Civilsdaily

Subject: Indian Society

  • Narayana Murthy just gave some very bad advice

    Narayana Murthy

    Central idea

    Narayana Murthy’s advice to work 70 hours a week sparks debate on the balance between productivity and workforce well-being. The article explores the challenges, gender disparities, and global work hour comparisons, emphasizing the need for adaptable work strategies in a post-COVID era to achieve sustainable growth without compromising individual lives.

    Key Highlights:

    • Narayana Murthy’s Advice: Murthy advises young IT professionals to work 70 hours a week to address India’s low productivity concerns and meet global changes.
    • Productivity Concerns: Murthy emphasizes the need for a cultural shift toward determination, discipline, and hard work, especially among the youth.
    • Global Work Hours Comparison: Data from the International Labour Organisation shows South and East Asia having the highest average weekly work hours, contrasting with North America and Europe.
    • Work-Life Balance Challenges: Murthy’s approach raises concerns about the impact on stress, income, and work-life balance, particularly for women in the workforce.

    Challenges and Concerns:

    • High Working Hours: South and East Asia, including India, have high average weekly work hours, impacting the well-being of the workforce.
    • Gender Disparities: A 24/7 work culture may disproportionately affect women, with unrealistic professional standards and limited concessions for family responsibilities.
    • Workplace Expectations: Murthy’s emphasis on extended working hours may contribute to a culture valuing presence over contribution, potentially affecting mental health and family life.

    Analysis:

    • Nation Building vs. Workforce Well-being: The tension between nation-building efforts and the well-being of the workforce is highlighted, raising questions about sustainable growth.
    • Workplace Changes Post-COVID: The article suggests that the COVID-19 pandemic has reshaped the workplace, emphasizing the need for practical expectations and support mechanisms.

    Key Data:

    • Average Work Hours: South and East Asia have the highest average weekly work hours, with South Asia at 49 hours and East Asia at 48.8 hours.
    • Global Comparison: North America records 37.9 average weekly work hours, while Europe ranges from 37.2 to 37.9 hours.

    Key Terms:

    • Flexi-time: Flexible working hours allowing employees to choose their work hours within certain limits.
    • FOMO (Fear of Missing Out): The culture where an individual fears missing out on opportunities or experiences, often applied in the context of work.
    • Work-Life Balance: The equilibrium between professional and personal life to ensure overall well-being.
    • Remote Work: Work performed outside the traditional office setting, often enabled by technology.
    • Job Flexibility: Adaptable work arrangements, including flexi-time and remote work, to accommodate employees’ needs.

    Concerns for Future Work Strategies:

    • One-way Work Culture: The traditional approach of work as a one-way street, potentially overlooking the changing dynamics of the modern workplace.
    • Impact on Lives: The need for work strategies that consider individual lives, relationships, and personal aspirations alongside professional goals.

    Way Forward:

    • Adaptable Work Policies: Organizations should embrace adaptable work policies, including flexi-time and remote work, to accommodate diverse needs and promote work-life balance.
    • Equal Opportunities: Ensure equal opportunities and concessions for both genders, challenging traditional norms that disproportionately affect women in the workforce.
    • Rethinking Productivity: Shift the focus from sheer working hours to productivity and contribution, fostering a culture that values efficiency over extended presence.
    • Support Mechanisms: Establish robust support mechanisms, acknowledging the changing dynamics post-COVID, to nurture employee well-being and mental health.
    • Continuous Dialogue: Encourage ongoing dialogue between employers and employees to understand evolving needs and collectively shape a work environment that aligns with the aspirations of the workforce.

  • Salt Consumption and Health: Striking a Delicate Balance

    Central Idea

    • Salt is an essential component of our diet, adding flavor to our food and serving vital bodily functions.
    • However, excessive salt intake can lead to health issues, including high blood pressure.

    Salt Intake in India

    • In India, a recent national survey revealed that men consume 8.9 grams, while women intake 7.1 grams of salt daily (Prashant Mathur et al., Scientific Reports, 2023).
    • While the World Health Organization recommends a daily salt intake of 5 grams, the global average is much higher at 10.8 grams.

    Salt and Health Implications

    • Diverse Health Effects: Extensive research in animals and human surveys consistently link high salt consumption to kidney, brain, vascular, and immune system diseases. Conditions such as kidney stones and osteoporosis are associated with excessive sodium intake.
    • Global Impact: Excessive salt intake contributes to approximately five million deaths worldwide annually, underscoring the global health impact of salt-related health issues.

    The Yanomami Example

    • The Yanomami people, living in the Amazon rainforest, follow a foraging lifestyle and consume a diet primarily composed of Cassava, plantains, fruit, fish, and occasionally tapir.
    • Interestingly, they use peppers for flavor but do not use salt.
    • Their daily salt intake is less than one gram, yet they maintain excellent health and fitness.

    Salt and Obesity Connection

    • Balancing Act: While our bodies require salt for essential functions, excessive salt consumption can lead to health problems, including obesity.
    • Metabolic Impact: High salt intake impairs metabolism and increases the size of adipocytes, the cells that store fat, contributing to obesity.
    • Dietary Preferences: There is a connection between a preference for high-fat and salty foods. Experiments with mice showed that those exposed to high-fat diets during gestation preferred salty water.

    Reducing Salt Intake and Blood Pressure

    • Population Studies: Reducing salt intake by five to eight grams daily can lead to a 4 mmHg drop in systolic blood pressure and a lower risk of cardiovascular disease, as demonstrated in population studies.
    • Clinical Trials: Antihypertensive drugs, which lower blood pressure, show similar results, with an average reduction of 5 mmHg.
    • Salt Alternatives: Replacing normal salt with a mixture of 75% sodium chloride and 25% potassium chloride reduced systolic blood pressure by 3.3 mmHg in a Chinese population study.
    • Caution for Elderly: Reducing salt intake may pose risks for elderly adults, particularly if they are taking blood pressure medication, as it could lead to hypotension and falls.

  • Women can make the world better

    Central idea

    The article highlights Arun Maira’s insights on the gender disparity in economic narratives, emphasizing the undervaluation of women’s contributions, the evolving challenges in global employment patterns, and the need for a more inclusive and care-focused approach to economic development, particularly in the context of India and the G-20’s call for a holistic vision beyond GDP

    Challenges in How We See Money and Work:

    • Not Enough Women Recognized: The Nobel Prize in Economics mostly goes to men, leaving out women’s important contributions. Only three women have won it so far.
    • Forgetting the Value of Care: The work women do at home, taking care of family and community, isn’t seen as important for the economy. This is a big problem.
    • Jobs Changing Globally: The way people work is changing worldwide. More jobs are now short-term or in the gig economy. This is a big challenge for India, which has a lot of young people.
    • Not Paying Enough for Important Jobs: Jobs like taking care of families or working in health and education are crucial, but the people doing these jobs, mostly women, are not paid well.

    India’s Economic Situation:

    • Problems for Young People: In India, even though the economy is growing fast, it’s hard for young people to find good jobs with good pay and security.
    • Need More Focus on Care: India ranks 132nd in human development, and we need to spend more on services that take care of people. But sadly, jobs like taking care of families or working in health and education are not paid much.
    • G-20’s Call for a Different Way: Our Prime Minister has asked the G-20 for a new approach, one that looks beyond just making money. He says it’s time to think of the world as one family.

    Checking How Well We’re Doing:

    • Progress Slow for Big Global Goals: The G-20 says we’re not doing great halfway to our big global goals. Only 12% of the things we wanted to achieve are on track.
    • Time for a Big Change: Arun Maira says we need to change how we solve problems. The usual way is not working, so we need to try something new.

    Seeing Economics in a New Way:

    • Thinking About Everyone: Maira says we need to change how we see our economy. It’s not just about making things and competing. It’s about taking care of people.
    • Looking at What Women Do: Women, according to Maira, do a lot of important work that isn’t always noticed. Nobel laureate Elinor Ostrom showed that when women are in charge, communities work well together.

    What Needs to Change:

    • Giving Women More Power: Maira says we need to let women shape how things work, not just follow what men have set up.
    • Letting Local Communities Decide: Instead of having big experts decide everything, Maira says we should let local communities come up with their solutions. What works in one place might not work in another.
    Unique phrases from article for upsc mains exam value addition

     

    “Tragedy of the Commons Revisited:”

    Referring to Nobel Laureate Elinor Ostrom’s insights, this phrase underscores the importance of cooperative governance, particularly led by women, in managing local resources sustainably.

     

    “Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam: One Family, One Earth, One Future:”

    This phrase encapsulates the Indian Prime Minister’s call at the G-20, emphasizing a vision that transcends traditional economic metrics and advocates for a global community approach.

