Author: Root

  • Message from Civilsdaily

    Dear students,

    This week we launched the AWE program and we’ve seen a tremendous response. Though we had earlier rejected the idea of the daily answer writing, we now understand its importance especially for those who are not confident about going for the elaborate Mains Guidance Program.

    This month also saw the launch of our ios application. It is not perfect and is a work in progress. It has limited features but our ios audience will now have access to the most important content. An ipad compatible version is on its way.

    While many new initiatives are in the pipeline, we wanted to reach out to our students to what lies in our journey ahead.

    A traditional coaching would take over 1.5L for a 1-year program. Neither do they revamp their content depending upon observed trends, nor do they provide any personalized attention. you are stuck in a classroom full of 500 students. The teacher is accessible but it requires you to either catch him/her after the class or schedule an appointment. There is no standard 1-1 interaction time thus discouraging interactions.

    We want to change all of that. We are constantly working towards improving our offerings. We want to get better at guessing the precise questions that will be asked in both prelims and mains. We want our students to prepare better so they can handle adverse situations. Our Mains Guidance Program has institutionalized 1-1 interaction with the mentors. 

    Moreover, we are trying to get the best people with a proven track record to help you out. Vipul Sir conducting our Essay Program is an IPS officer while Pritam Sir for the AWE has appeared for 3 interviews. These are solid guys capable of uplifting your preparation to a whole new level.

    Not to forget, we are doing all this at almost 1/2 the price of similar programs.

    The goals we have set out to achieve are not easy. We want to spend more time talking to you, discussing your strategy and your level of preparedness. And we are nowhere near perfect. But we are evolving and strengthening our frameworks. In the coming days, you will see further fine-tuning of our initiatives. 

    Having said that, end of the day, our support has to be backed by ruthless efforts from you. You have to be consistent. We are always pushing our students to attempt tests, to be regular with lectures. Hopefully, such messages will put you back on track.

    Good luck.

  • Essay Writing Open Test

    As a part of our Essay Test Series, we are conducting an open test so students can get their hands dirty.

    1. Submissions are open till Thursday (1 November 2018) midnight. The sooner you submit, the earlier it will be reviewed
    2. The top 10 entries will be announced by next week
    3. Vipul Shrivastava Sir, IPS will discuss top 10 entries, what they did well, what they didn’t in a video discussion
    4. Submissions will be via comments (below this post)
    5. As you can see, the topics are in line with the pattern asked this year.

    Be innovative, make a point, get noticed

    Topics here

    Part A

    1. If you want to test a man’s character, give him power
    2. Should religion be limited to only private sphere

    Part B

    1. Should India adopt a more aggressive foreign policy
    2. Virtual reality: Boon or Bane

  • Answer Writing Enhancement (AWE) Program under the guidance of a UPSC veteran

    The only daily answer writing program that you’ll ever need. Under the aegis of Pritam Sir who has faced 3 UPSC interviews. Scored exceptionally well in all Essay and GS papers during his attempts.

    Daily Answer Writing for Mains has always been a point of contention at Civilsdaily. Essentially, it suffered from the following issues that made it a bad deal for the students.

    1. Forming questions from today’s news – Questions asked in UPSC are generally on an overarching theme. Very rarely will you find a question based on just one single op-ed or news item.
    2. Repetition of questions – As an issue updates with time, the answers become obsolete. That is why it is more important to frame questions on issues when 3-4 articles have already been written on them.

    Moreover, the issue that we see with other platforms is that they post similar questions every 2nd 3rd day. Follow the example at the end to understand what we are talking about

    1. Quality of both questions and answer checking – If we are making questions every day, they will not be intelligent. They will come directly from op-ed/news headings.
    2. The unreliability of peer reviews – Peer reviews cannot be relied upon and show a lot of variabilities. It is very important that you get feedback from someone experienced when it comes to your style, content, and presentation.

    However, we have come to realize that many students do see a value in practicing questions every day. It keeps the momentum going and incrementally builds a database of questions and answers that can be used for Mains.

    So we have tried to create a program that is truly effective.

    1. We have roped in a UPSC Veteran.

    2. We will ask 4 questions every day covering GS 1,2,3,4. Questions will cover both contemporary and static part. 1 question will be from ethics. Questions will not be specific or formed from op-ed titles. Instead, they will be broad-based aligned with the UPSC pattern.

