread corruption, while greater confidence in the judiciary helps reduce it.

    What is our present methodology for counting inequality?

    • Piketty’s Measure: Thomas Piketty’s measure compares the income share of the top 1% to that of the bottom 50%. This highlights the growing disparity in income distribution effectively.
    • Consumption vs Income Inequality: Inequality is traditionally measured using consumption expenditure surveys by the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO). However, consumption inequality tends to be lower than income inequality.
    • Use of Multiple Data Sources: Researchers often combine data from various sources, including national accounts, tax data, and recent surveys like the Periodic Labour Force Surveys (PLFS) and Consumer Pyramid Household Survey (CPHS).
    • Gini Index and Other Metrics: The Gini index is frequently used to quantify inequality, but it has limitations, being less sensitive to changes at the income distribution extremes.

    Issues Associated with measuring income inequality:

    • Data quality and availability: There has been a noted decline in the reliability of household surveys since 2011-12, making it difficult to obtain accurate and comparable data. For example, The 55th NSS round showed a dramatic decline in poverty estimates, which many experts deemed misleading due to the survey’s methodological flaws.
    • Underreporting of wealth: Surveys may underreport wealthier households’ consumption, leading to inaccurate inequality assessments. For example, the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) 2022-23 reported a significant drop in rural and urban poverty levels. However, critics argue that these figures may not accurately reflect the reality of wealthier households
    • Comparability with other countries: India’s reliance on consumption data rather than income data can result in mischaracterization as a low-inequality country in international comparisons.
    • Focus on labor income: Some reports focus only on labor income, ignoring other income sources and skewing the understanding of overall inequality. For example, studies have shown that the income share of the top 10% in India has grown significantly, while labour income alone does not reflect this concentration adequately
    • Complexity of income dynamics: Accurately assessing inequality is challenging due to the influence of economic policies, globalization, and market forces. For instance, Researchers have noted that the absence of comprehensive tax data beyond 2017-18 adds uncertainty to the analysis of income inequality trends

    Way forward: 

    • Improve Data Collection and Methodologies: There is an urgent need to enhance the quality and reliability of household surveys and other data sources.
    • Broadening Income Metrics Beyond Labor Income: To better capture the full spectrum of income inequality, it’s essential to include non-labor income sources, such as capital gains, property income, and speculative investments.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q It is argued that the strategy of inclusive growth is intended to meet the objective of inclusiveness and sustainability together. Comment on this statement. (UPSC IAS/2019)

  • Labor conditions in southern states  

    Why in the News?

    Migrant workers from various parts of India are gradually becoming a noticeable presence in the agricultural fields of Tamil Nadu’s Cauvery delta, often called the granary of South India.

    Migrants in Tamil Nadu’s Cauvery Delta

    • Labour Shortage in Agriculture: The Cauvery Delta, known as the granary of South India, is experiencing a significant shortage of farmhands as the younger generation moves away from agriculture. This has led to a reliance on migrant workers, particularly from states like West Bengal and Bihar, who are skilled in paddy transplanting and harvesting.
    • Economic Dynamics: Migrant labourers are filling the labour gap during agricultural seasons, working in groups and completing tasks more quickly than local labourers. They charge around ₹4,500 to ₹5,000 per acre, compared to local workers who earn ₹600 per day.
    • Sociocultural Integration: While there hasn’t been significant tension between migrant workers and local labourers, the integration of migrants into the agricultural workforce is still evolving.
      • Local labour unions acknowledge the presence of migrant workers but do not see it as a widespread issue yet, partly due to the ongoing mechanization of agriculture and changing job preferences among the local youth.

    Dependence on Migrant Workers in Kerala

    • Shift in Labor Sources: Kerala has seen a growing dependence on migrant workers from northern and eastern states, including West Bengal and Bihar, to fill labour shortages in various sectors, including agriculture.
      • A recent study by the Gulati Institute of Finance and Taxation estimated the number of inter-state migrant workers in Kerala at 2.5 million, equivalent to 7% of the state’s population.
    • Economic Factors: High wage differentials between Kerala and the migrants’ home states, along with a robust urban economy, have made Kerala an attractive destination for migrant labourers.