     

    “Paradigm Change in Economics:”

    Arun Maira advocates for a fundamental shift in economic thinking, moving away from traditional models dominated by men and towards a more inclusive, caring, and community-driven perspective.

     

    “The Feminine Lens on Economics:”

    This phrase highlights the article’s exploration of a feminine perspective in economics, drawing attention to the undervalued contributions of women and the need for a broader understanding of economic dynamics.

     

    Conclusion:

    Changing how we think about our economy is not easy, but it’s important. Maira tells us that we should listen to regular people, especially women, and let them help make things better. This way, we can build a future where everyone is taken care of, and our world becomes one big family.

     

     

     

  • Supreme Court upholds Woman’s Right to Parenthood in Surrogacy Case

    surrogacy

    Central Idea

    • In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court of India has safeguarded a woman’s right to parenthood, particularly in cases of medical conditions, by suspending the enforcement of a law that jeopardized her aspiration to become a mother through surrogacy.
    • This significant ruling provides protection and empowerment for women facing unique medical challenges on their journey to parenthood.

    Case Details

    • Medical Condition: The woman suffers from the rare Mayer Rokitansky Kuster Hauser (MRKH) syndrome. Medical records confirm her condition, which includes “absent ovaries and absent uterus,” rendering her unable to produce her own eggs.
    • Hope through Gestational Surrogacy: She and her husband embarked on the path of gestational surrogacy using a donor’s eggs (a process where one person, who did not provide the egg used in conception, carries a fetus through pregnancy and gives birth to a baby for another person or couple.).

    Threatening Amendment

    • No donor gamete use: A government notification dated March 14 of the current year introduced an amendment to the law, prohibiting the use of donor gametes in surrogacy. It mandated that “intending couples” must employ their own gametes for the surrogacy process.
    • A Violation of Parenthood Rights: This amendment was challenged in the Supreme Court, alleging a violation of a woman’s fundamental right to parenthood. The court found that the amendment contradicted the core provisions of the Surrogacy Act, both in form and substance.

    Gametes Regulation and ART Act, 2021

    • Gametes are reproductive cells. In animals, the male gametes are sperms and female gamete is the ovum or egg cells.
    • On March 14, 2023, the Health Ministry published Rules that said:
    1. A couple undergoing surrogacy must have both gametes from the intending couple and donor gametes are not allowed;
    2. Single women (widow/divorcee) undergoing surrogacy must use self-eggs and donor sperms to avail surrogacy procedure.
    • Section 2(h) of the Assisted Reproductive Technology Regulation Act, 2021 defines a “gamete donor” as a person who provides sperm or oocyte with the objective of enabling an infertile couple or woman to have a child.

    Court’s Ruling: Allows Donor’s Gametes

    • Prima Facie Contradiction: The SC Bench issued a decisive order, stating that the amendment obstructed the intending couple from achieving parenthood through surrogacy and was prima facie contrary to the Surrogacy Act’s intentions.
    • Petitioner’s Argument: Senior advocate Sanjay Jain, representing the petitioner, argued that the amendment invalidated the possibility of gestational surrogacy, which the Surrogacy Act, 2021, recognized as a valid option for couples facing medical conditions.
    • Rule 14(a) Clarification: Jain referred to Rule 14(a) of the Surrogacy Rules, emphasizing that it explicitly listed medical or congenital conditions, such as the absence of a uterus, as valid reasons for gestational surrogacy. The rule affirmed that the choice was solely the woman’s.
    • Retrospective Implementation: The petitioner contended that the amendment could not be applied retrospectively to her case.

    Court’s Ruling and Interpretation

    • Woman-Centric Perspective: The court concurred with Mr. Jain’s argument that gestational surrogacy was “woman-centric.” It recognized that the decision to opt for surrogacy was driven by the woman’s inability to become a mother due to her medical or congenital condition.
    • Validation of Rule 14(a): The court asserted that the amendment could not contradict Rule 14(a), which explicitly acknowledged medical conditions, including the absence of a uterus, as valid reasons necessitating gestational surrogacy.
    • Genetic Relation Interpretation: Addressing the government’s contention that the surrogate child must be “genetically related” to the couple, the court clarified that this related to the husband when Rule 14(a) applied.

    Conclusion

    • The Supreme Court’s decision in favour of ‘Mrs. ABC’ not only upholds her right to parenthood but also reinforces the significance of gestational surrogacy as a woman-centric solution for individuals facing challenging medical conditions on their path to becoming parents.
    • This ruling sets a precedent for protecting the parenthood rights of women across India.

  • TN experience on Caste Survey

    tn caste

    Debate: Caste-Based Surveys

    • The recent nationwide discussions on caste-based surveys and reservations have ignited debates regarding reservation limits.
    • While many call for a similar census across India, Tamil Nadu’s history offers insights into the complexities of caste-based reservations.
    • Despite previous efforts, the implementation of OBC (Other Backward Class) reservations remains a challenge in the state.

    Genesis of Ramachandran Commission

    • Background: The First BC panel (1969-70), led by A.N. Sattanathan, suggested raising BC reservations, but the idea of a creamy layer hasn’t gained political backing.
    • Current Backdrop: In 1980, following electoral setbacks, the government in Tamil Nadu, led by M.G. Ramachandran, increased BC (Backward Class) reservations from 31% to 50%, totalling 68% with SC & ST reservations (later 69% with ST exclusive reservation).
    • Legal Challenge: The move faced legal challenges, prompting the state government to form a commission to review BC enumeration and classification.
    • Commission Formation: The Second BC Commission, chaired by J.A. Ambasankar, was established in late 1982 and submitted its report in February 1985.

    Key Highlights of the Commission’s Work

    • Socio-Educational-cum-Economic Survey: The Commission conducted a comprehensive door-to-door enumeration of BCs in two stages during 1983-84. Unlike the previous panel, which relied on the 1921 Census, this survey was based on contemporary data.
    • Caste Classification: The Commission identified 298 BC communities within main groups such as BCs, Most BCs, Denotified Communities (DNCs), SCs, STs, and others. BCs constituted 67.15% of the state’s population.
    • Educational Survey: A sample survey of students in schools and colleges was conducted, along with an assessment of BC representation in public services.

    Key Recommendations

    • Reservation Quantum Debate: Disagreements arose between Chairman Ambasankar and other members regarding the reservation percentage. While Ambasankar proposed reducing it to 32% to stay within the 50% limit, dissenting members argued for at least 50% due to the BC population’s size.
    • Reservation Coverage: Differences also emerged regarding the coverage of reservations. Ambasankar suggested separate lists of BCs for Article 15(4) and Article 16(4), while members favored a single list.

    Government Response and Legal Safeguards

    • No Change in Reservation Quantum: The government retained the 50% BC reservation and did not accept Ambasankar’s recommendation to reduce it.
    • Ninth Schedule: To safeguard the 69% quota, Tamil Nadu enacted a law and placed it under the Ninth Schedule following the Supreme Court’s Mandal Commission case judgment in 1992.
    • Subsequent Changes: Over the years, separate quotas for Muslims and Christians were introduced within the BC reservation, but some were later withdrawn or challenged.
    • SC Verdict: In 2021, the Supreme Court struck down a law providing 10.5% reservation for Vanniyars within the MBC quota, citing non-contemporaneous data from the Ambasankar panel.

    Conclusion

    • Tamil Nadu’s experience with caste-based reservations underscores the intricate challenges involved. While the state has maintained a high reservation percentage, debates over quantum and coverage persist.
    • The recent legal developments highlight the importance of contemporary data in determining and sustaining reservations, making it a complex and evolving issue.

  • Women, marriage and labour market participation

     

    women

    Central idea

    The article explores the decline in women’s labor force participation rates, particularly among married women in India, emphasizing its economic implications. It discusses key challenges, including societal norms and limited educational opportunities, while highlighting government schemes and proposing solutions for enhancing women’s participation in the labor market.

     

    Relevant Data from the Article:

    • World Bank estimates (2022) indicate a global female LFPR of 47.3%, with India experiencing a decline from 28% to 24% between 1990 and 2022.
    • Economist Goldin’s analysis reveals a U-shaped pattern in women’s LFPR during economic growth, influenced by factors like income and substitution effects.
    • The article emphasizes the pronounced decline (5%) in female LFPR among married women aged 25 to 49 in India from 2004-05 to 2022-23.

    Present Status:

    • Married women exhibit a significant decrease in LFPR after marriage due to factors such as limited educational attainment, increased family obligations, and societal disapproval of women in the workforce.
    • Data analysis from India’s NSSO Periodic Labour Force Survey indicates a substantial drop in LFPR among married women, especially in the age group of 25-29.