    3. There will be a guaranteed detailed review of the answers written by the paid subscribers. Review of free subscribers will depend on the time available with mentors. Priority will be given to students who engage in peer reviews. 

    4. Approach and Model answer to be published and will be accessible to all. 

    5. Dedicated telegram groups for doubts and monthly call post writing answers for paid subscribers.

    6. Free Monthly AWE Magazine with questions and sample solutions.

     

    Program Details

    Duration of the Program: 10 months

    15th October – 28th Feb (Phase 1) – We stop 3 months before prelims. 

    15th June – 31st August (Phase 2) – We stop a month before mains. 

    7 month program. 

    1. The program will operate on the Weekdays. Saturdays and Sundays will be off to allow students to contribute to other programs during the weekends.

    2. Answers submitted after the last day of every month will not be considered for review. We do not guarantee when they will be reviewed but we will try to do so.

    3. The program will start from the 5th of every month. 1st-4th will be kept to clear the backlog.

    4. We will follow a monthly cycle. Meaning you enroll for a particular month. If you join on the 9th of December, you will have access to the month of December from the first day to the last day of December. It will *NOT* be from 9th December to 9th January. You will be expected to manage the time to submit the answers for the days you’ve missed.

    5. Students joining after 25th of a particular month can opt for AWE for the next month. Meaning – if you join on 26th of November, you have the option of enrolling for the month of December(1st to last day of December). Students who join on the 23rd of November will have close to 18 days to submit all answers for the month of November. We believe it is a good enough time to clear the backlog.  

    6. We are committed to providing you reviews ASAP. But we will keep a 1-week deadline for students submitting their answers on the same day and a 2-week deadline for students submitting their answers late. This is to ensure that we don’t compromise on the quality just to stick to a deadline. It is better to get a proper review than to get a quicker review.

    As you can see the focus of the programme will not be on the quantity but the quality of questions and model answers.

    Monthly Rs. 1k + taxes: Click2Join

    Yearly Rs 8K + taxes: Click2Join

    (Comes out to be Rs. 13/review which is nothing for the time and effort our mentors will be putting in)

    Example

    On a well-known site, the question on data localization has been asked 5 times in the last 2-3 months.

    Let us further illustrate our point with an example:

    Superfluous Questions from the well-known website

    Q.) What do you understand by data localisation? Discuss the importance of data localisation for India and analyze India’s present and proposed policies related to data localisation with respect to their effectiveness?

    Q.) The debate on data localisation must not be reduced to a simple binary of whether data localisation is good or bad. Comment.

    Repeated – Q.) What do you understand by data localisation? Discuss the importance of data localisation for India and analyze India’s present and proposed policies related to data localisation with respect to their effectiveness?

    Our Selected Question?

    Q.) What do you understand by Data localization? Recently Draft Data protection bill and Draft E-commerce policy has recommended localisation of data. Can data localization help protect Indian national and economic interests?

  • [Introductory Video] Target 160+ Essay Program under the aegis of VIPUL SHRIVASTAVA, IPS

    Essay Paper in UPSC can be tricky. It requires a mentor with both wide knowledge and a sense of what is expected by UPSC to score high marks.

    Hence, we roped in Vipul Sir. He is serving as an IPS officer presently.

    During his time, he had consistently scored the highest marks in Essay papers in consecutive attempts. He is extremely well read and his proximity to the government helps him identify key focus areas better than others.

    He stays humble and down to earth always willing to help young aspirants achieve their dreams. We couldn’t have asked for a better mentor than him. His video on tips is as follows –

     


    10% discount for all students joining on or before November 15

    30% discount for CD Prime Prelims Test Series Subscribers

    20% discount for other old students of our paid programs

    Join Comprehensive Essay Guidance Program here: Click2Join

    Join Sectional Tests Essay Guidance Program here: Click2Join


    The importance of essays for the exam cannot be underscored.

    While the performance of students is more or less the same in GS papers (especially 1,2,3), they have an excellent shot at scoring over 150+ in essays which could spearhead them to the top

    Practicing essays can also be the best way to consolidate what you’ve read so far and make good revision notes helping you for both prelims and mains GS papers as well

    Writing good essays can be very challenging. Time and again we’ve received many queries from students like

    1. Reviews provide additional points but don’t address the inherent shortcomings and deficiency in my skills

    2. Will reading ready-made sample essays help me prepare for essays?

    3. Don’t know how to start an essay, how to organize one.

    4. Can we do well in essays without practicing by re-using our GS paper knowledge alone?

    5. Is there a universal format that I can stick to?

    That’s why we’ve invested a great deal of energy to create a program the likes of which are offered by no one else

    What are we offering and how is it unique?

