Civilsdaily

Subject: Indian Society

  • [16th October 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Food access is about equitable agrifood systems

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q) Elaborate the policy taken by the Government of India to meet the challenges of the food processing sector. (UPSC CSE 2019)

    Q) What are the reformative steps taken by the Government to make the food grain distribution system more effective? (UPSC CSE 2019)

    Q) What are the challenges and opportunities of the food processing sector in the country? How can the income of the farmers be substantially increased by encouraging food processing? (UPSC CSE 2020)

    Mentor’s Comment: Food security in India faces several critical issues that affect the availability, accessibility, and quality of food for its population. A significant portion of India’s population lives below the poverty line, limiting their access to nutritious food. Despite high agricultural production, unequal distribution means that many people do not receive adequate food, leading to malnutrition and hunger.

    While food availability has improved, there is a growing concern regarding the nutritional quality of food in upcoming years. Many people suffer from “hidden hunger,” lacking essential vitamins and minerals despite sufficient caloric intake. The increasing population pressures food resources, making it challenging to ensure that everyone has access to adequate nutrition.

    Addressing these challenges requires a multi-faceted approach involving policy reforms, improved agricultural practices, and enhanced social safety nets to ensure equitable access to food across all segments of society.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    The theme for this year’s World Food Day (16th Oct 2024) is “Right to Foods for a better life and a better future,” emphasizing the importance of equitable access to safe, nutritious, and affordable food.

    • This initiative is supported by the FAO, IFAD, and WFP in collaboration with the Government of India, highlighting the urgent need to address food insecurity affecting 733 million people globally.

    What is Equitable Agrifood Systems?

    Equitable agrifood systems are defined as those that not only ensure food security but also promote social equity among various stakeholders involved in the food supply chain.

    • Food access is a critical aspect of equitable agrifood systems, which aim to address food inequality and ensure that all individuals have sufficient access to nutritious food.

    These systems are characterized by:

    • Sustainability: They contribute to the sustainable management of natural resources while ensuring economic opportunities for all actors within the agri-food sector.
    • Social Equity: They aim to provide equal access to resources, addressing disparities related to gender, ethnicity, and socio-economic status.
    • Nutritional Security: They focus on delivering adequate nutrition to all populations, combating issues like malnutrition and hunger.

    Challenges in achieving Equitable Food Access

    • Current System Limitations: Existing agrifood systems often fail to provide adequate food security and equitable distribution, leading to simultaneous issues of hunger and overconsumption, known as the “triple burden of malnutrition”.
    • Investment Priorities: Most investments in agrifood systems prioritize production over social or environmental objectives, which limits progress toward equity.
    • Research Gaps: There are significant gaps in research focused on social equity outcomes within food systems. This lack of targeted research contributes to the marginalization of critical issues such as health, nutrition, and the needs of vulnerable populations like women and youth.

    What are the different strategies for building Equitable Agrifood Systems?

    • Integrated Approaches: Transforming food systems requires integrated actions across sectors and levels of governance. This includes aligning agricultural practices with climate action initiatives to build resilience against environmental changes.
    • Policy Design: Policymakers must design inclusive policies that consider the impacts on gender and youth inequalities within agrifood systems. Monitoring these impacts is essential for ensuring equitable outcomes.
    • Engagement of Diverse Voices: Effective transformation necessitates the inclusion of diverse stakeholders—scientists, policymakers, farmers, women, youth, and Indigenous peoples—in decision-making processes. Their insights can help shape more responsive and equitable policies.

    What role do sustainability and innovation play in promoting equitable agrifood systems?

    • Digital Technologies: Leveraging digital innovations can enhance access to information and resources for marginalized communities, improving their participation in agrifood systems.
    • Collaborative Research: Engaging multiple stakeholders in research efforts can help identify best practices and innovative solutions tailored to local contexts.

    Conclusion: Achieving the SDG 2- “Zero Hunger” goal requires a multifaceted approach that addresses systemic inequities while promoting sustainability and resilience. By prioritizing social equity in policy design we can create a more just and sustainable future for all individuals within the global food system.

  • A blueprint for safeguarding children

    Why in the News?

    A recent Supreme Court ruling redefines the act of watching and downloading child pornography as a serious crime, rather than merely an adult indulgence.

    Effectiveness of Existing Laws:

    • Expansion of Legal Scope: The Supreme Court ruling corrected the limited interpretation of the Madras High Court by making downloading and storage of Child Sexual Exploitative and Abuse Material (CSEAM) a crime under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act. This strengthens the legal framework for child protection.
    • Shift in Terminology: The judgment reframed “child porn” as CSEAM, emphasizing that it is a severe crime rather than an “adult indulgence,” thereby acknowledging the harm caused to children.
    • Mandating Responsibilities for Intermediaries: The court placed stringent obligations on social media platforms to report CSEAM content to authorities in real-time, ensuring compliance with Indian law.

    What new measures will be implemented to enhance Child Safety?

    • Cybercrime as an Organized Crime: Explicitly defining cybercrimes involving CSEAM as economic and organized crimes in Indian law, including outlawing emerging offenses like AI-generated child sexual abuse content.
    • Forensic Lab Establishment: A domestic forensic lab equipped with advanced technology will be set up to handle CSEAM cases, enabling faster response times to flagged content and coordination with law enforcement agencies.
    • National Database on Sexual Offenders: Ensuring that individuals prosecuted for possession or sharing of CSEAM are added to a database and prohibited from employment in child-related sectors.

    Collaboration among Stakeholders:

    • Real-Time Reporting by Social Media Platforms: The judgment mandates social media companies and intermediaries to report instances of CSEAM to law enforcement immediately, facilitating rapid intervention.
    • International Cooperation: Calls for the establishment of an International Database of Sex Offenders to strengthen cross-border coordination in tracking offenders. This includes working with international agencies like Interpol to streamline efforts.
    • Role of Financial Institutions: Leveraging financial institutions to trace and disrupt the financial transactions that support networks involved in child exploitation.

    Educational Initiatives:

    • Awareness Programs on Digital Safety: Launching campaigns to educate parents, children, and communities about the dangers of online child exploitation and methods for protecting themselves.
    • Training for Law Enforcement and Judiciary: Providing specialized training to authorities on identifying and prosecuting CSEAM cases, including the use of AI in the creation of exploitative material.
    • School-Based Programs: Implementing programs in schools to teach children about safe online behavior and recognise signs of potential exploitation.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthen Legal and Technological Frameworks: Update laws to explicitly classify CSEAM-related cybercrimes as organized crimes and establish a state-of-the-art forensic lab for swift case handling and coordination with global agencies.
    • Enhance Prevention and Awareness Initiatives: Implement nationwide digital safety education for children, parents, and authorities, while bolstering collaboration with international bodies and financial institutions to dismantle exploitation networks.

  • [14th October 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: A critical message for the urban elite

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q) “Access to affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy is the sine qua non to achieve Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)”.Comment on the progress made in India in this regard. (UPSC CSE 2018)

    Q) Discussion the various social problems which originated out of the speedy process of urbanization in India.(UPSC CSE 2014)

    Q) To what extent has the urban planning and culture of the Indus Valley Civilization provided inputs to the present-day urbanization? Discuss. (UPSC CSE 2013)

    Mentor’s Comment: The SDG 11 for sustainable cities addresses the challenges of urbanization and aims to ensure that all urban areas provide equitable opportunities and improved living conditions for their residents.

    Presently, our Indian cities are termed “heat traps” due to unbalanced urban growth, which has led to the depletion of water bodies and increased greenhouse gas emissions. Urban areas are significantly warmer than rural counterparts, exacerbated by concrete and glass structures that retain heat. Studies indicate urban areas can be 5-7°C hotter than surrounding rural areas. Vulnerable groups such as delivery workers, auto drivers, and street vendors face severe consequences from heat exposure, with limited access to hydration and shade.