    Key Challenges:

    • Marital status significantly influences women’s labor market outcomes, with married women showing lower LFPR compared to unmarried counterparts.
    • Educational achievement plays a role, with less-educated women displaying a higher inclination to participate in the labor force after marriage.

    women

    Government Schemes and Initiatives:

    • The National Creche Scheme for The Children of Working Mothers is cited as a government initiative to support women’s labor force participation.
    • The article stresses the need for enhancing the quality and accessibility of day-care services to act as an incentive for employed women, especially married women.

    Way Forward:

    • Solutions proposed include improving day-care services and crèches across various socio-economic strata in both the public and private sectors.
    • Work settings prioritizing women’s needs, secure transportation options, and the expansion of part-time job possibilities are suggested to enhance women’s participation in the labor market.

    Conclusion:

    In conclusion, the article underscores the economic impact of the decline in married women’s LFPR in India and advocates for targeted initiatives to promote women’s empowerment. It emphasizes the need for comprehensive solutions, including improved day-care services, supportive work environments, and part-time job opportunities, to address the challenges hindering women’s participation in the labor market.

    Do follow https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1908961

  • How big is the Gender Gap in earnings?

    gender gap

    Central Idea

    • The Periodic Labour Force Surveys (PLFS) have diligently monitored the gender earnings gap in India from April-June 2019 to 2023.
    • This latest iteration places a vital spotlight on weekly hours worked, unveiling that the inequity in total earnings may not fully encapsulate the true narrative.

    Examining the Gender Earnings Disparities

    • Claudia Goldin’s Pioneering Work: Building upon Nobel laureate Claudia Goldin’s research, India’s gender disparities in employment and wages come into focus.
    • Earnings Converted to Weekly Figures: Earnings for various worker categories are transformed into weekly earnings.
    • Ratio of Weekly Earnings: Table 1 displays the ratio of weekly earnings between men and women at the national level, encompassing rural and urban sectors. A figure above 1 denotes men earning more than women.
    • Persistent Gender Gap: Men out-earn women across all forms of work, with the self-employed experiencing the most significant gender gap in 2023, where men earned 2.8 times more than women. In contrast, male regular wage workers earned 24% more, and male casual workers earned 48% more than their female counterparts. The gender earnings gap remains a persistent challenge.
    • Changing Trends: Notably, the gender gap has increased for self-employed workers but decreased for regular wage workers, dropping to 24% in 2023 from 34% in 2019.

    Analyzing Average Weekly Work Hours

    • Incomplete Picture: Disparities in earnings per unit of work are not entirely elucidated by the earnings gap alone. Women consistently work fewer hours than men across all forms of employment, as depicted in Table 2.
    • Largest Gap for the Self-Employed: In 2023, men in self-employment worked 50% more hours than women, while the gap was the smallest for regular wage workers (19%).
    • Rising Gender Gap in Hours Worked: The gender gap in hours worked has expanded, particularly for self-employed women, indicating an increase in part-time employment among them. Simultaneously, male self-employed workers continue full-time work.

    Diving Deeper into Hourly Earnings Gap

    • Hourly Earnings Analysis: Calculations of hourly earnings for each worker category reveal the ratio between men and women’s hourly earnings, as presented in Table 3.
    • Significant Reduction in Regular Wage Workers’ Gap: In 2023, men in regular wage employment earned 24% more than women over the week but worked 19% longer hours. The hourly earnings gap narrows to approximately 4%, down from 11% in 2019.
    • Hourly Earnings Parity in Regular Wage Work: On average, women in regular employment earn less per week but nearly match men when hourly earnings are considered. However, these averages mask nuanced disparities across occupations and industries.
    • Higher Inequality in Other Employment Types: Inequality in hourly earnings is more pronounced in other work categories, albeit lower than when assessing total earnings. In 2023, male casual workers earned 23% more per hour than women, a reduction from 33% in 2019. Conversely, the self-employed category witnessed an increase in the hourly earnings gap from 84% in 2019 to 87% in 2023.

    Factors Influencing Work Hours

    • Beyond Pure Choice: Lower hourly earnings inequality for regular wage workers doesn’t imply women opt for shorter work hours by choice.
    • Societal barriers: Barriers, such as societal expectations that women manage domestic and childcare duties, may limit their employment options.

    Conclusion

    • Addressing both remuneration disparities and disparities in total work hours is crucial.
    • Policymakers should target the removal of barriers that curtail women’s working hours.
    • This involves workplace interventions like mandating childcare facilities and extended maternity leaves and broader societal transformations that challenge traditional gender norms and share childcare and domestic responsibilities more equitably.

  • The present and future of Dalit politics

     

     

    Central idea:

    • The decline of independent Dalit political parties is linked to changing aspirations and a failure to address the rising class of politically aspirant Dalits, who seek economic mobility. The need for a shift from conventional identity-based politics to a more dynamic, economically focused approach is crucial for the survival of these parties. Ensuring democratic functioning and preventing dynastic tendencies is essential for relevance in the evolving political landscape.

    Who Are Dalits?

    • Dalits, historically known as untouchables, are marginalized and oppressed communities in India who have faced severe discrimination and social exclusion based on their caste. They constitute a significant portion of the Indian population.

    Dalits in India:

    • The latest data on the number of Dalits in India is from the National Sample Survey Office’s (NSSO) 75th Round Survey, which was conducted in 2017-18. The survey found that there are approximately 272 million Dalits in India, which is about 17% of the total population.
    • This means that the Dalit population has increased by about 3% since the 2011 Census. This increase is likely due to a number of factors, including population growth, improved census methodology, and increased awareness of Dalit identity.

     

    Dalit Movements in India:

    • 19th Century: The Self-Respect Movement, led by E.V. Ramasamy Naicker, challenged the caste system and advocated for social justice for Dalits.
    • Early 20th Century: The Depressed Classes Movement, led by B.R. Ambedkar, fought for the rights of Dalits, including education, employment, and political representation.
    • 1950s: The Indian government passed a number of laws to protect the rights of Dalits, including the Untouchability (Offences) Act of 1955 and the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act of 1989.
    • Late 20th Century: Dalit movements continued to fight for social justice and equality, including the Dalit Panthers movement in the 1970s and the Bahujan Samaj Party movement in the 1980s.

     

    Changing Political Landscape:

    • While dalit political parties played a crucial role in empowering Dalits, they are facing organizational challenges and a decline in electoral performance.
    • Some Dalit leaders are shifting to mainstream political parties, further weakening independent Dalit politics.
    • Rising aspirations among Dalit communities, driven by education and affirmative action, are leading to a quest for political space in other parties.
    • Social welfare schemes by major political parties are influencing Dalit voters, creating a new Dalit mentality.

     

    What Is the Need for Democratic Functioning of dalit parties?

    • Adapting to Changing Aspirations: Independent Dalit parties need to adapt to the evolving aspirations of Dalit communities, which now emphasize socio-economic mobility alongside identity politics.
    • Preventing Dynastic Tendencies: Ensuring democratic functioning within these parties is essential to prevent the growth of dynastic political culture, enabling grassroots leaders to have a say in the party’s direction.
    • Balancing Identity and Socio-economic Goals: These parties should develop a political agenda that combines the politics of identity with the economics of identity to cater to the new aspirations of the Dalit community.
    • Safeguarding Grassroots Participation: By allowing grassroots leaders to have a role in the party’s decision-making process, independent Dalit parties can ensure that the concerns and needs of the most marginalized Dalits are addressed effectively.

     

    Status of Dalit politics:

    • Weakening Independent Dalit Parties: RPI and BSP face declining influence and organizational challenges.
    • Fragmentation and Desertion: Internal divisions, leader departures, and shifting alliances affect party stability.
    • Loss of Base Voters: RPI, BSP losing votes to dominant parties like BJP and Congress.
    • Changing Aspirations: Dalits now seek meaningful political space due to education and affirmative actions.
    • Shift from Identity to Aspiration: Transition from identity politics to socio-economic mobility aspirations is challenging traditional modes.

    Decline in performance of Dalit political parties

    • Electoral Erosion: Dalit political parties, including the BSP and RPI, have experienced a decline in their electoral performance, losing ground to mainstream parties.
    • Loss of Base Support: Many Dalit parties have witnessed a loss of their core voter base to dominant regional and national parties like the BJP and Congress.
    • Changing Aspirations: Evolving aspirations among Dalit communities, driven by education and affirmative actions, are challenging the parties’ ability to connect with their constituents.
    • Shift to Socio-economic Focus: The traditional focus on identity politics is waning, and Dalit parties are struggling to adapt to the new emphasis on socio-economic mobility and development.