    We’ve innovated at every step of the process.

    1. More precise topic selection 

    Our research tells us there are 8 broad themes of essays being asked since 2010.

    1. Economy

    2. Polity

    3. Women Issues

    4. Education

    5. Science & Tech

    6. Philosophy

    7. IR

    8. Miscellaneous

    We plan to develop your competencies in each of these themes so you are extremely well prepared for the exam

    We will have 14 tests in total where you will get to write 28 essays. 8 tests before prelims and 6 tests after prelims. The 8 tests will be theme-wise. So you would’ve covered all the themes before prelims.

    2. An innovative methodology for reviews  

    Our biggest innovation lies in our review methodology.

    Specific portions of your essay will be highlighted with symbols to indicate issues in essay writing

    1. (X) Cross  – FUNDAMENTAL FLAWS like judgments/strong postures which need to be avoided at all costs.

    2. (*)Star -APPRECIATION for uniqueness.

    3. STRUCTURE is not maintained. Issues with Language and expression.

    4. GENERAL SUGGESTIONS for candidates.

    Along with this, Sir will also leave specific reviews on strengths and weaknesses

    Other institutes suggest additional points which can be googled by the student himself or point out superficial flaws like not sticking to the topic. They don’t necessarily highlight the shortcomings in the essay. This adds very little value to students. We go much beyond that and help students fix major flaws in their essays.

    3. Sample Structure, video solutions and personalized attention. 

    Sir will discuss the topic in considerable depth, appropriate structure, pitfalls to avoid, etc.

    Along with that, Sir will also discuss copies presenting different styles in which the essays could be attempted

    This component of the program is the most important.

    Students have an incorrect impression that going through a sample essay will somehow help them write better essays. This is absolutely incorrect

    While this strategy works for GS because there is a good chance of the question being repeated, with essays it is not true. You have to understand that the broader theme of the essay might be similar but the topics are always unique and require to be tackled differently.

    To develop your competency in tackling different topics, you have to be able to come up with appropriate structures This aspect of the program addresses this issue

    The expectation from you would be that you study the solutions in detail and try to address the shortcomings in your essays. Should doubts still persist, contact us and we will help get them resolved.

    4. Good essay copies 

    You will be provided with good essay copies to serve as sample answers. This is a better alternative than sample answers which are hastily written and at times not updated with the latest figures.

    5. Improvement tracking excel

    Your essays will be marked on the following parameters.

    1. Comprehension of the topic
    2. Language and Expression
    3. Structure and Organisation of thought.
    4. Objectivity and Biases. Balance of perception
    5. Attitude whether learner or judgmental
    6. Focus and attention
    7. Content and Source matter, Knowledge and information processing capability
    8. Ability to forge links in an interdisciplinary manner
    9. The simplicity of disposition
    10. Observational Skills

    We’d suggest students maintain a copy of the following excel sheet and keep a track of their performance.  https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12A0G3ypGls8J4tAzcvvg9bKol3vnqPuEj60Ap0E8yp4/edit?usp=sharing

    6. Besides these, you will be given the following 

    >CD Current Affairs Monthly Magazines.

    >Any additional material that we release for essays.

    What will be the program structure?

    Total of 14 tests (28 essays)

    The program starts on 27th October.

    Paper will be made live every Saturday.

    Before Prelims – 8 Tests (16 essays)

    -The first round of 4 tests will have topics from previous year papers that have relevance even today. This will establish your baseline performance.

    -It is very important that you understand the uniqueness of topics and expectation of the essays. No better way than to attempt previous year questions and get them reviewed.

    -Our reviews will help you deepen your understanding of the Essay Paper.

    The time-table is as follows

    27 Oct
    17 Nov
    8 Dec
    29 Dec
    19 Jan
    2nd Feb
    16 Feb
    2nd Mar

    After Prelims – 6 Tests (12 essays)

    -On topics with the highest probability of appearing in the exam


    We made the decision simpler for you

    10% discount for all students joining on or before November 15

    30% discount for CD Prime Prelims Test Series Subscribers

    20% discount for other old students of our paid programs

    Join Comprehensive Essay Guidance Program here (14k + taxes): Click2Join

    Join Sectional Tests Essay Guidance Program here (8k + taxes): Click2Join

  • App is down for Maintenance

    Hi All,

    Apologies for the inconvenience . The mobile app is down for routine maintenance.