    External Migration from Uttar Pradesh to Maharashtra

    • High Migration Rate: Uttar Pradesh tops the list for inter-state job-related migration to Maharashtra, with over 5.7% of migrants moving for employment purposes between 2020 and 2021.
    • Concentration of Migrants: Within Maharashtra, districts such as Mumbai and Thane have the highest concentrations of migrants from Uttar Pradesh.

    How does the proposed ‘quota-for-local’ Bill impact migrant workers?

    • uction in the already precarious employment options available to migrants, who often fill lower-skilled positions.
    • Increased Competition: The migrant workers might face intensified competition for fewer available roles, particularly in sectors where they have traditionally been employed, such as delivery services and hospitality.
    • Economic Migration: The bill could lead to a demographic shift in the labor market. Migrants may choose to relocate to states with more inclusive hiring practices, impacting the state’s economy and workforce diversity.
    • Exploitation Risks: The present Bill could make migrants more vulnerable to exploitation, as companies may feel less inclined to hire them, leading to further marginalization of these workers.
    • Industry Concerns: Business leaders and industry representatives have expressed concerns that the bill could deter investment and talent from flowing into Karnataka, potentially leading to job losses and reduced economic growth. The focus should be on skills rather than reservations.

    What measures can be taken to protect migrant workers from exploitation?

    • Right to Change Employers: States need to ensure that migrant workers have the freedom to change employers without facing penalties, which can reduce their vulnerability to abuse and exploitation.
    • Empower Migrant workers: The government/ Private sector needs to provide comprehensive information regarding workers’ rights, including recruitment processes, legal protections, and avenues for reporting abuse.
      • Strengthening labor laws and legal assistance with counseling services that protect migrant workers and ensure strict enforcement through regular inspections of workplaces is a need of the hour.
    • Social Security and Housing Access: States need to ensure that migrant workers have access to social services, housing, and healthcare, which can help mitigate their vulnerabilities.
      • NITI Aayog in its report ”India’s Booming Gig and Platform Economy” has said that fiscal incentives such as tax breaks or startup grants may be provided for businesses that provide livelihood opportunities where women constitute a substantial portion of their workers.
    • International Cooperation: Encourage countries to adopt and implement international standards and conventions that protect the rights of migrant workers, promoting safe and ethical recruitment practices.

    Lack of Proper Data and Registration

    • Historical Data Gaps: The last comprehensive survey on internal migration was conducted as part of the National Sample Survey in 2007-08, with the Census 2011 data only partially released in 2020.
    • Absence of Real-Time Data: During the COVID-19 lockdown, the Indian government did not collect data on the deaths or job losses of internal migrants. The Ministry of Labour and Employment confirmed that it maintained no records of migrant workers who lost their jobs or lives during this period.

    Legislation: 

    The Inter-State Migrant Workmen (Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, 1979 was enacted to protect the rights and regulate the conditions of service for migrant workers who move between states in India for employment.

    Implementation Challenges

    • Lack of Awareness: Many migrant workers are unaware of their rights under the Act, leading to exploitation and poor working conditions.
    • Inadequate Enforcement: There is often insufficient enforcement of the Act by state governments, resulting in widespread violations and the continued presence of migrant workers in informal and unregulated sectors.
    • Data Gaps: The absence of accurate data on the number of inter-state migrant workers complicates enforcement and the provision of services.

    Way forward: 

    • Promote Sustainable Employment and Skill Development in Source Regions: To reduce the over-reliance on migrant labour and address labour shortages in sectors like agriculture, the government should focus on creating sustainable employment opportunities in the migrants’ home states.
    • Promote Sustainable Employment and Skill Development in Source Regions: The government should create a real-time migrant data system linked with Aadhaar, enabling targeted policies, social security, and effective crisis response for internal migrants.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q Discuss the changes in the trends of labour migration within and outside India in the last four decades. (UPSC IAS/2015)

  • [16th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed:  An obstinate refusal to focus on welfare

    [16th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed:  An obstinate refusal to focus on welfare

    PYQ Relevance:

    Mains:

    Q. 1 Performance of welfare schemes that are implemented for vulnerable sections is not so effective due to absence of their awareness and active involvement at all stages of policy process. Discuss. (UPSC IAS/2014) 