    Today’s editorial emphasizes the need for the privileged classes to confront the realities of urban life, as their comfort-driven lifestyles, facilitated by technology, contribute to systemic urban issues. 

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    Cities like Delhi that are exceeding 50°C, highlight how poor urban planning disproportionately affects vulnerable groups, who suffer the most from extreme weather conditions.

    • This exacerbates inequalities and diminishes empathy towards those who serve.
    • There is a need for a reconnection with urban environments, urging the elite to leverage their influence to advocate for equitable improvements in living conditions for all.

    How does poor urban planning impact marginalized sections of the urban society?

    • Delivery boys, who navigate city streets to meet the demand for online orders, face relentless heat with little relief.
    • Auto drivers are directly exposed to the scorching heat of the day as they strive to earn a living.
    • Construction workers are forced to work long hours outdoors, enduring the hot sun without adequate shade or hydration.
    • Domestic women workers frequently travel by foot, and street vendors constantly battle the whims of the weather, with their earnings declining as foot traffic reduces due to the heat.

    Other challenges of poor Urban Planning and Technology’s impact

    • Disproportionate Effects: Poor urban planning primarily impacts marginalized communities, while the privileged remain largely unaffected.
    • Technology-Induced Inaction: Comforts of technology, like air conditioning and delivery apps, insulate the elite from urban challenges, reducing their motivation to advocate for change.
    • Reduced Outdoor Engagement: Grocery delivery and ride-hailing apps minimize the need to engage with the urban environment, fostering detachment.
      • The reliance on technology diminishes empathy towards service workers, as interactions are minimized.
    • Comfort Trap: A tech-enabled lifestyle creates a false sense of luxury, leading to greater human domestication and reduced social engagement.
    • Reactive Governance: Urban issues gain attention only when they affect the elite, prompting swift governmental action in affluent areas but neglecting broader community needs.
    • Cycle of Decline: Heat waves and poor conditions drive people indoors, increasing reliance on technology and further deteriorating public services.
    • Aggravated Inequalities: The integration of technology into urban living exacerbates existing inequalities and creates new ones, failing to improve overall quality of life.
    Initiatives taken by the government:

    • Heat Action Plans (HAPs): Cities like Ahmedabad have implemented HAPs that include establishing cooling centers, early warning systems, and public awareness campaigns about heat-related illnesses. 
    Delhi Heat Wave Action Plan focuses on profiling heat hotspots, enhancing healthcare capacity, and developing emergency response protocols.
    • Budgetary Allocations: The Union Budget 2024-25 allocated significant funds for urban transformation projects, including Rs 10,400 crore for the Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation (AMRUT) and Rs 80,761 crore for the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY).

    What needs to be done?

    • Breaking the Comfort Trap: Reconnecting with cities and communities is essential for collective survival, moving beyond a false sense of comfort.
      • The privileged must leverage their influence to engage with governments and improve urban living conditions.
    • Confronting Urban Realities: Acknowledging the true state of urban areas is crucial for rebuilding equitable and livable spaces.
    • Changing Urban Landscape: Increasingly frequent extreme weather events are diminishing public spaces and outdoor activities.
      • Allowing convenience to dictate urban development risks the decline of cities, making them less sustainable for all.

  • International NGOs and the Perils of Outsourcing Development

    Why in the News?

    For many years, International NGOs (INGOs) have promoted donor-driven agendas that have frequently caused harm to local communities.

    Case Study: Africa and Bolivia

    • Tanzania and Kenya (Africa): In these regions, INGO-led conservation efforts, often backed by Western donors, displaced indigenous Maasai communities from their ancestral lands. These interventions were justified as conservation projects but disregarded local rights and livelihoods, leading to social and economic harm for the Maasai.
    • Bolivia (Cochabamba): Water privatization, supported by INGOs and international donors, restricted access to basic water resources, sparking widespread public outcry.
      • The privatization, part of broader neoliberal reforms, was later reversed due to local resistance, revealing the negative effects of donor-driven agendas on essential public services.

    What are the Historical roots of Gender Imbalance? 

    • Colonial Policies: British colonial land reforms in the 18th and 19th centuries, especially among land-owning castes, exacerbated female infanticide due to several socio-economic factors linked to inheritance, property rights, and the structure of agrarian society.
    • Post-Independence Malthusian Fears: Following independence, fears of overpopulation dominated Western perceptions of India, and INGOs, influenced by these Malthusian concerns, promoted population control measures.
    Note: Malthusian concerns originate from the ideas of Thomas Malthus, an 18th-century British scholar. In his 1798 work, An Essay on the Principle of Population, Malthus argued that population growth would outpace food production, leading to widespread famine, disease, and societal collapse.

    Role of INGOs in Worsening Gender Imbalance in India

    • Population Control Focus: INGOs such as the Ford Foundation, Rockefeller Foundation, and Population Council were instrumental in introducing sex-determination technologies, particularly between the 1950s and 1980s, by directing significant funds towards these efforts while sidelining other public health needs.
    • Influence in Institutions: INGOs embedded themselves in key Indian institutions such as AIIMS and the International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS), shaping the direction of research and policy towards population management.
      • For example, Sheldon Segal of the Population Council worked closely with the Indian Health Ministry to prioritize family planning over other pressing health concerns like tuberculosis and malaria.
    • Promotion of Sex Selection: Doctors, influenced by the donor-driven agendas of INGOs, began promoting sex-determination technologies like amniocentesis under the pretext of reducing “unnecessary fecundity.”  

    Impact of Sex Determination Technology

    • Introduction and Spread: Sex determination technologies, such as amniocentesis and ultrasound,  Initially intended for detecting fetal abnormalities, they were quickly co-opted for sex selection, leading to a significant increase in female foeticide.
      • Census data reveals a steady decrease from 943 girls per 1,000 boys in 1951 to 927 girls per 1,000 boys by 1991. The sharpest fall occurred between 1971 and 1991, coinciding with the spread of these technologies.
    • Regional Variations: States with easier access to sex-determination tests, such as Punjab and Haryana, experienced the steepest declines in their child sex ratios.
      • By 2001, Punjab’s ratio had dropped to 876 girls per 1,000 boys, while Haryana’s fell to 861.
    • Missing Girls: A 2006 study published in The Lancet estimated that sex-determination technologies contributed to the loss of 10 million female births in India between 1980 and 2010, with approximately 500,000 female foetuses aborted annually during this period.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthen Legal Enforcement and Awareness: Enforce stricter penalties for illegal sex determination practices and raise public awareness to shift societal norms that value male children over female children, promoting gender equality at all levels.
    • Focus on Holistic Public Health and Gender Policies: Redirect INGO and government efforts toward comprehensive health programs, prioritizing women’s health, education, and economic empowerment, rather than solely focusing on population control.

  • Rise in life expectancy has slowed dramatically: New study

    Why in the News?

    After decades of steady increases in human life expectancy due to advancements in medicine and technology, recent trends suggest that these gains are starting to slow down, according to a new study.

    The Key Findings of the Study:

    • Slowing of Life Expectancy Gains: After decades of rising life expectancy due to medical and technological advancements, the pace of these increases has slowed significantly. The study suggests that human life expectancy has nearly plateaued, with dramatic extensions unlikely without breakthroughs in anti-aging medicine.
    • Regional Analysis: The study analyzed life expectancy data between 1990 and 2019 from regions with the longest life spans, such as Australia, Japan, and Sweden.
      • Even in these regions, life expectancy increased by only 6.5 years on average over the 29-year period.
    • Challenges of Radical Life Extension: Researchers found that while people live longer due to improvements in healthcare, the human body’s aging process—marked by the declining function of internal organs—limits life span. Even if diseases like cancer and heart disease are eliminated, aging itself remains a barrier.
    • Low Probability of Reaching 100: The study estimates that girls born in the longest-living regions have only a 5.3% chance of reaching 100 years, while boys have a 1.8% chance. Thus, despite medical advancements, reaching 100 years remains rare without interventions to slow aging.
    • Aging as the Primary Barrier: Researchers argue that extending average life expectancy dramatically will require breakthroughs that slow the aging process rather than just better treatments for common diseases.
      • Some experimental drugs, like metformin, have shown potential in animal studies, but human trials are needed.