    Future of Dalit Politics:

    • Uncertainty for Independent Parties: Independent Dalit parties like RPI and BSP face an uncertain future due to internal issues and declining influence.
    • Deepening Democracy: Some believe that as Indian democracy matures, mainstream parties may better represent Dalit interests, diminishing the need for separate Dalit parties.
    • Aspiring Political Space: Dalits aspire for greater political participation, which could shape the future of Dalit politics.
    • Socio-economic Focus: The future may see a shift from identity-based politics to socio-economic goals, aligning with evolving Dalit aspirations.

    Significance of dalit politics:

    • Empowerment of Dalits: Independent Dalit political parties have played a pivotal role in raising the political consciousness of Dalits and advocating for their rights and dignity.
    • Political Representation: These parties have been instrumental in increasing the political representation of Dalits in India, giving them a platform to voice their concerns and grievances.
    • Awareness and Solidarity: The existence of independent Dalit political parties has created awareness about Dalit issues and fostered a sense of solidarity among marginalized communities.

     

    Challenges:

    • Electoral Erosion: Independent Dalit political parties are facing a gradual decline in their electoral influence, with many Dalit leaders defecting to dominant regional and national parties.
    • Shifting Aspirations: Rising aspirations among Dalit communities, driven by education and affirmative action, are causing a shift from identity-based politics to socio-economic mobility aspirations. This transition poses a challenge for Dalit parties that fail to adapt.
    • Competition from Mainstream Parties: Dominant national and regional parties are actively vying for Dalit voters, further challenging the influence of independent Dalit political parties.

     

    Initiatives and schemes by Indian Government for Dalits:

    • Reservation Policy: India implements reservations for SC, ST, and OBC in education and government jobs, aiming to provide opportunities for historically marginalized communities.
    • Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act: Enacted in 1989, it legally protects Dalits and Adivasis from caste-based discrimination and violence, with strict penalties for offenders.
    • Ambedkar Post-Matric Scholarship: A financial support program for Dalit and economically disadvantaged students pursuing higher education, covering tuition fees, books, and related expenses.
    • Ambedkar Hastshilp Vikas Yojana (AHVY): Launched by the Ministry of Textiles, it aids Dalit artisans through training, market linkages, and financial support to promote their traditional handicrafts and skills.

     

    Way Forward:

    • Independent Dalit parties need to redefine their political agendas by integrating socio-economic mobility with identity politics.
    • Democratic functioning within these parties must be encouraged to give space to grassroots leaders.
    • A multi-polar Dalit politics may emerge as leaders, cadres, and Dalit masses disperse among different political parties, emphasizing their rising political values.
    • The government should continue its affirmative action policies and address the socio-economic disparities faced by Dalits.

  • Women’s Reservation Bill: After passing, challenge now to ensure promise translates to equality

     

    What’s the news?

    The Women’s Reservation Bill recently passed in Parliament after a 27-year journey, marking a crucial milestone for gender equality in politics.

    Central idea

    The Women’s Reservation Bill, recently approved by Parliament, signifies a pivotal step for women’s inclusion in politics after 27 years of deliberation. It addresses challenges of historical resistance and perceptions regarding equality while government initiatives like the 73rd Amendment and property rights extension aim to empower women at grassroots levels.

    Theory of reflective autonomy given in the article states

    • Definition: Reflective autonomy is the ability of women to critically examine and understand their values, beliefs, and choices in the realm of politics.
    • Importance: This self-awareness empowers women to make political decisions based on their own understanding, free from external pressures or uninformed influences.
    • Example: In the context of the Women’s Reservation Bill, reflective autonomy implies that women aspiring to be MPs should critically evaluate their motivations and political goals, ensuring they align with their personal values and aspirations.
    • Commitment to Shared Values: Women’s commitment to shared values emphasizes a collective responsibility for gender equality, inclusivity, and the empowerment of women in the political landscape.
    • Importance: This commitment provides a foundation for cooperation, fostering unity and aligning individual actions with the broader societal goal of women’s empowerment.
    • Example: In the article, shared values could revolve around advocating for gender equality, creating an inclusive political space, and actively working towards the empowerment of women in India.

    Three “E”s – Engagement, Emancipation, and Empathy:

    • Engagement: Women aspiring to be MPs need to actively participate in addressing societal issues and engage in political processes to contribute meaningfully.
    • Emancipation: Seeking freedom and empowerment for women, particularly those from marginalized groups, becomes a crucial goal in the pursuit of political leadership.
    • Empathy: Understanding and sharing the feelings of fellow citizens, particularly those with diverse perspectives, is essential for creating a harmonious and inclusive political environment.
    • Example: Women aspiring to be MPs in India should engage with local issues, actively contribute to the emancipation of marginalized women, and cultivate empathy for the diverse challenges faced by different segments of society. This approach ensures that their political journey is not only self-aware but also deeply rooted in shared values and a commitment to women’s empowerment.

    Key Challenges:

    • Historical Resistance: Women’s reservation faced prolonged resistance, evident in debates from Sarojini Naidu to contemporary concerns about power balance.
    • Perception of Equality: Addressing skepticism regarding quotas and their alignment with the principle of equality.
    • Masculinist Dominance: Overcoming the historical dominance of men in politics and shifting towards a more inclusive representation.

    Government Schemes and Initiatives:

    • Women’s Reservation Bill (Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam): A landmark legislation passed in September, marking a historic commitment to women’s empowerment.
    • 73rd and 74th Amendments: Empowering women at the grassroots level through panchayati raj institutions.
    • Extension of Property Rights: Measures benefiting women in tribal communities and initiatives like Beti Bachao Beti Padhao.

    Way Forward:

    • Training and Education: Encouraging women to pursue higher education in relevant fields such as public policy, political science, and law.
    • Mentorship Programs: Establishing mentorship initiatives with experienced women politicians guiding aspiring leaders.
    • Local Engagement: Emphasizing the importance of engaging with local issues and providing solutions, fostering confidence and commitment.

    Conclusion:

    Advocating the theory of reflective autonomy, the focus should be on engagement, emancipation, and empathy. Women aspiring for political roles must actively participate in local problem-solving, gaining confidence, and nurturing empathy for societal harmony. The Women’s Reservation Act, a formal step towards equality, should translate into substantive equality through these concerted efforts.

  • The Court’s ‘no fundamental right to marry’ is wrong

    fundamental right to marry

    What’s the news?

    The Supreme Court of India’s line, with respect to same sex persons, that there is no fundamental right to marry, is incorrect.

    Central idea

    The Supreme Court’s decision in Supriyo Chakraborty judgement is unfair as it denies same-sex couples the right to marry. This reinforces discrimination and stigma against LGBTQI communities. It’s crucial to correct this for equal rights.

    Debate and controversy on Same-sex marriage

    • Same-sex marriage is the legal recognition of a marriage between two individuals of the same sex.
    • It grants same-sex couples the same legal and social recognition, rights, and privileges that are traditionally associated with marriage, including property rights, inheritance rights, and the ability to make decisions for each other in medical emergencies.
    • The recognition of same-sex marriage varies around the world, with some countries legalizing it while others do not.
    • The issue has been the subject of much debate and controversy, with arguments for and against same-sex marriage based on religious, cultural, social, and legal considerations.

    Same-sex marriage in India

    • Same-sex marriage is currently not legally recognized in India.
    • Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, which criminalized homosexuality, was struck down by the Supreme Court of India in 2018, which was a landmark decision for LGBTQ+ rights in the country.
    • However, there is still no law that allows same-sex couples to legally marry or have any legal recognition of their relationships.

    Key Challenges and Legal Maze

    • Background and Section 377: The legal journey began with the Delhi High Court’s 2009 decision in Naz Foundation, striking down Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code. However, the Supreme Court’s 2013 ruling in Suresh Kumar Koushal reinstated the criminalization of non-heterosexual relationships, only to be overturned in 2018 with Navtej Singh Johar.
    • Stigmatization and Societal Perception: The LGBTQI communities faced severe challenges, including blackmail, torture, and violence, under the oppressive Section 377. The societal perception that a relationship less than marriage lacks legitimacy fueled strong demands for the right to marry.
    • Global Legal Shifts: The Supreme Court’s reluctance to consider foreign jurisprudence contrasts with global trends. Many countries, including the United States, have evolved their legal frameworks by drawing on international experiences and human rights principles to recognize same-sex marriage.

     

    Government Schemes and Initiatives

    • NALSA and Transgender Rights: The NALSA judgment recognized the right of individuals to identify their gender, paving the way for the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act. While this Act addresses gender identity, the recent judgment on same-sex marriage presents a contradiction in the application of rights.
    • International Commitments: India’s commitment to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) has been vital in shaping legislation. However, the recent verdict seemingly ignores India’s pledge to accord with international human rights standards.
    Highly important points for critical analysis in mains and essay

     

    ·         Pioneering Activism: The fight against Section 377 and for LGBTQI rights in India has a long history. The Lawyers Collective, led by activists like Anand Grover, initiated legal challenges against Section 377 as early as 2001, setting the stage for future legal battles.