    We will be back in 4-5 hours.

    We request you to please hold on for few hours and use website until we are back.

  • [Batch 2] Samachar Manthan Yearly Program 2018-19

    View the schedule for covering backlog of the previously held tests here: Click2View

    We are delighted to launch Batch 2 of Samachar Manthan Yearly Program for 2018-2019. All the students who were not able to join the first batch of the program and were waiting for next 6 months batch can join this yearly batch and cover up the tests and CA portion already covered and also get in sync with the program schedule. This will also help students get entire year CA at one place instead of two separate batches.

    The course is designed to help you develop a solid command on your newspaper reading and current affairs analyzing skills. Since it builds your core, it is important for both prelims and mains.

    10% discount for all students joining before 25th October (Date of start of yearly batch 2)

    Prime Students get their usual discount of 30%

    Join Batch 2 of Samachar Manthan Yearly 2018-19 (with Answer Writing Module) here: Click2Join

    Join Batch 2 of Samachar Manthan Yearly 2018-19 (only videos and notes) here: Click2Join

    For any queries, mail us on hello@civilsdaily.com or message on Whatsapp on 89299-87787


    What are we offering and how is it unique?

    1. Mentorship and guidance taken to a whole new level 

    Once you enroll, you’ll be assigned a Telegram group headed by Sajal Sir and rankers like Dr. Vipin Garg AIR 20, Swapnil Pawar AIR 525 and others.   Our past students have found this immensely beneficial.

    • A convenient way to resolve your doubts and queries.
    • You’ll be provided with value-added material which is very important.
    • You’ll have an ecosystem to study and learn from.
    • Above all, it will help you stay focused every day.

    Here’s what some of our students had to say about our mentorship.    

    2. 4 stage structure of Video->Notes->testing->review to perfect your preparation    The sequence of video->Notes->testing->review is the best way to ensure maximum retention and a rock solid preparation. Each component of the program has been meticulously crafted.

    3. Our video lectures and notes on weekly CA are brief but comprehensive   Packed 2 lectures of 2 hours each on a Weekly basis (1 on Sunday & 1 on Tuesday) which will focus on news and its importance from both prelims and mains perspective. We understand that the UPSC exam is a generalist exam.

    It’s important to cover more issues than to cover one issue in more depth. Hence, we maintain a fine balance of covering cover many important news items and have a detailed discussion on selected topics which require the same. This program will also help you understand how to utilize current affairs in all your prelims and mains papers. This ideology makes this course the best utilization of your time.

    Here’s what some of our students had to say about the lectures.

       

    4. Guest Lectures on specific issues by UPSC Toppers and other expert faculties   Besides the above, you will have access to our monthly magazines and weekly notes/links to important news/external material. You will have access to all modules included in our Mentorship program – Study-plan, strategy discussion, specific weaknesses, overall guidance. Since our mentors will have information about your performance

    5. Weekly Mains Test and Evaluation by our team of subject experts   The video and notes will be followed by a test released every weekend. It will have 10 high-quality questions. This will complete your study loop and enhance your retention. >Mains level questions with feedback. Sample review is attached.

         > Answer Enhancement We chose the Question & Answer format because it is perfectly aligned with the requirements of the exam. Having information is very different from presenting it in an answer with a proper structure. This will help in better retention of prelims specific information and prepare a solid ground for your mains prep. After every 2nd test you attempt, you can reach out to our mentors for personalized feedback.

       6. Current Affairs Monthly Prelims Test package This was a feedback we received from many students. They wanted appropriate focus on the current affairs program.

    We are also providing 10 Prelims CA tests along with this package.


    Join Batch 2 of Samachar Manthan Yearly 2018-19 (with Answer Writing Module) here: Click2Join

    Join Batch 2 of Samachar Manthan Yearly 2018-19 (only videos and notes) here: Click2Join

     

    10% discount for all students joining before 25th October (Date of start of yearly batch 2)

    Prime Students get their usual discount of 30%

    For any queries, mail us on hello@civilsdaily.com or message on Whatsapp on 89299-87787

  • UPSC Mains 2018 GS Paper 4 – Solutions, Sample Structures and Repeated Questions from CD Mains TS

    In GS 4, close to 9 out of 13 questions from Section A came from our 3 Full-Length-Tests. We obviously couldn’t predict the precise quotes and generic questions, but our students could easily attempt those.