    Q. 2 Hunger and Poverty are the biggest challenges for good governance in India still today. Evaluate how far successive governments have progressed in dealing with these humongous problems. Suggest measures for improvement. (UPSC IAS/2017) 

    Note4Students: 

    Mains: Underfunding issues related to welfare schemes;

    Mentor comments:  The government’s stubborn refusal to prioritize welfare is baffling, especially in a country where, according to its own data, around 34% of the population survives on less than ₹100 a day, and over 81 crore people depend on free foodgrains to make ends meet. The National Democratic Alliance (NDA) in its current term, NDA 3.0, seems to be perpetuating the trend set in its previous two terms by cutting back on welfare allocations, as evidenced by the analysis below based on Budget documents.

    Let’s learn!

    __

    Why in the News? 

    On the welfare front, the government has once again failed to boost expenditure on crucial welfare schemes that support the country’s marginalized populations.

    Underfunding issues related to welfare schemes:

    • Declining Budget Allocations as per GDP%: Both MGNREGA and NFSA have seen continuous declines in their budget allocations as a share of GDP since 2014-15, with MGNREGA’s allocation dropping from 0.29% to 0.26% and NFSA’s from 0.72% to 0.63%.
      • The combined budget allocation for MGNREGA and NFSA has decreased by 25% since 2014-15, highlighting a long-term trend of underfunding these essential welfare schemes. 
    • Stagnating Real Wages and Increased Demand: With stagnating rural real wages and increased demand for work under MGNREGA, the current budget does not account for the rising number of person-days generated, which increased by 5.74 crore in the first quarter of the financial year.  
    • Neglect of Vulnerable Groups: The National Social Assistance Programme, which provides monetary support to vulnerable groups such as widows, the elderly, and disabled individuals, has not seen any increase in its allocation. Its budget remains stagnant at ₹200 per month for the elderly and ₹300 for widows, despite inflation and the rising cost of living.  
    • Chronic Malnutrition Rates: Over 50% of children under the age of five in India suffer from chronic malnutrition, with anaemia rates in women and children significantly higher than the global average—20% and 15%, respectively.  
    • Declining Budget Allocations: The budget allocation for the Saksham Anganwadi and Poshan 2.0 schemes has decreased by more than 50% since 2014-15, dropping from 0.13% of GDP to 0.06% of GDP. This reduction in funding undermines the effectiveness of these programs aimed at combating child malnutrition and hunger.
    • Mid-Day Meal (MDM) Programme: The MDM programme, which provides meals to about 12 crore children, has also seen its funding halved since 2014-15 as a share of GDP. 
      • Despite its success in improving attendance and nutritional outcomes, the lack of adequate funding limits its potential to address hunger effectively.
    • Education Funding Decline: The share of central expenditure on education (primary and secondary) has declined from 0.37% of GDP in 2014-15 to 0.22% today.  
    • Health Budget Allocation: While the budget allocation for health has seen a slight increase from 0.25% to 0.28% of GDP since 2014-15, this increase is still inadequate given the high out-of-pocket health expenses that push millions into poverty each year.

    What Government can do?

    • Increase Budget Allocations to Meet Actual Needs: The government should significantly increase the budget allocations for welfare schemes such as MGNREGA and NFSA to ensure they meet the actual demand for employment and food security.
      • For instance, allocating at least ₹2 lakh crore for MGNREGA, which is approximately 1% of GDP, would help clear pending dues and provide adequate employment opportunities for rural households. This increase would not only address the immediate needs of the population but also stimulate rural economic growth by enhancing purchasing power and consumption.
    • Implement Targeted Policy Reforms and Monitoring Mechanisms: The need to establish robust monitoring systems to track the effectiveness and utilization of funds allocated to welfare schemes is crucial.
      • The government should implement targeted policy reforms that focus on the specific needs of vulnerable groups, such as widows, the elderly, and disabled individuals, ensuring that their support systems are adequately funded and responsive to inflation and rising living costs.  

    Conclusion: The government must increase budget allocations for welfare schemes and implement targeted reforms with effective monitoring to address underfunding, ensuring vulnerable groups receive necessary support amidst rising costs.

  • Freedom from dependence, a new era in health care

    Why in the News?

    India’s healthcare since globalization has improved greatly, and is globally recognized due to skilled professionals, effective policies, and strong institutions which draw patients from over 147 countries.