     

    ·         Unique Transgender Recognition: While the recent judgment denies same-sex marriage, it recognizes the legality of marriages involving transgender individuals. This reveals an interesting legal nuance, emphasizing the evolving understanding of gender identity in Indian law.

     

    ·         Symbolism of Marriage: The demand for the right to marry goes beyond legal recognition. It symbolizes the quest for social acceptance, legitimacy, and equal standing in society. The denial of this right perpetuates stigmatization and reinforces societal prejudices.

     

    ·         Resilience of LGBTQI Community: Despite setbacks, the LGBTQI community has demonstrated remarkable resilience. The progression from challenging Section 377 to advocating for the right to marry showcases the community’s determination to overcome legal barriers and societal biases.

     

     

     

    Way Forward

    • Correcting the Legal Framework: There is an urgent need to revisit the foundational decision that there is no fundamental right to marry in India. Aligning the legal framework with the principles of equality and non-discrimination is paramount.
    • Incorporating International Jurisprudence: While the Court has rejected the use of foreign jurisprudence, there is a compelling case to reconsider this stance. Introducing global perspectives, such as the doctrine of intimate association, can enhance inclusivity and align Indian legal principles with evolving global standards.
    • Empowering LGBTQI Communities: Beyond legalities, empowering LGBTQI communities involves addressing societal perceptions. Recognition of same-sex marriage is crucial not only for legal rights but also for dismantling stigmas and prejudices.

    Conclusion

    The LGBTQI community’s call for equality in marriage is not just a legal battle but a societal transformation. A correction of the recent judgment is a step towards ensuring that no citizen is deemed “not fit for marriage” based on their sexual orientation.

    The journey involves falls and rises. Learning from past victories, the LGBTQI community must persist in the fight for equal rights, ensuring that the wrongs are corrected, and the path to equality is firmly established.

  • Gyan Sahayak Scheme for Contractual Teachers

    Gyan Sahayak Scheme

    Central Idea

    • The Gyan Sahayak Scheme, introduced by the Gujarat state government, has stirred controversy, facing opposition from various quarters of society.

    Why discuss this?

    • The scheme seeks to address teacher vacancies in government schools through contractual appointments until regular appointments are finalized.
    • Many states in India have opted for the contractual filling of govt job vacancies ever since the regime change in 2014.

    Understanding the Gyan Sahayak Scheme

    • Interim Solution: The scheme aims to temporarily fill teaching positions in primary, secondary, and higher secondary government schools until regular appointments could be made.
    • Basis in National Education Policy (NEP) 2020: The scheme draws inspiration from the NEP 2020, which emphasizes the need for teachers with interdisciplinary skills, beyond traditional academic subjects.

    Scope of the Scheme

    • Applicability: The Gyan Sahayak Scheme is applicable to government and grant-in-aid schools, particularly Mission Schools of Excellence.
    • Vacancy Statistics: The government announced the hiring of 15,000 Gyan Sahayaks for primary schools and 11,500 for secondary and higher secondary schools.
    • Salary Structure: Gyan Sahaks receive varying monthly salaries based on their school level: Rs 21,000 for primary, Rs 24,000 for secondary, and Rs 26,000 for higher secondary.
    • Vacancy Context: Gujarat reports an estimated 32,000 teaching vacancies in government and grant-in-aid schools, primarily affecting primary and secondary schools. Some secondary schools rely on Pravasi teachers to meet staffing needs.

    Eligibility Criteria

    • Primary Gyan Sahayak: Candidates must have cleared the Gujarat Examination Board’s Teachers Eligibility Test (TET)-2.
    • Secondary and Higher Secondary Gyan Sahayak: Candidates should have cleared the Teacher Aptitude Test (TAT).
    • Age Limit: Both primary and secondary school Gyan Sahayaks must be under 40 years of age, while higher secondary school Gyan Sahayaks can be up to 42 years old.
    • Merit-Based Selection: Selection involves the preparation of a merit list based on percentile ranks from TET-2 results, followed by the allocation of Gyan Sahayak positions to School Management Committees (SMCs) through district education officers.

  • CJI lists measures against LGBTQI Discrimination

    Central Idea

    • In a significant ruling, CJI D Y Chandrachud made a series of directions to address discrimination against the LGBTQ+ community and underscored the need for legislative action to recognize same-sex marriages.
    • This decision reflects a pivotal moment in India’s LGBTQ+ rights movement, emphasizing the intersection of legal and societal norms.

    Preventing LGBTQI Discrimination: Key Directions by CJI

    • Creation of Safe Houses: The ruling called for the establishment of “Garima Grehs” or safe houses in all districts to provide shelter to LGBTQ+ individuals facing violence or discrimination. These safe houses aim to offer refuge and support to those in need.
    • Anti-Discrimination Measures: The Centre, States, and Union Territories were urged to ensure that LGBTQ+ community members are not subjected to discrimination based on gender identity or sexual orientation. This includes equal access to goods and services available to the public.
    • Public Awareness: The ruling emphasized the need to sensitize the public about queer identity, affirming that it is natural and not a mental disorder. It encourages educational efforts to promote understanding and acceptance.
    • Hotline Numbers: The authorities were directed to establish hotline numbers that LGBTQ+ individuals can contact when facing harassment or violence. This initiative aims to provide immediate assistance and support.
    • End of Harmful “Treatments”: The ruling called for an immediate cessation of any “treatments” offered by doctors or others that attempt to change gender identity or sexual orientation. It prioritizes the well-being and autonomy of LGBTQ+ individuals.
    • Protection from Family Pressure: Police were advised not to force LGBTQ+ persons to return to their natal families if they choose not to do so. Furthermore, the ruling emphasized the importance of verifying the claims of LGBTQ+ individuals when they file complaints against their families, ensuring their freedom is not curtailed.
    • Fair Preliminary Investigation: Before registering an FIR against a queer couple or one of the parties involved, a preliminary investigation should be conducted. This step ensures that the complaint discloses a cognizable offence, preventing unnecessary legal action against LGBTQ+ individuals.

    Historical Context

    • The ruling underscored that India has a rich history of LGBTQ+ lives, encompassing various identities and communities.
    • It emphasized that queerness is not limited to urban settings or privileged classes but exists across different regions, castes, and economic backgrounds.

    Future Steps

    • The ruling has set a precedent for addressing discrimination and ensuring the protection of LGBTQ+ rights.
    • Justice S K Kaul expressed the need for a comprehensive anti-discrimination law prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation.
    • State governments have also been prompted to create guidelines and committees to address LGBTQ+ issues, demonstrating the broader impact of this ruling beyond the courtroom.

    Conclusion

    • The Supreme Court’s ruling on LGBTQ+ rights signifies a significant milestone in the ongoing struggle for equal rights and acceptance.
    • While legislative recognition of same-sex marriages remains pending, the directions provided by the CJI emphasize the importance of dismantling discriminatory practices and promoting inclusivity in Indian society.
    • The ruling paves the way for a more equitable future for LGBTQ+ individuals in the country.

  • India seeks inclusion of Traditional Medicine on WHO’s ICD List

    Central Idea

    • The Centre seeks to include traditional Indian medicines in the 11th revision of the World Health Organisation’s International Classification of Diseases (ICD).
    • The traditional Indian medicine system is categorized into Ayurveda, Siddha, Unani and Yoga, Naturopathy, and Homoeopathy

    About International Classification of Diseases (ICD)

    Purpose Standardized system for classifying and coding diseases, health conditions, and related information.
    Established 1893, by International Statistical Institute (WHO’s predecessor)
    Authority Developed and maintained by the World Health Organization (WHO).
    Scope Covers a wide range of diseases, health conditions, injuries, and health-related factors.
    Coding System Assigns unique alphanumeric codes to each health condition for consistent recording and reporting.
    Global Applicability Internationally recognized and used for health data collection, analysis, and reporting.
    Updates Periodically updated to reflect advances in medical knowledge and changing health trends.
    Latest Version ICD-11 became effective in January 2022.
    Uses Clinical diagnosis, health record documentation, research, health policy, and resource allocation.

    India’s quest to update ICD-11

    • Universal Language: The ICD provides a universal language that enables healthcare professionals worldwide to share standardized information.
    • Traditional Medicine Module: The 11th revision includes a module dedicated to traditional medicine conditions, offering a standardized way to collect and report data on these conditions internationally.
    • Formal Recognition: Ayurveda and related Indian traditional healthcare systems are formally recognized and widely practised in India, making a strong case for their inclusion.
    • Chinese Medicine Inclusion: After a decade of consultations, ICD-11 included Module-1, covering traditional medicine conditions originating in ancient China.