    *These are not solutions but pointers/line of thought to be followed.

    **Please do not look for a precise 1-1 match between the UPSC paper and our Test Series. The comparison is there to help you get a feel of the approach we follow while designing questions in our TS.
    ***In the comments section, let us know interesting points along with the reasons that could enrich these answers.


    Section A
    1) (a) State the three basic values, universal in nature, in the context of civil services and bring out their importance. (150 words) 10
    Various questions have been asked in our tests on a similar theme. We have provided reviews asking students to quote committees, contemporary examples, quotes to highlight the importance and score maximum marks.
    You could easily score 7+ marks if you had gone through our solutions + feedback on answers.
    Round1 GS4
    2. Examine the relevance of the following in the context of civil service citing examples. (10 Marks)
    a)Probity
    b)Taking Accountability
    c)Delegation
    d)Developing Others
    e)Consultation and Consensus Building
    Round2 GS4
    1.a. Accountability is the need of the hour for Civil Servants. Analyze. (10 marks)
    (b) Distinguish between “Code of ethics” and “Code of conduct” with suitable examples.
    Round2 GS4
    5.a. What is the difference between Code of Ethics and Code of Conduct. Should Code of Ethics be preferred over Code of Conduct?  (150 words) 10
    Should Code of Ethics be preferred over Code of Conduct? – asked in our TS directly. Our TS question was more nuanced and required critical analysis. On the contrary, the actual exam question was quite simple. 
    Approach
    Start by defining Code of Conduct first. It is a set of instructions that ensure
    Say it is being governed by All India Services (Conduct) Rules,1968
    https://www.civilsdaily.com/reforms-needed-in-civil-services-2nd-arc-report-and-other-committee-recommendations/
    2) (a) What is mean by public interest? What are the principles and procedures to be followed by the civil servants in public interest? (150 words) 10
    Many case-studies involving a conflict of interest between public interest and private interests. 
    (b) “The Right to Information Act is not all about citizens’ empowerment alone, it essentially redefines the concept of accountability. Discuss. (150 words) 10
    A case study of RTI was asked in our TS. No specific question was asked. 
    3) (a) What is meant by conflict of interest? Illustrate with examples, the difference between the actual and potential conflicts of interest. (150 words) 10
    There are many case studies on conflict of interest across the 3 tests explicitly mentioning the term. This would’ve given you a fair idea of conflict of interest and also helped you come up with very effective examples for both actual and potential conflicts of interest.
    Approach
    Define conflict of interest
    Conflict of interest refers to conflicts between one’s professional responsibilities as a public servant or as a member of an organization and ones private interests as an individual. They are the most obvious examples of an ethical dilemma.
    An actual conflict of interest –
    You are in the interview board of a selection committee. Your family member is appearing for the same interview.
    This scenario represents an actual conflict of interest. Your responsibilities demand you to demonstrate neutrality. However,  with your family member being present it is going to be very difficult to do the same.
    conflict of interest can be managed appropriately by recusal (withdrawal) – that is, by having another official temporarily sit in the interview panel.
    potential conflicts of interest
    A “potential conflict of interest” is different from actual conflict of interest in the sense that they may arise at some time in the future.
    If a person agrees to give a contract to a party without holding competitive budding and justifying it on grounds of superior technology/first come first serve, etc.
    The person might not have gained anything from the contract. The contractor might not be known to the person. But following the above process gives rise to a potential conflict of interest.
    At the same time, many situations might seem like conflicts of interest but are actually not. Eg. If you are a teacher and you see your son cheating, it should seem like a conflict of interest but it is not. Punishing your son, not treating him differently from other students will help him evolve as someone more responsible and aware of what needs to be done.
    (b) “In looking for people to hire, you look for three qualities: integrity, intelligence and energy. And if they do not have the first, the other two will kill you.” – Warren Buffett
    What do you understand by this statement in the present-day scenario? Explain. (150 words) 10
    We asked a question on Probity but not Integrity. Probity is a more difficult term to bluff around, hence we stressed on that. The question talks about the importance of integrity. At the same time, it is asking you to discuss in the present-day context.
    Approach
    Integrity not only means upholding the values of public or private service like honesty, decency, frankness, fairness but also ensuring that consistency is maintained in exercising these values. It ensures reliability and establishes one as trustworthy. If one has acted in a certain manner, then it is more likely that he/she will repeat it. ARC expands the meaning of the concept of the integrity of public servants need to be amplified. While financial integrity is one element of it, functional integrity and a high level of efficiency at work are equally important.
    The above statement highlights the importance of integrity. It says that without it, intelligence and energy can be detrimental to an organization and the person himself.
    An intelligent and energetic man is capable enough to do unethical tasks and tricks a system. Without integrity, he is more likely to do so.
    Take the eg. of Mallya or Nirav Modi. Both intelligent and energetic businessmen who have built their empires. Unfortunately, they lacked integrity and hence it proved dangerous both of them and the country.
    Hence, integrity holds primacy over all other values. Hiring someone smart might seem like the right thing to do in the short run.
    4) (a) “In doing a good thing, everything is permitted which is not prohibited expressly or by clear implication”. Examine the statement with suitable examples in the context of a public servant discharging his/her duties. (150 words) 10
    Approach
    The question focuses on widespread discretion a public servant enjoys and yet they have become more cautious in discharging their duties and taking risks due to the 4Cs – CVC, Courts, CBI, CAG.
    Laws and rulebooks lay down broad-based restrictions. They can neither cover all circumstances as it is impossible to foresee them nor can they be very detailed to become restrictive in scope.
    Hence, everything outside the restrictions is permitted.