    Economic implications of being a preferred Medical Destination:

    • Foreign Exchange Savings: India saves billions in foreign exchange as fewer Indians need to travel abroad for advanced medical treatments.
    • Revenue Generation: The influx of international patients generates over $9 billion annually, contributing to economic growth.
    • Job Creation: The medical tourism sector creates employment opportunities in healthcare, hospitality, transportation, and pharmaceuticals.
    • Cost-Effective Treatments: India’s affordable yet high-quality medical services attract patients globally, further boosting the economy.

    What are the challenges? 

    • Shortage of Healthcare Professionals
        • Current Shortage: India is estimated to be short of around 600,000 doctors, leading to a doctor-patient ratio of approximately 0.7 doctors per 1,000 people, which is significantly lower than the World Health Organization’s recommended ratio of 1 doctor per 1,000 people.  
        • Future Demand: By 2030, the demand for healthcare professionals in India is expected to double, driven by an ageing population and the increasing burden of non-communicable diseases.
    • Inadequate Public Healthcare Spending
        • Low Expenditure: As of 2021-22, India’s public healthcare expenditure stood at 2.1% of GDP, which is significantly lower than that of many developed countries, For instance, countries like Japan and France spend about 10% of their GDP on healthcare, while the United States spends 16.9%.
        • Comparison with Neighbors: Even neighbouring countries like Bangladesh and Pakistan allocate over 3% of their GDP to public healthcare.
    • Unequal Access to Healthcare
        • Urban-Rural Disparity: There is a stark disparity in healthcare access between urban and rural areas. Rural regions often lack basic healthcare facilities, leading to limited access to quality services for a significant portion of the population.  
        • Healthcare Infrastructure: India’s healthcare infrastructure is inadequate to meet the growing demands of its population. For instance, India has one of the lowest per capita bed counts in the world, with only about 0.5 hospital beds per 1,000 people, compared to the OECD average of 4.7 beds per 1,000 people.
    • High Out-of-Pocket Expenditure
      • Financial Burden: Approximately 75% of healthcare expenditure in India is borne out-of-pocket by individuals and families.

    Need for a Strong Vision (Way forward)

    • “Heal in India” Initiative: The Prime Minister’s vision of “Heal in India” emphasizes positioning India as a global healthcare leader. This initiative is not merely a slogan but a strategic approach to enhance India’s reputation as a preferred medical destination.
    • Youth Engagement: Inspiring the youth to pursue careers in healthcare is crucial for sustaining growth in this sector. By encouraging innovation and entrepreneurship among young Indians, the country can ensure a robust healthcare system.
    • Investment in Public Healthcare: Increase public healthcare spending to improve infrastructure, especially in rural areas, and bridge the urban-rural disparity.
    • Focus on Medical Device Manufacturing: Promote domestic production of medical devices under the “Make in India” initiative to reduce dependency on imports.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q Appropriate local community-level healthcare intervention is a prerequisite to achieve ‘Health for All’ in India. Explain. (UPSC IAS/2018)

  • [10th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Refugee rights, the gendered nature of displacement

    [10th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Refugee rights, the gendered nature of displacement

    PYQ Relevance:

    Mains:

    Q1 “Refugees should not be turned back to the country where they would face persecution or human right violation”. Examine the statement with reference to ethical dimension being violated by the nation claiming to be democratic with open society.  (UPSC IAS/2021) 

    Q2 Cross-border movement of insurgents is only one of the several security challenges facing the policing of the border in North-East India. Examine the various challenges currently emanating across the India-Myanmar border. Also, discuss the steps to counter the challenges. (UPSC IAS/2019) 

    Note4Students: 

    Mains: Conventions and Rights;

    Mentor comments:  By the end of June 2023, 110 million people worldwide were forcibly displaced due to persecution, conflict, violence, and severe disruptions to public order. This included 36.4 million refugees (30.5 million under UNHCR and 5.94 million Palestine refugees under UNRWA), 62.1 million internally displaced persons, 6.08 million asylum seekers, and 5.6 million Venezuelans needing protection. Additionally, millions of stateless individuals lack nationality and basic rights. In the first half of 2023, 90% of new displacements arose from major crises in Afghanistan, the DRC, Latin America, Myanmar, Somalia, Sudan, and Ukraine.