  • Abortion Rights in India: Legal Complexities and Ethical Dilemmas

    abortion

    Central Idea

    • CJI DY Chandrachud said that India’s abortion law was liberal, pro-choice and far ahead of other countries.
    • SC is hearing the case of a married woman who wants to medically terminate her 26-week pregnancy.
    • This raises critical questions about a woman’s autonomy in deciding to abort and the existing legislative framework.

    Woman’s Perspective

    • Unplanned Pregnancy: A 27-year-old married woman, already a mother of two, contends that her pregnancy was unplanned.
    • Financial Strain: She argues that her family’s income is inadequate to support another child, and she is undergoing treatment for postpartum depression after her second child’s birth.

    Court Decisions and AIIMS Report

    • Initial Approval: A two-judge Bench initially allowed the termination, reasoning that an unplanned pregnancy due to contraceptive failure is akin to a forced pregnancy, permitting abortion up to 24 weeks.
    • AIIMS Concern: AIIMS, Delhi, raised questions about whether foeticide (stopping the foetal heart) could be performed before termination since the foetus is currently viable.
    • Three-Judge Bench: The case was transferred to a three-judge Bench, led by Chief Justice of India (CJI) D Y Chandrachud, which called for a fresh medical report to assess the foetus’s health and the woman’s medical condition.

    Understanding the Abortion Law

    • Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act (MTP Act): The MTP Act allows termination of pregnancy in three stages.
      1. Termination up to 20 weeks with the advice of one doctor.
      2. Pregnancy at 20-24 weeks requires the opinion of two registered medical practitioners, under specific conditions.
      3. After 24 weeks, a medical board in approved facilities assesses the termination based on substantial foetal abnormalities.

    Court’s History of Allowing Late-Term Abortion

    • Several Precedents: The court has previously permitted terminations beyond 26 weeks in various cases, often in cases of rape or consensual relationships.
    • Marital Status Factor: The current case distinguishes itself by the woman’s marital status, implying that the conception is consensual and not a forced pregnancy.

    Balancing Rights: Woman vs. Unborn Child

    • Ongoing Debate: The CJI-led Bench oscillates between prioritizing a woman’s rights over abortion and the need to balance the rights of the unborn child.
    • Liberal Approach: India’s law on abortion is considered liberal and pro-choice, with courts often favouring the woman’s autonomy.

    Comparisons with International Standards

    • Foetal Viability: The concept of “foetal viability” as a benchmark for abortion approval is relatively new in India. It aligns with international standards.
    • US Roe v Wade: The landmark 1973 US Supreme Court case, Roe v Wade, allowed abortion until foetal viability. In 1973, viability was at 28 weeks, now lower due to scientific advancements.
    • Criticism of Indian Law: Some critics argue that India’s law lacks clarity as the decision to terminate after 20 weeks falls on doctors rather than the women, leading to frequent court interventions.

    Autonomy vs. Unborn Child’s Rights

    • Legislative Gap: While the Indian legal framework supports a woman’s autonomy in reproductive decisions, gaps persist, especially concerning last-minute interventions.
    • Ethical Debate: The Indian law leans toward women’s autonomy, but ethical dilemmas arise regarding the rights of the unborn child.
    • Legal Precedents: Cases like Nand Kishore Sharma versus Union of India have debated the constitutionality of the MTP Act concerning the right to life of an unborn child.

    Conclusion

    • The ongoing Supreme Court case highlights the intricate legal and ethical considerations surrounding abortion in India.
    • While the law supports a woman’s right to choose, the challenge lies in finding a delicate balance between individual autonomy and the rights of the unborn child.
    • As the court grapples with this complex case, it underscores the need for continued legal discourse and potential legislative amendments to address evolving reproductive rights issues.

  • Women and water and the potential of green jobs

    What’s the news?

    • Water, a vital resource for life, is poised to play a central role in the transition to a green economy. This transition brings not only environmental benefits but also the potential to drive significant employment growth, particularly for women.

    Central idea

    • Water is essential for a green economy, offering immense potential for job generation, particularly for women. Women globally are pivotal players in water management, yet their expertise remains underutilized. As green jobs surge in India, how can women’s roles in water management be enhanced and recognized?

    Backdrop

    • Green Jobs in Water Management: These jobs contribute to preserving or restoring environmental quality. A promising estimate by the International Labour Organisation posits that jobs in this sector could escalate from 3 million (2020) to 19 million by 2030 in India.
    • Water and Global Employment: A 2016 UN report underscores that nearly 1.5 billion people, or half the global workforce, are in water-related sectors. Water thus fosters both direct (managing resources, infrastructure, services) and indirect jobs.

    Harse reality

    • A World Bank evaluation of 122 water projects found that those involving women were six to seven times more effective than those that did not.
    • Despite this evidence, women constitute less than 17 percent of the paid workforce in water, sanitation, and hygiene in developing economies, and women’s representation as technical experts remains disproportionately low.

    The Role of Women in Efficient Water Management

    • Household Water Management: Women are typically responsible for managing water within households. They oversee water collection, storage, and distribution for domestic use, ensuring a safe and sustainable water supply for their families.
    • Community Engagement: In many communities, women actively engage in the management of communal water sources. They take the lead in maintaining these sources, making sure they remain accessible and functional for all community members.
    • Agriculture: Women play a crucial role in agriculture, which is a major consumer of water resources. They are involved in activities such as irrigation, crop cultivation, and livestock care. Their knowledge of efficient water use is vital for agricultural sustainability.
    • Environmental Stewardship: Women often act as environmental stewards, safeguarding local ecosystems, rivers, lakes, and forests. Their traditional practices and knowledge contribute to the preservation of water resources and the environment.
    • Community Development: Women actively participate in community development projects related to water infrastructure, sanitation, and hygiene. They serve on water and sanitation committees, helping plan and implement projects that benefit the entire community.
    • Innovative Solutions: Women frequently devise innovative solutions to address water-related challenges. They may create rainwater harvesting techniques, sustainable farming practices, or household-level water treatment methods, enhancing water resource management.

    Unlocking Opportunities through Government Programs

    • Traditionally, women’s involvement in water management has been limited to voluntary or part-time roles, often at the lowest level of decision-making.
    • Recent government initiatives in India, such as the Jal Jeevan Mission, Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation, Atal Bhujal Yojana, and Jal Shakti Abhiyan, present an opportunity to expand women’s participation in water management and provide access to decent work.
    • These programs prioritize community ownership and support both direct and indirect jobs.

    The Potential of Jal Jeevan Mission

    • The Jal Jeevan Mission, in particular, has the potential to generate a substantial number of jobs.
    • A study by the Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore, estimated that the mission could create millions of person-years of direct and indirect employment, although gender-disaggregated data are lacking.

    Way forward

    • Addressing Skill Gaps and Capacity Building:
    • Water management jobs require specific skills and training, yet there is often a gap between the skills needed and the expertise available.
    • While some training programs exist for wastewater treatment and watershed management, they do not cover emerging employment opportunities in the water sector.
    • Promoting Sustainable Employment:
    • Despite robust policies for community participation, sustainable employment creation has been lacking.
    • Investing in training women, providing access to finance, and leveraging self-help groups can foster women’s self-employment in water management, strengthening water security in both rural and urban areas.

    Conclusion

    • Government initiatives such as the Jal Jeevan Mission are poised to unlock this potential. By addressing skill gaps and promoting women’s participation, India can not only create green jobs but also empower women in the vital task of water management, contributing to a more sustainable and inclusive future.

  • India ranks 111/125 in Global Hunger Index, 2023

    Central Idea

    • India has been ranked 111th out of 125 countries in the Global Hunger Index-2023, a stark decline from its 107th position in 2022.
    • The index highlights a concerning statistic – India reports the world’s highest child wasting rate at a staggering 18.7 percent.
    • Interestingly, India’s neighboring countries, including Pakistan (102nd), Bangladesh (81st), Nepal (69th), and Sri Lanka (60th), have performed comparatively better in the index.

    Global Hunger Index (GHI)
    Publication Jointly published annually by Concern Worldwide and Welthungerhilfe.
    Scale Measures hunger on a 100-point scale, with 0 as the best (no hunger) and 100 as the worst score.
    Purpose Comprehensively measures and tracks hunger globally, regionally, and at the country level. Aims to trigger action to reduce hunger worldwide.
    Indicators 4 key indicators for each country:

    1. Undernourishment (reflects inadequate food availability): Share of the population that is undernourished.

    2. Child Wasting (reflects acute undernutrition): Share of children under five with low weight for their height.

    3. Child Stunting (reflects chronic undernutrition): Share of children under five with low height for their age.

    4. Child Mortality (reflects inadequate nutrition and unhealthy environment): Mortality rate of children under five.

     

    Hunger in India: Fact Check

    • Serious Hunger Levels: India’s score of 28.7 in the Global Hunger Index-2023 places it in the “serious” category, according to the report.
    • Child Wasting: India’s child wasting rate, the proportion of undernourished children measured by weight relative to their height, stands at an alarming 18.7 percent, signaling acute undernutrition.
    • Undernourishment Rate: The rate of undernourishment in India is reported at 16.6 percent, further highlighting the gravity of the issue.
    • Child Mortality: Under-five mortality in India is recorded at 3.1 percent.
    • Anemia Among Women: The report underscores a significant concern, with 58.1 percent of women aged 15 to 24 in India being affected by anemia.

