Mentors Comments:
1. Briefly explain NRC and what the debate surrounding it
2. Discuss both the human rights and strategic dimensions of the debate
Answer:
The National Register of Citizens (NRC) exercise is among the most ambitious experiments the Indian state has undertaken. The NRC is the list of Indian citizens and was prepared in 1951, following the census of 1951. The process of NRC update was taken up in Assam as per a Supreme Court order in 2013. In order to wean out cases of illegal migration from Bangladesh and other adjoining areas, NRC updation was carried out under The Citizenship Act, 1955, and according to rules framed in the Assam Accord. Insecurity, uncertainty and trauma are looming large over sections of the people, mostly the very poor and deprived.
NRC as Human Rights issue-
If appeals are rejected in the final instance, they are declared as a ‘foreigner’ and packed off to jail – which serve as detention centres. In the six ‘Detention Centres’ in Assam, they have no prison rights, and are treated as ‘undertrials’.
Apart from deportation, the other option is large scale detention camps – which is an unlikely option for a civilised democracy like India.
They are condemned as ‘foreigners’ even though doubtful voters are legitimately under scrutiny because of technical or official anomalies in their documents.
Most affected are Bengali-speaking Hindus and Muslims. Reports suggest that the NRC process is directly having the most impact on religious and linguistic minorities.
Another option is instituting work permits, which would give them limited legal rights to work but ensure they have no political voice. However, it is not clear what will be the fate of children of such individuals.
More importantly, illegal migrants may find it even more difficult to procure Indian identity documents and avail all the rights and benefits due to all Indian citizens.
NRC as Strategic and Security issue-
The exclusion of people in such a large numbers has led to criticism of the NRC exercise. People fear that they might become stateless if their names are not included in the list. What is worrying is that is there has been no specific policy in ascertaining their fate.
Expelling them to Bangladesh is not an option since Dhaka has never accepted that they are its citizens or that there is a problem of illegal immigration. In the absence of a formal agreement, India cannot forcibly push the illegal migrants back into Bangladesh.
Moreover, raising this issue can also jeopardise relations with Dhaka. Such an attempt would not only damage bilateral relations but also sully the country’s image internationally.
The option of push-back is neither desired nor helpful in preventing infiltration. Previous experiences indicate that those who were pushed back, returned within few days.
Heavy-handedness on this issue could also harm warm ties between India and Bangladesh, an eventuality both neighbors would like to avoid.
The controversy over the Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2016 is a case in point, as some fear the introduction of the NRC might result in serious law and order issues.
Way forward
The Central Government should appoint a National Immigration Commission to frame a National Migration Policy and a National Refugee Policy. The Commission should examine ways of strengthening the Foreigners Act 1946,
as well as feasibility of Identity Cards for both citizens and non-citizens and Work Permits for migrants.
Border fencing in Assam must be completed forthwith on a war footing. The existing Border Security Force posts and the BSF water wing should be strengthened.
Our nationals in the border districts and for that matter in the whole State should be provided multipurpose photo identity card.
The ongoing NRC updating should be completed without delay and proper arrangement for the deportation of illegal migrants should be done.
The cooperation of the States will be key for the success of NRC. Support of the State governments will be vital, and reaching a consensus on the NRC will be a challenge. Already, State governments like West Bengal have expressed reservations on the issue. However, the NRC is a forward-looking step in documenting India’s citizens and detect
and deter infiltrators.
Comments
17 responses to “The debate around National Register of Citizens (NRC) should not be viewed as a human rights issue, but as a strategic and security issue. (250 Words)”
Payment ID: MOJO9731Y00N34245077
Use subheadings in your paragraphs.
Preferably use bullet points.
And underline your points in the answer.
This style is better suited for essay and not GS answers.
The 1st part of the answer (just after intro) is lengthy and suffers from over explanation. Keep that discussion short.
Apart from missing way forward, there is nothing wrong in the answer in terms of content.
The flow is decent in the main body.
Try to write in bullet format for better clarity.
Q3
The main requirement of the question is to discuss the NRC in terms of strategic and security issue.
For that you need to have multiple dimensions. But answer failed to emntion many of them like:
exclusion of people in such a large numbers; no specific policy; Dhaka has never accepted that they are its citizens; absence of a formal agreement; jeopardising relations with Dhaka; Heavy-handedness on this issue; controversy over the Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2016 etc.
The way forwards are very good and holistic.
The 1st part of the answer is decent in terms of structure and content
MOJO9801U00N04106675 Sir, Please Review My Answer.
Underline your points in the answer.
Better way forwards are needed in your answer.
Good main body in terms of explanation and content.
Language and structure are decent.
Presentation can be made better with time.
Read the model answer for way forwards.
MOJO9731E00D34250209
The content in the main body, specially the 1st part is fine
It is on the expected lines of the demand of the question.
But way forward is missing.
You have to give proper way forward balancing the security/strategy angle and humanitarian. issues
Very good explanation in the main body.
read the model answer for way forward.
MOJO9803C00N96073071
There are more angles that you can explore in the security and strategic issues discussion like no specific policy; Dhaka has never accepted that they are its citizens; absence of a formal agreement; jeopardising relations with Dhaka; Heavy-handedness on this issue.
Way forwards, albeit less, but are decent. For more of them, read the model answer.
The main body is good.
Content is deep and informative.
Good use of tabular format.
Many people are interested in the substance of your article, and I am quite impressed by it. I eagerly anticipate more excellent content.
fireboy and watergirl
After study a few of the websites for your internet site now, and I genuinely as if your technique for blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark internet site run 3 list and will be checking back soon. Pls look at my website likewise and let me know what you think.
I appreciate utilizing this website. Because it is both unique and advantageous. I also enjoy wearing it with outfits like this Kevin Hart Philadelphia Eagles Bomber Jacket and suggesting it to others.
Most of your blogs are quite educational, and I enjoy how unique you write. I’d like to tell you some information about this Emily In Paris Emily Cooper Red Sequin Blazer; if you’re into fashion, this is the perfect party attire.
Thanks for sharing this best stuff with us! Keep sharing! I am new in blog writing. All types of blogs and posts are not helpful for the readers. Here the author is giving good thoughts and suggestions to each and every reader through this article. pay to write my assignment literature-essay Quality of the content is the main element of the blog and this is the way of writing and presenting.
Your blog is really cool and great. I really appreciate your blog. I am glad to read your blog. Thanks for sharing the nice and cool post. Keep it up. I am waiting for Battery Injury Lawyer Toronto your next blog.
Your comments on the forum are very reasonable, hope you give your comments to make the website lol beans more and more perfect, sincerely thank you for your comments.