    Let’s learn!

    __

    Why in the News? 

    Armed conflict, violence, human rights abuses, and persecution force millions globally to escape their homes and homelands, resulting in their status as ‘displaced people’.

    Challenges Faced by Female Refugee 

    • India as a Refugee-Receiving Nation: India has hosted over 200,000 diverse refugee groups since independence. As of January 31, 2022, 46,000 refugees and asylum-seekers were registered with UNHCR India, with 46% being women and girls.
    • Gendered Responsibilities: Women and girls in refugee populations are disproportionately burdened with caregiving responsibilities for children, the elderly, and family sustenance. They are often the last to flee conflict zones, carrying the additional responsibility of managing family survival.
    • Impact on Physical and Mental Health: The gendered nature of displacement severely impacts the physical and mental well-being of refugee women. They face numerous stressors, including the loss of partners and children, hardships of camp life, altered family dynamics, and reduced safety.
    • Increased Risk of Gender-Based Abuse: Refugee women are exposed to heightened risks of gender-based violence, including transactional sex, due to prolonged conflict, disrupted social support systems, and socio-economic challenges.
    • Psychological and Psychosocial Conditions: Displaced women are particularly susceptible to psychological disorders such as PTSD, anxiety, and depression. They are twice as likely to experience PTSD and four times more likely to suffer from depression compared to male counterparts. For example, a study in Darfur, Sudan, found 72% of displaced women affected by PTSD and distress.

    Conventions and Rights  

    • UNCRPD Recognition:
      • The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) recognizes ‘psychosocial disability’ as long-term mental or intellectual impairments that hinder full participation in society.
      • Article 6 of the UNCRPD mandates protection against multiple discrimination faced by women and girls with disabilities and ensures their full enjoyment of human rights.
    • India’s Ratification and Legislation:
      • India ratified the UNCRPD and enacted the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 (RPWDA).
      • While the term ‘psychosocial disability’ is not explicitly used in Indian law, “mental illness” is recognized and covered under the RPWDA.
      • The RPWDA guarantees various rights to persons with disabilities, including the right to health care (Section 25) and equal rights for women with disabilities (Section 4).
    • Absence of Legal Framework: India is not a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol. There is no specific domestic legislation addressing refugees, particularly those with disabilities.
    • Right to Life and Health: The Supreme Court of India has upheld the right to life under Article 21, which includes the right to health, for refugees.

    Way forward: 

    • Enact Comprehensive Legislation: Need to introduce a uniform legal framework that specifically addresses the rights and protections of refugees, with provisions for those with disabilities, aligning with international commitments like the 2030 Agenda.
    • Inclusive Policy Implementation: The government should integrate refugees with disabilities into existing and new national policies and programs, ensuring accessible services and participation in decision-making processes.

  • Counting the ‘poor’ having nutritional deficiency       

    Why in the news?

    The National Sample Survey Office has released the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) report for 2022-23, along with public access to unit-level data on household expenditures.

    What does the recent NSSO Report tell us?

    • The report utilizes various definitions of poverty established by past committees, with the poverty line (PL) being anchored to calorie norms of 2,400 kcal for rural and 2,100 kcal for urban areas as per the Lakdawala Committee. The Rangarajan Committee’s approach considers broader normative levels, including non-food expenses.
    • The average per capita calorie requirement (PCCR) is estimated at 2,172 kcal for rural and 2,135 kcal for urban populations. The report highlights that the average per capita calorie intake (PCCI) for the poorest segments falls significantly below these requirements, indicating nutritional deficiencies.
    • The total monthly per capita consumption expenditure (MPCE) thresholds are set at ₹2,197 for rural and ₹3,077 for urban areas, with proportions of the population identified as ‘poor’ being 17.1% in rural and 14% in urban contexts. If non-food expenditures for the poorest 10% are considered, these thresholds rise, increasing the proportion of the deprived.