    India’s Present Status:

    • Lower Life Expectancy: As of 2024, India’s average life expectancy is around 70 years, In contrast, countries like Japan and Switzerland boast life expectancies exceeding 83 years.
    • Healthcare Advancements: While India has made significant progress in combating infectious diseases and improving maternal and child health, chronic illnesses and lifestyle diseases (such as heart disease and diabetes) are emerging as leading causes of death.

    What Needs to Be Done: (Way forward) 

    • Focus on Anti-Aging Research: India must invest in research on aging and regenerative medicine, exploring ways to slow down the aging process rather than just treating diseases.
    • Strengthening Healthcare Systems: Expanding access to quality healthcare and preventive medicine to manage age-related diseases can enhance the quality of life in later years, even if life expectancy does not rise dramatically.
    • Policy Support for Longevity Research: There is a need for policies supporting medical research into life-extension technologies, including drug trials and clinical studies focused on aging.
    • Public Health Interventions: Improved public health measures targeting lifestyle diseases (obesity, diabetes) and better management of age-related conditions can enhance life span and overall well-being.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q The increase in life expectancy in the country has led to newer health challenges in the community. What are those challenges and what steps need to be taken to meet them? (UPSC IAS/2022)

  • [10th October 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Mental health in India’s material world

    PYQ Relevance:


    Q). Besides being a moral imperative of a Welfare State, primary health structure is a necessary precondition for sustainable development.” Analyse. (UPSC CSE 2021)

    Q) The public health system has limitations in providing universal health coverage. Do you think that the private sector can help in bridging the gap? What other viable alternatives do you suggest? (UPSC CSE 2015)

    Mentor’s Comment:  In July, a 26-year-old executive from a multinational consulting firm ended her life due to immense work pressures, shedding light on a critical issue affecting millions of working Indians. In September, a 38-year-old software engineer in Chennai also took his life, battling depression caused by work-related stress. 

    Despite outwardly successful careers, these tragic losses highlight India’s growing mental health crisis, where success is often tied to relentless productivity and material wealth. With over 197 million people suffering from mental health disorders, according to the Lancet Psychiatry Commission, India’s economic growth has increased societal pressures, neglecting mental well-being and fostering disconnection from community and self-awareness. In today’s editorial, we will dive more into the causes and impacts of Mental Health in Indian Society.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    This year’s theme for World Mental Health Day (October 10) focuses on ‘prioritizing mental health in the workplace. India faces a mental health crisis driven by urban stress, financial instability, and intense competition.

    Key points related to Mental Health issues as per WHO: 

    • According to WHO, India has a significant burden of mental health issues with 2443 Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALYs) per 100,000 population.
    • India’s age-adjusted suicide rate is 21.1 per 100,000, among the highest globally.
    • The economic loss due to mental health conditions between 2012-2030 is estimated to be USD 1.03 trillion.

    What are the reasons behind the rising stress and anxiety?

    • Mental Health Epidemic: India is facing a growing mental health crisis, with millions suffering from disorders like depression, anxiety, and stress.
    • Pressures of Urban Living: Urban life, financial instability, and intense competition contribute significantly to rising stress.
    • Material Success vs. Well-being: Despite material success, many people feel isolated and disconnected from their communities, leading to a sense of purposelessness.
    • Consumerism and Social Comparison: In urban areas, consumerism fosters a culture where wealth and luxury goods define status, causing feelings of inadequacy and stress.
    • Fear of Insignificance: As per Ernest Becker’s theory, much of human behavior is driven by the fear of impermanence. People chase material wealth for social validation, but this pursuit neglects self-awareness and deeper emotional needs.
    Mental Health Policy and Legal Frameworks by Govt:

    • National Mental Health Policy, 2014: Promotes a rights-based and participatory approach for quality service delivery.
    • Mental Healthcare Act, 2017: Provides a legal framework that aligns with the UNCRPD (United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities), focusing on protecting the rights of individuals with mental illness, decriminalizing suicide, and ensuring access to mental health services.

    Collective Action, Community as Solutions:

    • Shifting focus to Collective Well-being: The emphasis needs to move from individual success to collective well-being. Strong social connections, supportive communities, and meaningful work are critical to mental health.
    • Examples from other Countries: Initiatives like Brazil’s community gardens promote shared responsibilities, fostering a sense of belonging and combating isolation.
    • Value of Community Living: Community living provides a sustainable alternative to individualistic consumerism by promoting shared responsibility and collective purpose, strengthening social support networks, reducing competition, and offering a sense of purpose.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthen Community-Based Mental Health Programs: Focus on building strong social connections and support systems through community-based initiatives, promoting collective well-being over individual competition, and addressing isolation.
    • Enhance Accessibility to Affordable Mental Health Services: Expand access to cost-effective, quality mental health care at the primary health care level, ensuring services are available to all, especially in underserved areas.

  • What is fortified rice? Why did the Centre extend the initiative for its distribution of schemes

    Why in the News?

    On October 9, 2024, the Union Cabinet approved extending the free fortified rice supply under welfare programs until December 2028.

    Why Rice Fortification is needed?

    • Widespread Micronutrient Deficiency: India faces a significant public health challenge with micronutrient deficiencies, particularly iron, Vitamin B12, and folic acid. Anaemia, caused by iron deficiency, is a persistent issue affecting large segments of the population, including children, women, and men.
    • Rice as a Staple Food: Given that 65% of India’s population consumes rice as a staple, it is an ideal vehicle to deliver essential micronutrients to combat these deficiencies, helping improve overall health, productivity, and cognitive development.

    Process of Rice Fortification:

    • Fortified Rice Kernels (FRK): The process involves producing fortified rice kernels that are enriched with essential micronutrients such as Iron, Folic Acid, and Vitamin B12.
    • Blending with Regular Rice: These fortified kernels are then blended with regular rice at a ratio prescribed by FSSAI (Food Safety and Standards Authority of India).
      • Typically, fortified kernels make up 1-2% of the total rice, ensuring consistent delivery of micronutrients without altering the taste or cooking properties of the rice.

    How the Fortification Initiative has fared so far?

    • The rice fortification scheme was implemented in three phases between 2022 and March 2024, with the target of achieving universal coverage in all government schemes by March 2024 successfully met.
    • Fortified rice is now supplied under major welfare programs like the Targeted Public Distribution System (TPDS), Integrated Child Development Service (ICDS), and PM POSHAN in all states and Union Territories.
    • The initiative is fully funded by the central government, highlighting its commitment to tackling malnutrition and ensuring inclusive nutritional security across the country.

    How can food fortification help reduce malnutrition in India?

    • Combats Micronutrient Deficiencies: Fortifying staple foods with essential nutrients like iron and vitamins helps reduce widespread deficiencies that cause anemia and poor health.
    • Wide Reach: Through existing public programs (PDS, ICDS), fortified food reaches vulnerable populations, ensuring consistent nutrient intake for large segments of society.
    • Cost-Effective: It offers a scalable, affordable solution to malnutrition, improving health outcomes without significant changes in diets or eating habits.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthen Monitoring and Quality Control: Implement robust monitoring mechanisms to ensure the consistent quality of fortified rice and its proper distribution across welfare programs to maximize nutritional benefits.
    • Raise Awareness and Promote Consumption: Conduct awareness campaigns to educate the public on the health benefits of fortified rice, ensuring higher acceptance and consistent consumption to address widespread micronutrient deficiencies.