    A report to bully India

    • Disputed Ranking: The Indian government has rejected the GHI 2023 ranking, citing serious methodological concerns and suggesting a malicious intent behind the report (considering elections).
    • Methodological Issues: The WCD Ministry asserts that the GHI 2023 report suffers from significant methodological issues. It contends that 3 out of 4 indicators used for calculation pertain to child health, which does not represent the entire population.
    • Sample size issue: It is questionable that only small sample size of 3,000 is used for the “Proportion of Undernourished Population” indicator for crores population in India.
    • Child Wasting Discrepancy: The ministry highlights a significant disparity between the child wasting rate as per the Poshan Tracker (consistently below 7.2 percent) and the 18.7 percent reported in GHI 2023.
    • Undue link with Child mortality: It also challenges the notion that child mortality is solely an outcome of hunger.

    Conclusion

    • India’s ranking underscores the persistent challenges in addressing hunger and undernutrition.
    • The report serves as a stark reminder of the critical need to comprehensively tackle these issues, especially child wasting and undernourishment, to ensure the well-being of the nation’s population.

  • Supreme Court’s divided on Abortion: A Complex Legal Dilemma

    Central Idea

    • A Division Bench of two judges of the Supreme Court grappled with divergent views regarding the abortion of a 26-week pregnancy and the government’s stance to protect the “unborn child.”
    • The judges, unable to reach a consensus, opted to refer the case to the CJI to convene a three-judge Bench for further deliberation.

    Woman’s Plight for Abortion

    • A mother of two with her youngest child just a one-year-old infant, she asserted her desire for a medically induced abortion due to her mental health condition and her inability to care for a third child.
    • Her lawyer stressed the court should prioritize the mother’s well-being.
    • He emphasized the threat to her privacy and dignity and her conscious decision to not proceed with the pregnancy.

    Government’s Stance

    • Legal Argument: The Additional Solicitor General contended that the woman did not possess an “absolute right of autonomy” to exercise her reproductive rights in a manner that would compromise the rights of the unborn child.
    • MTP Act of 2021: Reference was made to the Medical Termination of Pregnancy (Amendment) Act of 2021, which extended the abortion deadline to 24 weeks in “exceptional circumstances,” primarily to save the mother’s life or in the case of fatal foetal deformity.

    Legal Debate

    • Bodily Autonomy vs. Foetal Rights: The core of the debate centred on whether, once a viable baby exists, the woman’s right to bodily autonomy or integrity should yield to the Act, curbing her fundamental right to choose.
    • Court’s Earlier Decision: On October 9, the Bench had initially permitted the medical termination in line with the woman’s wishes, following a report from an All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) medical board.

    Government’s Reversal

    • Government’s Appeal: Subsequently, the Union government filed an application, citing an expert doctor’s opinion received on October 10, which advocated for giving the child a chance to survive.
    • State’s Responsibility: The argument was that a categorical medical opinion had emerged, offering hope for the child’s survival, and placing a responsibility on the state.

    Judicial Opinions

    • Justice Kohli’s Stance: One judge aligned with the government’s position that the woman should not be allowed to terminate the pregnancy.
    • Justice Nagarathna’s Dissent: In contrast, the other judge dissented, asserting that the woman’s decision should be respected, considering her socio-economic circumstances, mental health, and the young age of her second child.

    Conclusion

    • The Supreme Court’s divided opinion on this intricate abortion case underscores the challenging balance between a woman’s right to make decisions about her body and the state’s interest in protecting the unborn.
    • As the case proceeds to a three-judge Bench, it raises broader questions about the legal and ethical complexities surrounding reproductive rights and foetal interests in India’s legal landscape.

  • Women’s Reservation Bill: A Fresh Start

    What’s the news?

    • The recently released 17th edition of the Global Gender Gap Report (2023) predicts it will take 131 years to close the global gender gap, rising to 149 years in South Asian countries, including India.

    Central idea

    • The recently released Global Gender Gap Report by the World Economic Forum, based on data from 146 countries, paints a grim picture. In light of this sobering reality, it is evident that affirmative action in the form of reservation is an essential step towards achieving gender equity and, ultimately, gender equality.

    Reservation: An Effective Tool for Equality?

    • Equality through Equity: Equity is the initial and essential step toward achieving true equality. In a world where gender discrimination has persisted for centuries, equitable policies like reservations are indispensable. They provide women with the opportunities they have long been denied and help level the playing field.
    • Affirmative Action through Reservations: Reservations are undeniably one of the most effective forms of affirmative action aimed at rectifying historical injustices and promoting equity. It serves as the cornerstone for achieving gender equality and is integral to dismantling deeply entrenched societal biases.
    • Inefficiency and incompetency Misconceptions: Critics claim that reservations result in inefficiency, but this assertion lacks evidence; competency gaps, if any, are temporary and can be overcome through skill development and experience for marginalized individuals, including women.
    • A Level Playing Field: Women are not seeking to compete against their own gender; instead, they aspire to operate in an environment where gender becomes entirely irrelevant, where meritocracy triumphs over discrimination.
    • Challenging the Competency Argument: Women consistently outperform men in academics, with higher college graduation rates and increasing representation in the workforce. The glaring gender gap emerges in leadership positions, not due to women’s incompetence but because entrenched male hegemony persists.

    Notable examples: Complexities of Gender and Leadership

    • Indira Gandhi’s Delayed Leadership: Despite her significant political advantages and early involvement in politics, Indira Gandhi did not become Prime Minister immediately after Jawaharlal Nehru’s death in 1964. She had to wait until the passing of Lal Bahadur Shastri in 1966 to assume the role.
    • Historical Opposition to Gender-Based Reservations: During the 1930s Round Table Conference in London, prominent women leaders like Sarojini Naidu and Begum Jahanara Shahnawaz presented a joint manifesto. They rejected the idea of providing either discriminatory or preferential treatment based on gender in legislative representation, indicating their opposition to gender-based reservation policies.
    • Diverse Perspectives Within the Women’s Movement: Begum Jahanara Shahnawaz and Radhabai Subbarayan advocated for a modest five percent reservation for women, while Sarojini Naidu opposed such reservations.

    A Fresh Start: Women’s Reservation Bill

    • Historic Moment: The Women’s Reservation Bill, Constitution (One Hundred Twenty-Eighth Amendment) Bill, 2023, cleared both Houses in September 2023, marking a historic achievement in India.
    • Delayed Gender Equality: Despite early universal adult suffrage, women’s role in shaping Indian politics has remained minimal, highlighting the significance of this legislation.
    • Global Youthful Leaders: In a trend of younger political leaders worldwide, questions arise about the potential for an ordinary Indian woman to aspire to the Prime Minister’s office, as seen in leaders like Jacinda Ardern.
    • Undervalued Women’s Leadership: While women are often recognized in supportive roles, their presence in leadership positions remains limited, as evident in the case of Hillary Clinton, whose qualifications were overshadowed by an inexperienced male opponent in a prominent democracy.

    Regressive Views and Misconceptions

    • Regressive Views on Gender Equality:
    • One of the most significant obstacles to gender equality is the presence of regressive views held by both men and women.
    • Even individuals who are considered progressive, like C. Rajagopalachari, have opposed women like Radhabai Subbarayan from contesting general seats.
    • Misconceptions about the Women’s Reservation Bill:
    • Mulayam Singh’s accusation in Parliament in 2010 further illustrates the challenge. He argued that the earlier version of the Women’s Reservation Bill would primarily benefit educated, urban, and elite women.
    • However, this viewpoint failed to recognize that the bill’s core objective was to provide opportunities for women who did not belong to privileged and elite classes.

    Changing landscape

    • The Prolonged Gender Gap: The persistence of regressive views and misconceptions has contributed to the enduring gender gap. Women have had to wait for an extended period to close this gap. The current Women’s Reservation Bill is considered the first step toward achieving gender parity.
    • Desire for Expedited Implementation: There is a hope that the implementation of the Women’s Reservation Bill will be expedited by readjusting seats based on the 1991 Census data, similar to the process followed for Scheduled Caste seats by the Delimitation Commission.