    Approach for measurement is the Issue:

    • Defining Poverty: The report defines the poor based on MPCE, which is linked to the ability to purchase essential food and non-food items.
      • The reliance on MPCE does not adequately address nutritional needs. While the poverty line is linked to the ability to purchase food and non-food items.
    • Caloric Requirement Calculation: The PCCR is derived from the ICMR-National Institute of Nutrition’s latest recommendations, weighted by the population distribution across age-sex-activity categories.
      • The ICMR-National Institute of Nutrition’s (ICMR-NIN) recommendations for caloric requirements in India are derived from the Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDA) for Indians.
      • The RDA does not adequately account for regional and cultural differences in dietary habits and food availability.
    • Fractile Class Analysis: Households are categorized into 20 fractile classes based on MPCE, allowing for the calculation of average PCCI and MPCE for each class.
      • Each fractile class represents 5% of the population, allowing for a detailed understanding of expenditure distribution and nutritional intake variations within the population
      • MPCE reflects consumption patterns but does not capture the full spectrum of economic well-being or deprivation.
    • State-Specific Adjustments: The all-India thresholds are adjusted for regional price differences to derive state-specific MPCE thresholds.
      • The methodology for deriving state-specific MPCE thresholds relies on regional price indexes, which can vary significantly in their construction and accuracy.

    Recommendations for Improving Nutritional Levels (Way Forward) 

    • Nutritional Schemes: Govt. needs to develop and expand schemes specifically aimed at improving the nutritional intake of the poorest households.
    • Awareness and Education: Govt. should increase awareness about nutrition and healthy eating practices among low-income households.
    • Subsidized Food Programs: Need to enhance access to subsidised food items to ensure that households can meet their caloric and nutritional needs.
    • Monitoring and evaluation: Govt. should establish robust mechanisms to monitor the effectiveness of nutritional interventions and adjust strategies as necessary.

    Conclusion: ​​The NSSO HCES 2022-23 report reveals significant nutritional deficiencies among the poorest. To align with SDG goals, expanding targeted nutritional schemes, subsidized food programs, and robust monitoring is essential.

    Mains PYQ: 

    Q How far do you agree with the view that the focus on the lack of availability of food as the main cause of hunger takes the attention away from ineffective human development policies in India? (2013)

  • [6th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The social benefits of stock market speculation

    [6th August 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The social benefits of stock market speculation

    PYQ Relevance:

    Mains:

    Q1 Comment on the important changes introduced in respect of the Long-term Capital Gains Tax (LCGT) and Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT) in the Union Budget for 2018-2019. (UPSC IAS/2018) 

    Q2 Distinguish between Capital Budget and Revenue Budget. Explain the components of both these Budgets. (UPSC IAS/2021) 

    Prelims: 

    Under which of the following circumstances may ‘capital gains’ arise? (2012)
    1. When there is an increase in the sales of a product 
    2. When there is a natural increase in the value of the property owned 
    3. When you purchase a painting and there is a growth in its value due to an increase in its popularity 
    Select the correct answer using the codes given below: 
    (a) 1 only 
    (b) 2 and 3 only 
    (c) 2 only 
    (d) 1, 2 and 3

    Note4Students: 

    Prelims: Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG) and Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG);

    Mains: Impact of gambling instincts on the stock market;

    Mentor comments: In India, capital gains are classified into two categories based on the holding period of assets. Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG) apply to assets held for 12 months or less, taxed at a rate of 15% for listed equity shares. In contrast, Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) are applicable when assets are held for more than 12 months, taxed at 10% for gains exceeding ₹1 lakh, with no indexation benefits. This framework encourages long-term investment while imposing higher tax rates on short-term trading activities.

    Let’s learn!

    __

    Why in the News? 

    The Indian government has increased taxes on both short-term and long-term capital gains from stock market investments in its latest Budget, along with raising the securities transaction tax on derivatives trading.

    How capital gains occur

    Definition of Capital Gains: Capital gains are profits earned from the sale of an asset that has increased in value over the holding period. This occurs when the selling price exceeds the original purchase price.
    • Market Dynamics: In a perfect market where future cash flows are accurately forecasted, capital gains would not exist, as assets would be bought and sold at their fair value. However, in reality, uncertainty leads to mispricing, allowing investors to buy undervalued assets and realize gains when their true value is recognized.
    • Investor Behavior: Investors who allocate capital efficiently into undervalued businesses can earn capital gains when others recognize the fair value of those businesses. Conversely, those who misallocate capital into overvalued assets may incur capital losses.
    • Economic Implications: Efficient capital allocation is crucial for economic prosperity. Misallocation, such as investing in sectors with low demand (e.g., cruise ships during a pandemic), can lead to overall economic inefficiency and resource wastage.
    • Taxation and Incentives: A uniform tax on capital gains may help mitigate resource misallocation, but it can also impact private investment incentives and overall economic growth.  

