Civilsdaily

A Pandemic has broken out and the only key in sight is a drug developed by a group of doctors and scientists. The issue, however, is that the drug is not yet tested. If the standard testing protocol is adhered to, it would take at least a year to get the final approval for human consumption. By that time, the pandemic would have taken millions of lives already. The only possible way to expedite trials is to test the drug directly on human beings. It effectively means replacing animals with humans for trial. Furthermore, there would hardly be any volunteer for such trials. In the meantime, there is an idea floating around the countries. Why not choose the convicts of murders and rapes serving capital punishment for the trials? Even if they die during the trials, it would hardly be a loss to the society and if they survive, their lives would be of some worth for the society after-all. What do you think? Should prisoners be forced to undergo the trial? Examine and Substantiate your choice.10 Marks

Written by

Parth Verma

in

Mentor’s comment-

  • In the introduction briefly explain how the current case captures the ethical dilemma where lives of humans are weighed against the larger good of society.
  • In the body firstly, one must bring out the ethical values involved in the case such as – Violation of human rights,
    the debate of means vs. ends, concept of larger good etc.
    Then one should define the ethical dilemma involved in the situation.
    Identify the stakeholders involved; discuss the concerns associated with each of them.
    Examine the pros and cons of the move.
  • Conclude by suggesting a balanced solution to such a situation where ethical concerns of all the
    stakeholders are addressed. Justify your stand with suitable substantiation.

Comments

9 responses to “A Pandemic has broken out and the only key in sight is a drug developed by a group of doctors and scientists. The issue, however, is that the drug is not yet tested. If the standard testing protocol is adhered to, it would take at least a year to get the final approval for human consumption. By that time, the pandemic would have taken millions of lives already. The only possible way to expedite trials is to test the drug directly on human beings. It effectively means replacing animals with humans for trial. Furthermore, there would hardly be any volunteer for such trials. In the meantime, there is an idea floating around the countries. Why not choose the convicts of murders and rapes serving capital punishment for the trials? Even if they die during the trials, it would hardly be a loss to the society and if they survive, their lives would be of some worth for the society after-all. What do you think? Should prisoners be forced to undergo the trial? Examine and Substantiate your choice.10 Marks”

  1. Deepika Saini Avatar
    Deepika Saini

    Payment ID: #0000230867
    Please review

    1. Parth Verma Avatar
      Parth Verma

      Hi Deepika
      Lackluster introduction,in this you can start like this case study presents the ethical dilemma of deontology versus utilitarianism .
      You have mentioned the ethical values involved in the case in a good manner.
      Well-structured answer.
      Overall a decent attempt,keep it up!
      Avoid scribbling while writing.
      Persistence is the key to success,keep writing !

  2. Dakshina Moorthy Avatar
    Dakshina Moorthy

    Order no. #0000233081

    1. Parth Verma Avatar
      Parth Verma

      Hi Dakshina
      Introduction is missing in your answer.
      Add some more points in ‘ethical issues’ like- Means vs ends,violation of Human Rights of the under trials etc.
      Good use of diagram .
      Mention some other ways to overcome the criticality of situation like carry on clinical trials on lab animals bred for specific purpose and request the infected people to undergo clinical trials for new drug.
      Work on handwriting.
      Some good points but need to work on content.
      Keep writing,you will improve.

  3. NJ_00 Avatar
    NJ_00

    MOJO0206200D40884686

  4. NJ_00 Avatar
    NJ_00

    MJO0206200D40884686

    1. Parth Verma Avatar
      Parth Verma

      Hi
      Case study is about ethical dilemma nit about testing a new drug,
      rewrite your introduction.
      You have discussed the issues involved in a good manner.
      Mention some other ways to overcome the criticality of situation like carry on clinical trials on lab animals bred for specific purpose and request the infected people to undergo clinical trials for new drug etc.
      You can diversify your answer by mentioning Articles of the constitution.
      Need to work on basic grammar.
      Work hard,you can write good answers .

  5. Chester Avatar
    Chester

    please review

    1. Parth Verma Avatar
      Parth Verma

      Chester your answer is not legible,scan properly and send again.

Leave a Reply

More posts