  • What does USCIRF report say about India?

    Why in the News?

    On October 2, the Washington DC-based United States Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) released a country update on India, highlighting what it described as “collapsing conditions for religious freedom.”

    Mandate of the USCIRF

    • Monitoring Religious Freedom: The USCIRF is tasked with monitoring the universal right to freedom of religion or belief (FoRB) in countries outside the U.S. This includes assessing violations based on international human rights standards, particularly Article 18 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
    • Annual Reports: The commission produces annual reports that evaluate religious freedom conditions and recommend countries for designation as “Countries of Particular Concern” (CPC) or for inclusion on the “Special Watch List” (SWL).
    • Policy Recommendations: USCIRF provides policy recommendations to the President, Secretary of State, and Congress regarding actions to address violations of religious freedom.

    How does the UNSCIRF designate a country as a ‘Country of Particular concern’? 

    • Criteria for CPC Designation: A country is designated as a CPC if it engages in or tolerates “systematic, ongoing, and egregious violations” of religious freedom. This includes severe actions such as torture, prolonged detention without charges, and other flagrant denials of basic rights.
    • Recommendation Process: The USCIRF assesses countries based on its findings and recommends those that meet the CPC criteria. The U.S. Secretary of State ultimately decides whether to accept these recommendations and designate countries accordingly.

    How has the Indian government reacted to the report?

    • Rejection of Findings: The Indian government has strongly rejected the USCIRF’s report, labeling it as biased and politically motivated. Officials argue that the commission misrepresents facts regarding religious freedom in India.
    • Defense of Policies: The Ministry of External Affairs stated that India is committed to protecting the rights and freedoms of all its citizens, regardless of their faith, and urged USCIRF to refrain from agenda-driven narratives.

    Way forward: 

    • Engage in Diplomatic Dialogue: India should proactively engage with international bodies like USCIRF to address concerns, clarify its stance, and present factual data on religious freedom, fostering mutual understanding.
    • Strengthen Domestic Protections: India should reinforce legal and institutional frameworks to safeguard minority rights and religious freedoms, ensuring transparent mechanisms to address grievances and counter negative perceptions globally.

  • [8th October 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Unpacking the Centre’s affidavit on marital rape

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q). The soul of new law, Bhartiya Nyay Sanhita (BNS) is Justice, Equality and Impartiality based on Indian culture and ethos. Discuss this in the light of major shift from a doctrine of punishment to justice in the present judicial system. (UPSC CSE 2024)

    Q) Discuss the desirability of greater representation to women in the higher judiciary to ensure diversity, equity and inclusiveness. (UPSC CSE 2021)

    Q) Analyse the distinguishing features of the notion of Right to Equality in the Constitutions of the USA and India. (UPSC CSE 2021)

    Mentor’s Comment:  There have been continuous debates around the Legislative vs. Judicial powers. The present case is also not different. The Supreme Court of India is currently reviewing the constitutionality of the Marital Rape Exception (MRE) under Section 63 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which states that sexual acts by a husband with his wife are not considered rape if the wife is over eighteen.

    The Centre contends that defining criminal offenses is a legislative matter, although the Supreme Court can assess whether the MRE violates Fundamental Rights under the Indian Constitution. This case has sparked significant debate regarding women’s rights and bodily autonomy in India.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    The Supreme Court of India is examining the constitutionality of Section 63, Marital Rape Exception (MRE) in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which exempts husbands from rape charges involving their wives over eighteen.

    • The Centre has filed an affidavit supporting this exception, addressing legal concerns related to Articles 14 and 21, highlighting the ongoing debate over women’s rights and bodily autonomy in India.

    What are the challenges highlighted by the Central government?

    1) The issue of ‘expectation’:

    • The Centre argues that the Marital Rape Exception (MRE) does not violate Article 14 (right to equality) because married and unmarried women are not in the same position.
    • It claims that marriage creates a “continuing expectation of reasonable sexual access,” which justifies distinguishing between non-consensual sex within and outside marriage.
    • The concept of “reasonable sexual access” is criticized as vague, raising questions about who defines it and whether it is subjective or objective.

    2) The issue over Marriage institutions and the misuse of law:

    • The Centre argues that recognizing marital rape as a criminal offense could undermine the sanctity of marriage and lead to false allegations that are hard to disprove.
    • The argument about the potential misuse of marital rape allegations is seen as a distraction, as any criminal offense can be misused, and trials are designed to determine the validity of claims.
    • The Centre emphasizes that various laws like, Sections 354, 498A IPC, and the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act already provide remedies for violations of consent within marriage

    3) The arguments on the Court’s jurisdiction:

    • The Centre claims marital rape is a social issue, arguing it falls outside the Court’s jurisdiction, despite the law regulating many aspects of life.
    • The Centre asserts that Court’s task is to determine if the Marital Rape Exception (MRE) violates Fundamental Rights, not to decide if marital rape should be criminalized.
    • Many arguments in favor of MRE presented by the Centre are seen as lacking strong legal justification.

    What role should Parliament play in addressing marital rape?

    • Consultation with Stakeholders: Engaging in extensive consultations including women’s rights groups, legal experts, and social scientists will help.
      • It needs to Promote awareness about consent and the implications of marital rape to shift societal attitudes and foster a culture that respects women’s rights within marriage.
    • Balancing Rights and Social Norms: Weighing the need for women’s rights and bodily autonomy against traditional views of marriage as an inviolable institution, and ensure that any reforms need to respect both individual rights and societal values.
    • Updating Legal Framework: Reforming existing laws to provide adequate protection for victims of marital abuse without undermining the institution of marriage, ensuring that legal remedies are effective and accessible.
      • Parliament also needs to review current legal provisions to ensure they adequately address violations of consent within marriage.

    Way Forward:

    MRE, being a ‘law’, is subject to Part III of the Constitution of India. In other words, the Court may not be empowered to decide whether marital rape should be a criminal offense or not, but it is very much within the jurisdiction of the Court to determine whether MRE violates a fundamental right and to strike it down if it does.

    Source: https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/unpacking-the-centres-affidavit-on-marital-rape/article68729068.ece

  • India slipped on the Academic Freedom Index (AFI)

    Why in the News?

    India has seen a sharp decline in Academic Freedom Index rankings over the past 10 years.

    About the Academic Freedom Index (AFI):

    Details
    Released by Global Public Policy Institute (GPPi) in collaboration with Scholars at Risk (SAR) and V-Dem Institute (Varieties of Democracy)

    Published as a part of a global time-series dataset (1900-2019)
    Purpose To assess and quantify academic freedom across different countries
    Score Range
    • 0 (complete repression) to 1 (full academic freedom)
    • Scores based on expert surveys and institutional data
    Main Parameters
    • Freedom to Research and Teach
    • Institutional Autonomy
    • Freedom of Academic Exchange and Dissemination
    • Campus Integrity
    • Freedom of Expression for Academics
    • Constitutional Protection of Academic Freedom
    Usage
    • Tracking academic freedom trends
    • Influencing policy
    • Advocating for academic liberty in different countries
    Annual Report Published as part of the “Free to Think” report series by Scholars at Risk

    India’s Performance:

    • India’s academic freedom score dropped from 0.6 points in 2013 to just 0.2 points in 2023, marking a significant deterioration.
    • The report categorizes India as “completely restricted”, the country’s lowest rank since the mid-1940s.
    • This decline is attributed to many factors, including:
    1. Political Influence on Universities
    2. Limitations on Student Protests

    Significance

    • Impact on Democracy: The decline threatens democratic values, as universities, traditionally spaces for free thought and dissent, and are increasingly under political control, limiting student protests and academic expression.
    • International Reputation: India’s shrinking academic freedom could harm its global standing, making it less attractive to international students, scholars, and research collaborations.
    • Long-Term Effects on Education: The politicization of higher education may weaken innovation and critical thinking, hindering economic growth and the development of future leaders and policymakers.