    A civil servant should use his good judgment to ensure that he does his public duty and works in the best interest of the public even if it involves the fear of coming under scrutiny by the 4Cs. His aim should not be to keep himself away from any controversy and unforeseen legal hassles.
    Eg. Tamil Nadu IAS officer had pointed out the lapses in urban planning and construction which led to his transfer. Once urban flooding happened, he stood vindicated.
    Similarly, the courts giving relief to upright IAS officers of UP and Bihar in discharging their duties highlight the great work done by them.
    The need of the hour is civil servants taking quick decisions, ensuring that files and proposals are not stuck and evolving effective means for private sector participation.
    (b) With regard to the morality of actions, one view is that means is of paramount importance and the other view is that the ends justify the means. Which view do you think is more appropriate? Justify your answer. (150 words) 10
    The same question with more complex wordings was asked in our test. Go through it and our model answer provided in our TS. We have further left reviews highlighting concepts of Absolutism
    Round 1 GS 4
    6. a. Is it as much of a mistake to define ‘right action’ as to define ‘good consequence’? (10)
    Model Answer for the TS
    The above statement captures the essence of consequentialist and deontological approaches. Consequentialism talks of a good consequence regardless of whether the action was right or wrong. It say ends justify means. Deontological view talks of the right action regardless of the end consequence. Meaning, end is not important, it’s more important to follow the right path. As an eg. – the Utilitarian perspective is consequentialist while Kant’s categorical imperative is deontological. Both theories have their flaws. Utilitarian perspective is only concerned with the greatest happiness of the greatest number. If killing a person gave happiness to 100 other people, it would be just to execute that one person. On the other hand, Kant’s categorical imperative would condemn lying but there are many instances where lying can save one’s life. So it cannot be universally applied.
    From the above, we cannot say that defining ‘right action’ is a mistake and ‘good consequence’ should have primacy. There cannot be a narrative that can be universally applied. Their applicability depends on a case by case scenario. Gandhi was of the opinion that not only are the ends important but so are the means. It is not enough to fight for freedom but to have Dharma on our side which means right action. This implies that the right action and good consequence need not be in contradiction. They cannot be seen in dichotomous terms. A harmonious synthesis of the two is always possible and one should always think of solutions that do justice to both means and ends.
    5) (a) Suppose the Government of India is thinking of constructing a dam in a mountain valley bond by forests and inhabited by ethnic communities. What rational policy should it resort to in dealing with unforeseen contingencies (150 words) 10
    Question on EIA. Elaborate on the points below –
    Screening often results in the categorization of the project and from this a decision is made on whether or not a full EIA is to be carried out. Here I’ll decide that a full EIA is be carried out.
    Scoping is the process of determining which are the most critical issues to study.
    Here I’ll ensure community participation. Come up with a detailed analysis of the impact of constructing the Dam.
    -List of People who are affected by the project will be drawn and they need to hear about it as soon as possible.
    -The impact on the environment, flora, and fauna of the region will have to be laid out.
    -The costs to the government will be communicated.
    If the community agrees with the project design and are ready to accept the terms offered by the government, we will move ahead. Else changes in design of the project, looking at alternate venues will be considered and the same step will be repeated.
    Detailed prediction and mitigation studies follow scoping and are carried out in parallel with feasibility studies.
    The main output report is called an Environmental Impact Statement and contains a detailed plan for managing and monitoring environmental impacts both during and after implementation.
    Finally, an audit of the EIA process is carried out sometime after implementation. The audit serves a useful feedback and learning function.
    (b) Explain the process of resolving ethical dilemmas in Public Administration. (150 words) 10
    Throughout our test series, we have tested on your knowledge of attempting questions around virtue ethics, consequentialist ethics and deontological ethics. Utilitarian, Kantian, Gandhian principles.
    This question primarily wanted to assess your understanding of the above theories and their limitations and understand that they need to be applied on a case by case basis.
    6) What do each of the following quotations mean to you in the present context?
    (a) “The true rule, in determining to embrace, or reject anything, is not whether it has any evil in it; but whether it has more evil than good. There are few things wholly evil or wholly good. Almost everything, especially of governmental policy, is an inseparable compound of the two; so that our best judgement of the preponderance between them is continually demanded. ”Abraham Lincoln ( 150 words)10
    (b) “Anger and intolerance are the enemies of correct understanding. “ _ Mahatma Gandhi (150 words) 10
    Since a question on intolerance has been so common, we tried to ask a more difficult question on dissent.
    Round 2 GS4
    2.a. What do you understand by dissent and why is it important for a democracy. With examples explain why dissent needs more focus in India?
    Approach
    In this question talk about how emotional intelligence is hit if you are angry and intolerance. Hence it distorts our understanding of self and the environment, makes us draw wrong conclusions.
    Provide relevant examples.
    In the model answer, we had provided quotes that could’ve been used here –
    Voltaire had remarked – I might disapprove of what you say but defend to death your right to say so. We as individuals, society and a country have to realise this.
    Such tolerance can help us understand different perspectives to arrive at a more correct, accurate understanding.
    (c) “Falsehood takes the place of truth when it results in unblemished common good.” _ Tirukkural (150 words)10
    Approach
    The above quote is similar to Gita’s quote that one lie spoken to benefit someone is greater than 100 truths.
    Talk of consequentialism. That ends justify the means.
    Counter by proposing deontological ethics.
    Finally saying both means and ends are necessary. Lying to achieve ends might not always be a preferred way.
    Check out GS 1 Solutions here – 
    https://www.civilsdaily.com/upsc-mains-2018-gs-paper-1-solutions-sample-structures-and-repeated-questions/
  • UPSC Mains 2018 GS Paper 1 – Solutions, Sample Structures and Repeated Questions from CD Mains TS