    Impact of gambling instincts on the stock market

    • Increased Retail Participation: The Economic Survey 2023-24 highlights that the surge in retail investor participation in Futures and Options (F&O) trading is largely driven by inherent “gambling instincts.” 
      • This is evidenced by the rapid growth in trading volumes, with retail traders’ share in derivatives trading rising from 2% in 2018 to 41% in 2024.
    • Potential for High Returns: Derivatives trading offers the allure of outsized gains, which appeals to investors seeking quick profits.  
    • High Risk of Losses: Despite the appeal of quick profits, the reality is stark; a study by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) found that 89% of individual traders in the equity F&O segment suffered losses, with average losses of ₹1.1 lakh in FY22.  

    Gambling instincts are worse for derivatives

    • Complexity and Misunderstanding: Derivatives are often misunderstood due to their complexity. This lack of understanding leads to a negative perception because many do not grasp their practical benefits and risk management functions.
    • Speculative Nature: The speculative aspect of derivatives trading can resemble gambling, especially when neither party intends to buy or sell the underlying asset. This speculative behaviour is seen as risky and irresponsible, contributing to the negative reputation of derivatives.
    • Risk Transfer: Derivatives allow for the transfer of risk from one group of investors to another. While this risk management is beneficial, the perception that some investors profit from others’ risk aversion can be seen as exploitative or opportunistic.
    • Market Impact: Just as with active trading in the cash market, speculative trading in derivatives can be socially beneficial by providing liquidity and risk management tools. However, the public often overlooks these benefits and focuses on the perceived destabilizing effects and the potential for large, rapid losses, which can harm individual investors and financial markets.

    Way forward: 

    • Investor Education: Need to implement comprehensive educational programs for investors to improve their understanding of derivatives and capital markets.  
    • Transparency in Trading: Need to increase transparency in derivatives markets by requiring more detailed disclosures about trading strategies, potential risks, and the impact of speculative trades.  

  • The issue of institutional violence, addressing it   

    Why in the News?

    India’s election had 642 million voters, mostly women, but few candidates focused on women’s safety, failing to address the pervasive institutional violence that millions of survivors endure daily.

    Gender-based Violence: Prolonged and Institutional 

    • Judicial and Police Challenges: A significant barrier to justice is the perception among police officers that complaints of gender-based violence are often baseless as per the report published in 2019 by J-PAL, a global policy think tank.
      • Survivors frequently encounter a judicial process that is lengthy and traumatizing, which perpetuates a cycle of violence and silence.
    • Silence Among Survivors: Many women endure violence in silence due to societal stigma and fear of further victimization. 
      • National Crime Records Bureau reported 405,861 cases of crimes against women in 2021, including 32,033 cases of rape. However, these figures are believed to represent only a fraction of the actual incidents due to underreporting driven by societal stigma and fear of retaliation

    Problems in Rural India

    • Caste and Gender Dynamics: In rural areas, the dominance of male and upper-caste individuals in local governance (panchayats) creates additional barriers for women seeking justice.
      • The socio-cultural norms often discourage women from reporting violence, as divorce and legal recourse are rarely options available to them.
    • Access to Justice: The backlog of court cases (estimated at 40 million) disproportionately affects survivors from marginalized communities, making it even more difficult for them to seek redress.

    Strong laws: 

    • The Dowry Prohibition Act 1961: Made giving and receiving dowry a crime
    • The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2013: Introduced new offences like stalking, voyeurism, and acid attacks
    • The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act 2005: Defines domestic violence and provides legal recourse for survivors.