  • How circular migration can help meet global skill shortages and lift Indians out of poverty?

    Why in the News?

    Maharashtra’s 997 youth, earning Rs 1.37 lakh in Israel, engage in circular migration, boosting skills through labour mobility agreements.

    What is the “triple win” scenario associated with circular migration?

    • Migrants win by gaining high-paying jobs, improving their skills, and getting social security benefits while working abroad.
    • The home country (like India) wins because when the workers return, they bring back new skills and experience that help improve local industries.
    • The host country (like Israel or Germany) wins because they get the skilled workers they need to fill labour shortages without facing long-term migration issues.

    How does circular migration contribute to skill development and poverty alleviation for Indian migrants?

    • Skill Development: Indian workers gain exposure to international work environments, cutting-edge technology, and management protocols, which enhance their skills and employability.
    • Poverty Alleviation: Higher wages in developed countries allow migrants to send remittances back home, improving the economic conditions of their families and contributing to poverty alleviation.

    In what way does circular migration mitigate the issue of brain drain?

    • Temporary Nature: Since workers return after a set period (e.g., five years), they bring back their enhanced skills and experience, preventing a permanent loss of talent to foreign nations.
    • Knowledge Transfer: Returning workers contribute to domestic industries by applying the new skills and technologies they learned abroad, benefiting the home economy.

    What are the policy implications for implementing circular migration effectively? (Way forward) 

    • Skill Matching and Training: Governments must ensure exact skill matching between migrant workers and the requirements of the destination countries, providing refresher courses and training as needed.
    • Government-to-Government Agreements: Strong bilateral agreements are essential to safeguard the rights of workers, ensure fair wages, and provide social security in the destination countries.
    • Streamlined Procedures: Policies should simplify legal compliances, fast-track passport issuance, and remove barriers like language skills through training in languages such as Japanese, German, or French.

    Conclusion: Circular migration offers a “triple win” by benefiting migrants, home countries, and host nations. It enhances skills, boosts incomes, mitigates brain drain, and fosters knowledge transfer, provided there is proper policy support, skill matching, and streamlined processes.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q Major cities of India are becoming vulnerable to flood conditions. Discuss. (UPSC IAS/2016)

  • Tribes in news: Chenchu Tribe

    Why in the News?

    • The Chenchu tribe, a particularly vulnerable tribal group (PVTG) in Andhra Pradesh, faces poverty, unemployment, and worsening living conditions due to the discontinuation of a special MGNREGS project.
      • The government launched the MGNREGS Chenchu Special Project in 2009 to address their specific needs, providing 180 days of employment.

    About Chenchu Tribe

    Details
    Location Primarily found in Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Karnataka, and Odisha
    Habitat Sparse and deciduous Nallamala forest, part of the Eastern Ghats
    Language Chenchu language, belonging to the Dravidian language family
    Traditional Livelihood Hunter-gatherers, relying on forest produce like honey, roots, tubers, soapberries, and gum for sustenance
    Role in Tiger Conservation Involved as tiger protection watchers in the Nagarjuna-Srisailam Tiger Reserve (NSTR)
    Forest Rights Granted land rights under the Forest Rights Act (2006), allowing subsistence farming and forest dwelling
    Challenges Facing displacement, low literacy rate (40.6%), and rehabilitation issues due to relocation from their forest homes
    Cultural Practices Worship Malalamma Vana Devatha (goddess of honey); brew liquor from acacia bark, mahua flower, and jaggery
    Society Community-oriented with close-knit family bonds, practicing traditional subsistence living and deeply connected to forest ecosystems
    Population 64,227 (2011 Census), spread across five districts in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana
    Government Support Special rights granted under the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (FRA)
    Major Threats Displacement due to tiger conservation efforts, lack of modern skills, poverty, and low literacy rates

     

    PYQ:

    [2013] Consider the following pairs :

    Tribe: State

    1. Limboo Limbu : Sikkim

    2. Karbi : Himachal

    3. Dongaria Kondh : Odisha

    4. Bonda : Tamil Nadu

    Which of the above pairs are correctly matched?

    (a) 1 and 3 only

    (b) 2 and 4 only

    (c) 1, 3 and 4 only

    (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

  • Preparing for the next pandemic: what NITI Aayog report says

    Why in the News?

    Four years after the onset of Covid, an expert group formed by NITI Aayog has proposed the establishment of a comprehensive framework to handle future public health emergencies or pandemics effectively.

    Lessons Learned from COVID-19:

    • Gaps in Legal Frameworks: Existing laws like the Epidemic Diseases Act (1897) and National Disaster Management Act (2005) were insufficient for handling large-scale health emergencies. These laws lack clarity on definitions of epidemics and provisions for managing public health crises, drug distribution, and quarantine measures.
    • Delayed Response and Coordination: The COVID-19 pandemic exposed weaknesses in coordination between central and state governments, highlighting the need for a more organized response mechanism.
    • Inadequate Surveillance: Insufficient disease surveillance and early warning systems delayed the identification of threats. The role of zoonotic diseases, especially viruses linked to bat species, underscored the need for better monitoring of human-animal interactions.

    What specific recommendations does the NITI Aayog report make?

    • Enactment of PHEMA: Introduce the Public Health Emergency Management Act for a more robust legal framework to manage pandemics and other health emergencies.
    • Empowered Group of Secretaries (EGoS): Establish a central committee to oversee pandemic preparedness, governance, R&D, surveillance, and response efforts.
    • Strengthened Disease Surveillance: Create a national biosecurity and biosafety network and monitor human-animal interfaces, especially for zoonotic diseases.
    • Emergency Vaccine Bank: Develop a stockpile of vaccines for rapid access during health crises, sourced domestically or internationally.
    • Early Warning and Research Network: Build a forecasting and modelling network, along with Centres of Excellence (CoEs) to advance research on priority pathogens and preparedness.

    How can India enhance its pandemic preparedness framework? (Way forward)

    • Strengthening Legal and Institutional Frameworks: Enact a Public Health Emergency Management Act (PHEMA) and establish an Empowered Group of Secretaries for coordinated pandemic response.
    • Enhancing Surveillance and Early Warning Systems: Build a robust disease surveillance network, biosecurity system, and epidemiology forecasting for early detection and response to outbreaks.
    • Investing in Health Infrastructure and Vaccine Stockpiles: Develop public health cadres, boost healthcare infrastructure, and create an emergency vaccine bank for rapid deployment during health crises.

  • Tea tribes marginalized in Assam despite their contribution to the economy

    Why in the News?

    Recently, Jharkhand Chief Minister Hemant Soren urged Assam’s Himanta Biswa Sarma to grant ST status to tea tribes, he was also strategically countering the BJP’s campaign in election-bound Jharkhand.

    Demand for Scheduled Tribe Status

    • Recognition of Marginalization: The Jharkhand CM has emphasized that the tea tribes in Assam, numbering around 70 lakh, are marginalized despite their significant contributions to the state’s economy.
      • He has formally requested Scheduled Tribe (ST) status for these communities, which are currently classified as Other Backward Classes (OBCs) in Assam, limiting their access to essential government benefits and protections associated with ST status.
    • ST Status: The tea tribes meet the criteria for ST status due to their distinct cultural identity, traditional way of life, and vulnerability to exploitation.
      • Many members of these tribes are indigenous to Jharkhand and have historical ties to Assam, having migrated there during colonial rule to work in tea plantations.

    Which are the Tea Tribes in Assam?