    Click here to view the schedule + detailed syllabus with sources

    Click here to know the features and enroll.


    Our Mains Test Series had the highest hit ratio among all the Test Series. In GS 1 itself, close to 13 questions came directly from our 3 Full-Length-Tests(60 questions). If you followed our website/study material, you would’ve written above average answers for all questions. YES! All questions.     

    *These are not solutions but pointers/line of thought to be followed.

    **Please do not look for a precise 1-1 match between the UPSC paper and our Test Series. The comparison is there to help you get a feel of the approach we follow in our Test Series.
    ***In the comments section, let us know interesting points along with the reasons that could enrich these answers.

    1) Safeguarding the Indian art heritage is the need of the moment. Comment (10 marks)

    We had written a note on heritage 2 years back.

    1. What is heritage erosion and how can we manage it?

    2. What are the components of heritage?

    It was accessible via clicking on Paper 1 on left sidebar – https://www.civilsdaily.com/gspaper/paper1/

    We can’t claim this question but at the same time, we will work to ensure that good content from which questions are expected are made more accessible before the exams.

    Approach

    >Introduction – Start with defining Indian Art Heritage.

    The term heritage has wide connotations spanning across nature, culture, food and other dimensions. Art heritage primarily refers to the tangible heritage comprising of

    1.Paintings and art forms

    2.Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites

    3.Sculpture

    4.Scriptures

    5.Artifacts

    Preserving our heritage is enshrined as a Fundamental Duty in our Constitution

    Threats to Art Heritage

    1.Lack of public awareness -This makes the local administrator break the buildings and replace it with other structures.