    Conclusion

    • The Women’s Reservation Bill is the first step toward achieving gender parity in India. It is time to correct historical wrongs, as women and society as a whole demand and deserve change. There is no reason to delay the journey towards true gender equality.

  • India’s Unemployment Rate Declines: PLFS 2022-2023

    Central Idea

    • The latest findings from the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS), conducted by the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO), reveal a decrease in India’s unemployment rate for the period between April and June 2023.
    • This encouraging trend is accompanied by improvements in the Labour Force Participation Rate (LFPR) and the Worker-Population Ratio (WPR), signifying positive shifts in the country’s labor market.

    About Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS)

    Objective Collect comprehensive labor market data in India.
    Conducted by Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MoSPI), Government of India.
    Replacement for Replaced earlier employment-unemployment surveys by NSSO.
    Frequency Conducted periodically, with rounds typically spanning a year.
    First Round Conducted in July 2017-2018, marking the survey’s initiation.
    Data Categories Employment status, unemployment rate, sector-wise employment, income, demographics, and more.
    Sampling Methodology Sample survey approach with data collected from households and individuals through a scientific sampling process.
    Policy Impact Informs government policies related to employment, labor market interventions, and economic planning.

     

    2022-23 Survey Overview

    • Scope: The national survey compiled data from 5,639 first-stage sampling units (FSUs) and encompassed 1,67,916 individuals residing in 44,190 urban households.
    • Age Group: The survey focused on individuals aged 15 years and above.

    Improvements in Urban Labour Force Participation

    • LFPR Uptick: The LFPR in urban areas exhibited growth, rising from 47.5% in April-June 2022 to 48.8% in the corresponding months of 2023 for individuals aged 15 years and above.
    • Gender Disparities: While the LFPR remained stable at approximately 73.5% for males during this period, it notably increased for females, climbing from 20.9% to 23.2%.

    Enhanced Worker-Population Ratio

    • WPR Gains: In urban areas, the WPR increased from 43.9% in April-June 2022 to 45.5% during the same period in 2023 for individuals aged 15 years and above.
    • Gender-Specific Improvements: For males, the WPR progressed from 68.3% to 69.2%, and for females, it surged from 18.9% to 21.1% over this timeframe.

    Decrease in Unemployment Rate

    • Declining Unemployment: The PLFS reported a diminishing trend in the Unemployment Rate (UR) for individuals aged 15 years and above in urban areas.
    • UR in Urban Areas: It decreased from 7.6% in April-June 2022 to 6.6% in April-June 2023.
    • Gender-Based UR: For males, the UR dropped from 7.1% to 5.9%, while for females, it decreased from 9.5% to 9.1% during this period.

    Comparative Analysis

    • Positive Trends: The report highlights improvements in key labor market indicators in urban areas when compared to the pre-pandemic period (April-June 2018 to October-December 2019).
    • LFPR Improvement: The LFPR ranged from 46.2% to 47.8% during the pre-pandemic period and has now reached 48.8%.
    • WPR Enhancement: Pre-pandemic WPR figures ranged from 41.8% to 44.1%, while the current WPR stands at 45.5%.
    • Lower UR: Unemployment rates during the pre-pandemic period fluctuated between 7.8% and 9.7%, with the latest survey reporting a lower UR of 6.6%. This rate is deemed favorable compared to the unemployment rates observed in the quarters preceding the pandemic.

    Conclusion

    • The Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS) results reflect positive developments in India’s labor market, marked by a decreasing unemployment rate, improved labor force participation, and enhanced worker-population ratios.
    • These trends indicate a resilient labor market recovery and may signify the nation’s progress towards economic stability and job creation.

    Back2Basics:

    • Labour Force Participation Rate (LFPR): LFPR is defined as the percentage of persons in labour force (i.e. working or seeking or available for work)in the population.
    • Worker Population Ratio (WPR): WPR is defined as the percentage of employed persons in the population.
    • Unemployment Rate (UR): UR is defined as the percentage of persons unemployed among the persons in the labour force.
    • Activity Status- Usual Status: The activity status of a person is determined on the basis of the activities pursued by the person during the specified reference period. When the activity status is determined on the basis of the reference period of last 365 days preceding the date of survey, it is known as the usual activity status of the person.
    • Activity Status- Current Weekly Status (CWS): The activity status determined on the basis of a reference period of last 7 days preceding the date of survey is known as the current weekly status (CWS) of the person.

  • Ageing World: Addressing Mental Health Challenges in the Elderly

    Elderly

    Central Idea

    • The world’s elderly population is larger than ever before, with 1.1 billion people aged 60 and above in 2022, constituting 13.9% of the population (UNFPA report).
    • By 2050, this number is projected to rise to 2.1 billion, accounting for 22% of the global population.

    Why discuss this?

    • India’s Scenario: India is no exception to this trend, with 149 million older adults (10.5%) in 2022, expected to increase to 347 million (20.8%) by 2050.
    • Longevity: People are living longer lives than ever before, underscoring the need to understand healthy ageing and address mental health issues in the elderly.

    Misconceptions about Ageing and Mental Health

    • Ageing as a Process: Ageing is a natural physiological process encompassing physical, social, and psychological dimensions. However, misconceptions and fears about ageing, particularly mental health concerns like depression, anxiety, and dementia, persist.
    • Heterogeneity: The ageing process varies among individuals, influenced by factors such as genetics, lifestyle, environment, and diseases. Not all older adults experience the same physical or mental changes.

    Social Challenges Faced by the Elderly

    • Social Isolation and Dependency: Many elderly individuals grapple with increased dependency, social isolation, poverty, ageism, and feelings of pessimism and nihilism.
    • Abuse and Neglect: Elderly individuals are vulnerable to emotional, physical, sexual, and financial abuse, often perpetrated by family members.
    • Inaccessible Infrastructure: India’s towns and cities often lack elder-friendly infrastructure, including ramps, handrails, pavements, and adequate public transport, making healthcare access a challenge.
    • Lack of Purpose: Many elderly men, especially after retirement, may feel unproductive and lost. Developing diverse interests earlier in life can mitigate the sense of purposelessness in retirement, reducing the risk of depression.

    Psychological Aspects of Ageing

    • Psychological Growth: As individuals age, they are expected to gain wisdom and a broader understanding of life’s challenges through personal or vicarious experiences.
    • Erik Erikson’s Theory: Erik Erikson proposed ‘Ego integrity versus Despair’ as the final psychosocial development stage in human life. It emphasizes viewing one’s life accomplishments positively to avoid despair.
    • Indian Cultural Emphasis: Indian culture underscores the importance of accepting the limitations that come with old age and renouncing responsibilities without suffering.

    Mental Health Challenges

    • Prevalence: Approximately 15% of elders in India (22 million individuals) experience serious mental illnesses such as depression, anxiety, dementia, and substance use disorders.
    • Treatment Gap: A significant treatment gap of 90% exists, largely due to a lack of awareness among the public and healthcare professionals.
    • Stigmatization: Stigma associated with both ageing and mental illness often leads to reluctance to admit mental health issues and seek treatment.
    • Poverty and Access: Many elderly individuals lack access to mental healthcare services due to poverty and limited availability of interventions, particularly in rural areas.

    Case Study: SCARF Partnership

    • Community Initiatives: The Schizophrenia Research Foundation (SCARF) has partnered with the Azim Premji Foundation to raise awareness about elder mental health in rural areas of Tamil Nadu, benefiting over 350 villages.
    • Indian Tradition of Joint Families: While joint families are becoming rarer, they offer advantages in terms of multi-generational interactions and support for elders.

    Preserving Cultural Traditions

    • Importance of Festivals and Rituals: Cultural traditions, including festivals and rituals, encourage socialization and cognitive engagement among elders.
    • Risk of Tradition Loss: Neglecting these traditions risks losing their potential protective effects on elderly mental health.

    Way forward

    • Individual Planning: Planning for old age with financial savings and lifestyle adjustments is crucial.
    • Educational Initiatives: Introducing the concept of healthy ageing in school curricula can promote awareness.
    • Community Services: Accessible mental health services for elders should be available at the community level.
    • Role of Retirement Homes: Retirement homes and elder care facilities, while providing care and reducing social isolation, need to address mental health issues urgently.
    • Collective Responsibility: Caring for the elderly is a collective responsibility that requires the concerted efforts of individuals, families, civic society, private organizations, NGOs, and the government.

    Conclusion

    • The ageing world presents both opportunities and challenges, with a growing elderly population that demands a holistic approach to mental health care, community support, and cultural preservation.
    • Addressing the mental health needs of the elderly is not only a matter of compassion but also a responsibility that encompasses various stakeholders and sectors of society.