    • Munda: Originating from the Chotanagpur plateau, they are one of the most prominent groups among the tea tribes in Assam.
    • Santhal: They have a rich cultural heritage and are known for their traditional music and dance.
    • Oraon: This group also hails from central India and has a strong presence in Assam’s tea gardens.
    • Gond: Primarily found in central India, Gonds are part of the tea tribes due to historical migration patterns.
    • Kurukh: This group is related to the Oraon and shares linguistic and cultural ties with them.
    • Bhumij: They were brought to Assam for labor in tea plantations.

    The criteria for a community to be recognized as a Scheduled Tribe (ST) in India:

    As established by the Lokur Committee and currently followed by the Office of the Registrar General of India (RGI), include:

    • Primitive Traits: Indications of a primitive lifestyle or cultural practices that are less developed compared to mainstream society.
    • Distinctive Culture: A unique cultural identity that differentiates the community from others, including language, traditions, and customs.
    • Geographical Isolation: Communities that are historically or currently isolated from the mainstream population, often residing in remote areas.
    • Shyness of Contact with the Community at Large: A tendency to avoid interaction with broader society, which may stem from historical marginalization.
    • Backwardness: Socio-economic disadvantages compared to the general population, including lower levels of education and economic development.

    How do the Tea Tribes contribute to the Economy?

    • Major Workforce: The tea tribes form the backbone of Assam’s tea industry, which is one of the largest in the world.
      • Approximately 53% of India’s total tea production comes from Assam, and a significant portion of this labor force comprises tea tribe members, particularly women.
    • Economic Dependence: It is estimated that around 20 lakh people (2 million) in Assam are directly or indirectly dependent on the tea industry for their livelihoods.
      • The wages earned by tea tribe workers are a primary source of income for many families within these communities.

    Cultural Heritage and Historical Injustices

    • Due to Cultural Displacement: The tea tribes face challenges in preserving their cultural heritage due to their classification as OBCs. This status affects their land rights and access to employment opportunities, leading to a loss of cultural identity.
    • Due to Socio-economic Challenges: Despite contributing significantly to Assam’s tea industry, the tea tribes suffer from poor living conditions, lack of educational facilities, and inadequate healthcare. 
      • They often live in poverty and face systemic barriers that prevent them from accessing government programs designed for marginalized communities. This situation reflects historical injustices stemming from colonial labor practices that uprooted them from their ancestral lands.

    Way forward: 

    • Granting ST Status: Expedite the process of granting Scheduled Tribe (ST) status to the tea tribes, which would provide them with legal recognition and access to special protections, reservations, and welfare schemes aimed at uplifting marginalized communities.
    • Improving Living Conditions: Implement targeted government programs to improve the living conditions of tea tribe communities, focusing on access to education, healthcare, and better infrastructure in tea plantation areas.

  • 92% of workers cleaning urban sewers, septic tanks from SC, ST, OBC groups: survey

    Why in the News?

    Government data from over 3,000 urban local bodies across 29 States and Union Territories shows that 91.9% of the 38,000 sewer and septic tank cleaners profiles belong to SC, ST, or OBC communities.

    What are the socio-economic conditions of workers engaged in sewer and septic tank cleaning?

    • Demographics: A significant majority (91.9%) of the 38,000 profiled workers belong to marginalized communities: 68.9% Scheduled Castes (SC), 14.7% Other Backward Classes (OBC), 8.3% Scheduled Tribes (ST), and 8% from the general category.
    • Employment Status: The workforce largely comprises low-income individuals engaged in hazardous, low-status jobs, reflecting persistent caste-based disparities.
    • Capital Subsidies support: Since the launch of the NAMASTE program, ₹2.26 crore in capital subsidies have been distributed to 191 beneficiaries, indicating some financial support for transitioning into self-employment.

    How effective are current policies and rehabilitation schemes for sanitation workers?

    • NAMASTE Programme: Aimed at mechanizing sewer cleaning and providing safety training and equipment, the program is a replacement for the Self-Employment Scheme for Rehabilitation of Manual Scavengers (SRMS).
    • Enumeration Process: Over 3,326 urban local bodies (ULBs) are involved, with 38,000 workers profiled so far. However, 283 ULBs reported zero workers, suggesting that the profiling might not be comprehensive or that many workers are unrecognized.
    • Rehabilitation Success: Out of 58,098 identified manual scavengers under the previous SRMS scheme, 97.2% were from SC communities. While cash transfers of ₹40,000 were provided, only a fraction pursued skills training or loans for alternative livelihoods.

    What are the challenges?

    • Social Stigma: Predominantly from marginalized communities (SC, ST, OBC), these workers face discrimination, limiting their access to better job opportunities and social mobility.
    • Health Risks: Exposure to hazardous working conditions leads to significant health risks, with a high mortality rate (377 deaths from 2019 to 2023) due to unsafe practices.
    • Ineffective Rehabilitation: Current policies and support programs lack comprehensive coverage, leaving many workers unrecognized and limiting the effectiveness of financial assistance and training initiatives.

    What are the health risks and safety measures for workers in hazardous cleaning roles?

    • Hazardous Working Conditions: Between 2019 and 2023, 377 workers died from hazardous cleaning activities, highlighting the extreme risks associated with sewer and septic tank cleaning.
    • Safety Training: The NAMASTE program aims to provide safety training for workers to minimize health risks, but the effectiveness of such training needs further evaluation.
    • Equipment and Mechanization: The goal is to transition workers from manual cleaning to mechanized processes, reducing their exposure to dangerous conditions and improving overall safety.

    Way forward: 

    • Comprehensive Training and Support Programs: Enhance the effectiveness of the NAMASTE program by providing robust safety training and resources for workers, coupled with extensive outreach to ensure all workers are identified and supported, including those currently unrecognized.
    • Promotion of Mechanization and Safety Standards: Accelerate the mechanization of sewer cleaning operations to reduce health risks, and establish strict safety standards and regulations to protect workers, ensuring regular monitoring and enforcement of these standards.

  • Arogya Sanjeevani Policy

    Why in the News?

    The “Arogya Sanjeevani Policy” serves as a reference point for choosing health insurance for hospitalisation.

    About Arogya Sanjeevani Policy:

    Details
    Launch Date April 2020
    Issued by Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI)
    Objective To provide basic and affordable health insurance coverage to all citizens
    Sum Insured ₹1 lakh to ₹5 lakh per policy year
    Coverage Hospitalization, pre and post-hospitalization expenses, daycare procedures, AYUSH treatments, COVID-19 coverage
    Pre-Existing Conditions Coverage after 4 years of continuous policy renewal
    Co-Payment 5% co-payment on all claims
    Premium Varies based on age, sum insured, and insurer
    Waiting Period 30 days for new policies; 48 months for pre-existing diseases
    Daycare Procedures Covers over 50+ daycare treatments
    Room Rent Limit Up to 2% of the sum insured per day (maximum ₹5,000 per day)
    ICU Room Rent Up to 5% of the sum insured per day (maximum ₹10,000 per day)
    AYUSH Treatments Covers Ayurveda, Yoga, Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha, and Homeopathy treatments
    Maternity Coverage Not covered
    Network Hospitals Cashless facility in network hospitals
    Eligibility Individuals aged 18 to 65 years

     

    PYQ:

    [2019] Performance of welfare schemes that are implemented for vulnerable sections is not so effective due to the absence of their awareness and active involvement at all stages of the policy process – Discuss.

  • Keep the fire of the self-respect movement going

    Why in the News?

    This year marks the beginning of the centenary of the “Self-Respect Movement”, a transformative movement with a unique mission to empower individuals and communities to challenge and dismantle the oppressive hierarchical structures that had subjugated them.

    What is the significance of the Self-Respect Movement?