    Issue of Weak Implementation of Law: 

    • Ineffective Enforcement: Despite having strong laws, the enforcement is often inadequate. For example, there are approximately 40 million pending court cases in India, leading to significant delays in justice.
    • Corruption and Indifference: Corruption within law enforcement and the judiciary hampers the implementation of laws. Police officials may exhibit insensitivity towards marginalized communities, leading to a lack of trust in the system.
    • Administrative Fragmentation: The structure of local governance, particularly through panchayats, is often disempowered and fragmented. This limits their capacity to address local issues effectively, as they lack the necessary funds and authority to implement programs that meet community needs.
    • Lack of Coordination: Multiple departmental organizations operate separately, leading to a lack of coordinated action.
      • For instance, local officials may be unable to address pressing community issues due to rigid departmental mandates that do not align with the actual needs of the population.
    • Inadequate Resources and Training: Many implementing organizations suffer from inadequate staffing and lack of expertise.
      • For example, while there may be a sufficient number of government personnel, they often lack the necessary training and resources to execute their duties effectively.
    • Cultural and Societal Barriers: Societal attitudes and stigma surrounding issues like gender-based violence can lead to underreporting and a reluctance to seek help.

    Way forward: 

    • Enhance Law Enforcement Training: Need to implement comprehensive training programs for police and judicial personnel focused on gender sensitivity, trauma-informed responses, and the legal rights of survivors.
    • Empower Local Communities: Engage community leaders and organizations to create support networks for survivors of gender-based violence. This can include establishing helplines, counseling services, and safe spaces for women to seek help without fear of stigma or retaliation.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q Women empowerment in India needs gender budgeting. What are the requirements and status of gender budgeting in the Indian context? (2016)

  • On doorstep delivery of alcohol       

    Why in the News?

    Delhi, Karnataka, Haryana, Punjab, Tamil Nadu, Goa, and Kerala are considering or have considered allowing doorstep delivery of alcohol through platforms such as Swiggy, BigBasket, and Zomato.

    Arguments in favour of Online Delivery of Alcohol:

    • Revenue Generation: Excise taxes on alcohol sales can help generate significant revenue for Central and State governments.
    • Reduce Drunk-Driving Incidents: Doorstep delivery can potentially reduce drunk-driving incidents and prevent road traffic crashes and injuries.
    • Access and Safety for Women:  Doorstep delivery may reduce on-premise violence against women and allow women to access alcohol without facing social stigma.

    Arguments against Online Delivery of Alcohol:

    • Economic Costs vs. Benefits: The costs due to alcohol use often exceed the economic benefits from alcohol sales.
    • Increased Consumption and Binge Drinking: The availability of alcohol on-demand can increase consumption, promote binge drinking, and lead to alcohol-related harms.
    • Public Health Concerns: Alcohol is associated with various health risks including cancers, mental illnesses, liver disease, and increased risk of inter-partner violence.

    Consumption of Liquor in India:

    • India is the sixth-largest alcohol market worldwide with $52 billion in revenue.
    • Per capita alcohol consumption has increased from 1.6 litres in 2003-2005 to 5.5 litres in 2016-2018.
    • According to a 2019 survey, there were about 16 crore alcohol users in India in 2018.
    • Of these, 5.7 crore frequently consumed alcohol leading to social or interpersonal problems, and 2.9 crore were dependent users requiring therapeutic intervention.

    Can such a system make it safer for women to access alcohol?

    • Doorstep delivery may help women access alcohol without dealing with social stigma.
    • There is some evidence that it could reduce on-premise violence against women, as seen in Kerala. However, domestic violence related to alcohol use is rampant, and the overall safety of women cannot be presumed.

    How should governments regulate liquor consumption? (Way forward)

    • Restrict Availability and Marketing: Implement policies to limit the availability and marketing of alcohol.
    • Higher Taxes: Increase taxes on alcohol to deter consumption and generate revenue.
    • Enforce Drunk-Driving Laws: Strengthen the enforcement of drunk-driving laws with stringent penalties.
    • Invest in Treatment Programs: Allocate funds for psychosocial treatments of alcohol-use disorders and mental health initiatives.
    • Monitor and Evaluate Impact: Governments should work with health departments to monitor and evaluate the impact of doorstep delivery on alcohol consumption and revise policies if necessary.
    • Uniform Policy Standards: Develop more uniform policy standards and ensure better implementation grounded in public health priorities over revenue generation.

    Mains question for practice:

    Q Analyze the trends in alcohol consumption in India over the past two decades. How has this trend impacted public health and social dynamics? 10M