    • Empowerment Against Hierarchical Structures: The Self-Respect Movement, founded by Periyar in 1925, aimed to dismantle the caste-based hierarchy that oppressed lower castes, especially in the Madras Presidency.
    • Social Reform Beyond Political Representation: The movement went beyond advocating for communal representation, focusing on equal rights for women, caste abolition, and the upliftment of the depressed classes.
      • It introduced radical reforms like self-respecting marriages and supported women’s rights such as property ownership, divorce, and widow remarriage.
    • Kudi Arasu’s Role: The Tamil weekly, Kudi Arasu (The Republic), served as a platform to spread Periyar’s critiques of Brahminism and the caste hierarchy, expanding the reach of the Self-Respect Movement.
    • Federalism and Political Autonomy: Periyar and the movement contributed to the evolution of federalism in India by advocating for regional autonomy and opposing the dominance of elite caste groups in politics.

    How can the principles of the self-respect movement be sustained and promoted?

    • Adaptation to Contemporary Issues: The movement must address modern complexities like the intersectionality of caste with class, religion, gender, and sexuality. Expanding the movement’s scope to include LGBTQIA+ rights and evolving gender norms will keep it relevant.
    • Counter-fack news on social media: Active communication with younger generations, particularly in countering right-wing narratives and caste biases on social media, is vital for promoting the movement’s ideals of equality and rationalism.
    • Reframing Social Justice in a Global Context: Sustaining the Self-Respect Movement’s legacy requires integrating its principles with global discussions on social justice, identity politics, and human rights.
    • Advocacy for Policy Reforms: Continuous advocacy for policies that address caste and gender inequalities, such as reservations and legal protection for self-respect marriages, can strengthen the movement’s impact.

    What challenges does the self-respect movement face in the current socio-political climate?

    • Cultural Homogenisation: The rise of Hindutva and right-wing ideologies seeks to homogenise India’s diverse cultures, undermining regional, linguistic, caste, and gender identities that the movement has historically sought to protect.
    • Evolving Caste Dynamics: While traditional caste practices may have declined in some areas, caste-based discrimination persists subtly in other forms, which the movement must continue to confront.
    • Digital Misinformation: The rise of social media has led to the spread of falsehoods that reinforce caste and group prejudices. The movement must actively engage in digital spaces to counter these narratives.
    • Caste-based politics: In states like Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, many regional political parties engage in caste-based politics, which indirectly obstructs the principles and application of the Self-Respect Movement.

    Way forward: 

    • Promote Inclusive Policy Reforms: The Indian government should enhance policies that target caste and gender inequalities, such as expanding legal protections for self-respect marriages and enforcing anti-discrimination laws, while ensuring marginalized communities have equitable access to resources and opportunities.
    • Strengthen Digital Literacy and Anti-Misinformation Efforts: The government should initiate programs to combat digital misinformation, particularly caste-based narratives, by promoting digital literacy, fact-checking, and inclusive content on social media platforms to foster equality and social harmony.
  • [27th September 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: An opportunity to rethink India’s pension system

    [27th September 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: An opportunity to rethink India’s pension system

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q). Suppose you are an officer in charge of implementing a social service scheme to provide support to old and destitute women. An old and illiterate woman comes to you to avail the benefits of the scheme. However, she needs documents to show that she fulfils the eligibility criteria. But after meeting her and listening to her you feel that she certainly needs support. Your inquiries also show that she is destitute and living in a pitiable condition. You are in a dilemma as to what to do. Putting her under the scheme without the necessary documents would be a violation of the rules. But denying her the support would be cruel. (UPSC CSE 2016)

    Prelims:
    Who among the following can join the National Pension System (NPS)? (UPSC CSE 2017)
    (a) Resident Indian citizens only
    (b) Persons of age from 21 to 55 only
    (c) All State Government employees joining the services after the date of notification by the respective State Governments
    (d) All Central Government employees including those of Armed Forces joining the services on or after 1st April, 2004

    Mentor’s Comment:  There is an ongoing discussion about the need for a stronger welfare system because many countries are moving away from neoliberal policies. This has brought back conversations about government support for people in need. The proposed Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) aims to offer pensions to everyone, but it has been criticized for needing major changes to truly help retirees. These potential reforms are important as they relate to larger social support and financial security trends, making the editorial very relevant right now.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    The Indian pension system has evolved through various schemes, notably the Old Pension Scheme (OPS), the New Pension Scheme (NPS), and the proposed Unified Pension Scheme (UPS).

    • There are ongoing discussions about reforming India’s pension framework amidst significant socio-economic changes.

    Previous Pension Schemes in India:

    • Old Pension Scheme (OPS): Implemented before 2004, it guaranteed a defined benefit pension based on the last drawn salary.
      • The government was solely responsible for pension disbursement and provided stability and protection from financial market risks. It allowed employees to plan their retirements with financial security.
    • Transition to New Pension Scheme (NPS): Introduced in 2004 replacing the OPS, it shifted from a defined-benefit model to a defined-contribution model.
      • Both employees and the government contribute to a pension fund invested in financial markets. Pension payouts are linked to market performance, exposing retirees to market volatility.

    What are the criticisms faced by the NPS?

    • It represents a neoliberal shift reducing state involvement in welfare. It leaves retirees vulnerable to economic downturns and market fluctuations.
    • The market-driven model raises worries about the commercialization of public welfare programs. It highlights the weakening of the state’s social responsibility towards its citizens.
    A return to Welfarism

    • Global Context: The era of neoliberalism is declining, prompting calls for stronger social safety nets. The 2008 financial crisis highlighted the risks of over-reliance on markets. The COVID-19 pandemic intensified demands for government intervention to protect citizens.
    • Indian Context: India is experiencing a similar push for state-backed welfare provisions. The proposed Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) aims to provide universal pensions while balancing state involvement and market participation.

    About the newly proposed – Unified Pension Scheme (UPS):

    • It was introduced by the government in August 2024, replacing the 21-year-old National Pension System (NPS) with a structure closely resembling the Old Pension Scheme (OPS).
    • The UPS promises government employees a lifelong monthly pension of 50% of their last drawn pay.In the event of a government employee’s death, the family is assured a pension equivalent to 60% of the employee’s pension.
    • A minimum pension of ₹10,000 per month is assured for those who complete at least 10 years of central government service.
    • The scheme is contributory, requiring employees to contribute 10% of their salary. The government is to contribute 18.5% of the salary.

    Criticism faced by the Unified Pension Scheme:

    • Limited access to the Beneficiaries: UPS promises retirement payouts but offers lower returns than the Old Pension Scheme (OPS), which exposes retirees to market risks.
      • A requirement of 25 years of service for full pension disadvantages the late joiners, and concerns about potential underfunding could lead to pension delays.
    • Coverage Limitations: Currently, the UPS only covers Union government employees, excluding many public sector workers like teachers.

    Need for State Intervention:

    • Greater state involvement is necessary to protect retirees from market fluctuations.
    • The UPS should consider safeguards, such as a minimum guaranteed pension similar to the OPS, to enhance its viability as a welfare scheme.

    Conclusion: The UPS, if properly restructured, could become an important tool in protecting the financial security of retirees and addressing the shortcomings of the NPS, ensuring that India’s retirees are not left to the mercy of market forces but are supported by a robust welfare system.

  • [25th September 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The NCrF as a framework for well-rounded education

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q)  National Education Policy 2020 conforms with the Sustainable Development Goal-4 (2030). It intends to restructure and reorient the education system in India. Critically examine the statement. (UPSC CSE 2020)

    Q) The quality of higher education in India requires major improvement to make it internationally competitive. Do you think that the entry of foreign educational institutions would help improve the quality of technical and higher education in the country? Discuss. (UPSC CSE 2015)

    Q) How have digital initiatives in India contributed to the functioning of the education system in the country? Elaborate your answer. (UPSC CSE 2020)

    Mentor’s Comment:  The National Credit Framework (NCrF), derived from the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, provides a flexible template for educational institutions to offer a unified accumulation and transfer of credits across multidisciplinary education, including skill education.

    However, some remain resistant to the dynamic and forward-looking changes advocated by the NCrF, unwilling to adapt to India’s evolving societal, technological, and educational needs. In today’s editorial we will see how the Indian education system needs to remain relevant and competitive, higher education institutions (HEIs) must revise their curricula to align with the NCrF and bridge skill mismatches.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    The National Credit Framework (NCrF) represents a significant shift in India’s educational approach, aiming to create a more flexible, integrated, and student-centered learning environment that prepares individuals for the challenges of the 21st century.

    What is the National Credit Framework (NCrF)?

    • The NCrF is a set of guidelines to be followed by schools, colleges and universities in adopting the credit system.
    These guidelines are based on the inter-ministerial committee report, the Union Ministry of Education (MoE) unveiled the draft NCrF in 2022.
    • The primary goal is to help Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) balance vocational training with academic pursuits, thereby playing a crucial role in shaping individual futures and contributing to societal progress.
    • It brings the entire school education system under the ambit of credits for the first time. Only the National Institute of Open Schooling (NIOS) follows a credit system. The NCrF also covers skill and vocational education.

    Features:

    • NCrF will allow students to attain NSQF-approved foundational skills developed by industry and be more employable.
    • The provision of micro-credentials will allow integration of quick educational upgradation/up-skilling.

    Significant Impact of National Credit Framework (NCrF)

    • Credit Earning Opportunities: The National Credit Framework (NCrF) allows students to earn credits through various activities, including classroom teaching, laboratory work (like Atal Tinkering Labs), research projects, sports, arts, and vocational training, provided they undergo assessment.
    • Broad Educational Scope: Students can accumulate credits from diverse experiences such as internships, apprenticeships, social work, and experiential learning. This flexibility is designed to cater to their academic and career aspirations.
    • Integration of Vocational Training: It promotes a balanced approach between vocational training and academic pursuits, ensuring that both aspects are interlinked and equally valued in shaping students’ futures.

    What are the present issues in implementation?

    • Resistance to Change: Some educators are resistant to the NCrF, clinging to conventional educational methods. This reluctance challenges adapting to the evolving educational landscape shaped by societal and technological shifts.
    • Need for Curriculum Revision: To remain relevant and competitive, higher education institutions (HEIs) must revise curricula in alignment with the NCrF. This includes addressing skill mismatches that could hinder students’ career prospects.

    How HEIs can work in a modern education environment?

    • Dual Focus on Knowledge and Skills: HEIs should not only focus on producing knowledge but also equip students with practical skills necessary for emerging job roles and self-employment opportunities. This dual role is achievable through the adoption of the NCrF.

    Differences between MERU (Multidisciplinary Education and Research University) Universities and Traditional Universities:

    MERU Universities by NEPTraditional Universities
    Multidisciplinary FocusIt emphasizes a multidisciplinary approach to education, integrating various fields of study and promoting interdisciplinary research.It often operates within rigid academic silos.
    Research OrientationMERUs are designed to serve as centers for advanced research and innovation, aspiring to make India a global hub for research and development.Traditional universities may have limited research opportunities or focus primarily on undergraduate education.
    Flexible CurriculumThe curriculum in MERUs is envisioned to be flexible, allowing students to explore various disciplines and gain credits through diverse activities.Traditional universities often have a more structured curriculum with less room for interdisciplinary exploration.
    Accessibility and EquityMERUs aim to promote accessibility and equity in education, ensuring that all students have the opportunity to succeed regardless of their background.Traditional universities may still face challenges related to inclusivity and equal access.

    Continuous Adaptation is the Key: (Way Forward)

    • Support for Reforms: Promoting an inclusive higher education system requires supporting reforms that democratize education and enhance social equity. Continuous adaptation of Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) is essential to avoid stagnation and maintain effectiveness.
    • NEP 2020 and MERU Concept: The National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 introduces the Multidisciplinary Education and Research University (MERU) model, aiming to cultivate scholars and intellectuals. However, HEIs should also prioritize vocational and skill training to improve student employability.
    • Practical Skills and Social Mobility: A flexible curriculum, as proposed in the National Credit Framework (NCrF), enables students to acquire practical skills, making higher education a vehicle for social mobility. Resistance to structural changes in education often stems from outdated pedagogical methods that do not address current economic and social realities.
    • Need for Curriculum Reimagining: To align with modern needs, higher education curricula must integrate flexibility and multidisciplinary approaches, ensuring that institutions prepare students for emerging challenges in the job market.

    Conclusion: There is a need to integrate flexibility, multidisciplinary approaches, and skill-based courses to transform India into an economic powerhouse and technological leader. Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) should emphasize both vocational and skill training alongside fundamental research and innovation.

  • Professional Indian women work the most hours globally   

    Why in the News?

    The tragic death of 26-year-old Chartered Accountant Anna Sebastian Perayil in Pune has sparked debate about professional workload in India, with her mother citing “work stress” as the cause.

    What does the ILO data observe about Professional Indian women? 

    • Longest Working Hours Globally: Indian women in professions like information technology (IT), media, and professional, scientific, and technical fields work the highest number of hours globally. Women in IT and media jobs worked 56.5 hours weekly, while women in professional, scientific, and technical fields worked 53.2 hours per week in 2023.
    • Young Professional Women Work More: Younger women, especially those aged 15-24, work even longer hours. For instance, young women in IT and media work 57 hours per week, and those in professional, scientific, and technical fields work 55 hours per week.
    • Gender Imbalance in Workforce: Indian women are underrepresented in these sectors. Only 8.5% of the Indian workforce in professional, scientific, and technical jobs and 20% in information and communication jobs are women. This low percentage is among the lowest globally.
    • Global Comparison: In countries like Germany, women in similar IT and media jobs work far fewer hours (32 hours weekly). Russia reports 40 hours for the same sector, highlighting how disproportionately longer Indian women work.

    Major Challenges in Indian Society:

    • Workload Stress: The tragic death of Anna Sebastian highlights the intense workload stress that young professionals, especially women, face. High demands and long working hours can severely affect mental and physical health.
    • Male-Dominated Workspaces: Women in professional fields face challenges working in male-dominated environments, which can result in increased pressure, lack of support, and issues of gender equity.
    • Systemic Gender Inequality: Despite rising participation in the workforce, the gender imbalance in professional sectors reflects deeper societal and structural inequalities. Women continue to face barriers to career advancement, equal representation, and fair treatment.
    • Lack of Support: The absence of adequate organizational support during personal tragedies (as indicated by Anna’s case) points to a lack of empathy and a toxic work culture in certain professional settings.

    Government Initiatives:

    • Women in STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics): The Indian government has launched several initiatives to encourage women’s participation in technical and scientific fields, including scholarships, mentorship programs, and awareness campaigns (e.g., GATI initiative).
    • Maternity Benefits: The Maternity Benefit (Amendment) Act, 2017, increased paid maternity leave for women from 12 weeks to 26 weeks, aimed at helping women balance work and family life.
    • Gender Equality Programs: Initiatives like Beti Bachao Beti Padhao promote girls’ education and empowerment, aiming to address the long-term gender imbalance in professional spaces.
    • Skill Development Initiatives: Government programs like Skill India and Digital India aim to provide technical and vocational training to women, helping bridge the gender gap in high-skill industries such as IT and professional services.

    Way forward: 

    • Work-Life Balance Reforms: Enforce stricter labour regulations on working hours and promote flexible work arrangements to reduce burnout, particularly for young professionals in high-demand sectors.
    • Inclusive Workplaces: Strengthen gender diversity and equity initiatives within male-dominated industries by fostering supportive work environments, mentorship programs, and leadership opportunities for women.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q What are the continued challenges for Women in India against time and space?  (UPSC IAS/2019)