    2.Duplication of paintings and art forms

    3.Theft

    4.Smuggling

    Reasons for safeguarding

    Cultural

    1.Identity and pride of our country.

    Economic

    2. Tourism involves around monuments.

    3. Infrastructure development takes place in and around the areas. Eg. Khajuraho despite being a small village has excellent infrastructure.

    4. Creates jobs.

    Social

    5. It creates a feeling of community, a sense of attachment. enhances a sense of belonging.

    Way forward

    Strengthening institutions

    -Ministry of Culture, ASI, Museums, Archives, etc.

    Cultural awareness programs.

    -Curriculum modification – Identification and inclusion of heritage as an asset in school, Open departments of Heritage management on the lines of Ahmedabad University

    -Introduction of a compulsory offline and online training for tourism purposes willing to undertake ventures.

    -Heritage depiction and promotion through immersive technology & augmented reality

    -Re-Classify heritage and announce awards for people with exceptional heritage sense.

    Adaptive reuse of heritage sites

    -Restoring the historical sites in the form of festivals and inducing festivity link perceptions.

     

    2) Assess the importance of the accounts of the Chinese and Arab travelers in the reconstruction of the history of India. (10 marks)

    Similar question from Test Series – Round1 GS1

    19. Greek and Roman literary account proved extremely useful in writing the history of Ancient India? Discuss.

    This shows how our thinking is on the spot. Make a note of this question. Absolutely important for prelims and mains next year.

    Approach

    Foreign travelers in the past played a more profound role than tourists of the present day. They were agents of civilizational contact and exchange, bringing with them new ideas, skills and technologies and returning with new knowledge.

    They left elaborate records of their travels often mentioning facts that native writers simply took for granted and hence ignored.

    Chinese travelers visited India during the Gupta and Post-Gupta period when Buddhism was prominent while notable Arab travelers can be seen during the medieval period with the advent of Islamic rulers. Few important accounts are as follows.

    Fa-Hien – Account of the Gupta Period

    An extensive account of society. first to talk about the caste system and shudras. Shudras were kept outside the town and entered the town by making a noise with a stick. Fahien had also mentioned about Shaiv and Vaishnav religion.

    Comprehensive eyewitness account of the history and customs of Central Asia and India.

    Economic account. Stated that income of the government was mainly based on the revenue taxes which were one-sixth of the total production.

    Similarly, talk about

    Hsuan-Tsang – Account during Harshavardhan’s era.

    Al Beruni (AD 973 – 1048) – Mahmud of Ghazni. Culture of Indians especially the hindus.

    Abdur Razzaq – Vijaynagar Empire

    Conclusion – They provide enriching narratives highlighting the diversity of our past.

     

    3) Throw light on the significance of the thoughts of Mahatma Gandhi in the present times. (10 marks)

    Similar question from Test Series – Round3 GS1

    5. By offering an ideological critique of the western civilization in its modern phase, Gandhiji was effectively contesting the moral legitimacy of the Raj that rested on a stated assumption of the superiority of the west. Comment (10 marks)

    One of the most important topics from UPSC perspective relevant for Essay, GS1, GS4. A more difficult question was asked in the test series.

    Approach

    Start with a line like Gandhi is regarded as the greatest Indian since Gautama Buddha and the greatest man since Jesus Christ.

    Elaborate on the following writing 1-2 lines and you’ll score an 8/10.

    1.Truth

    2.Ahimsa – believer in peace and harmony.

    3.Satyagraha

    4.Swaraj – Multidimensional concept spanning political, cultural, economic and technological spheres.

    5.Dharma – Multidimensional concept meaning many things depending upon the situation – obedience to law, morality, being virtuous, etc.

    6.Trusteeship Model – Though a failed model but inspired Corporate Social Responsibility. The best companies in the world invest heavily in social projects.

    7.Ram Rajya/ Decentralized polity – Democracy is about giving power to the masses. Debates around strengthening the Panchayati Raj system all based on this ideal.

    8.Sarvodaya and Antyodaya

    9.Campaign against untouchability

    10.Campaign for cleanliness – Inspired swatch bharat.

    11.Ethical journalism – Gandhi was a journalist at heart. He published 4 newspapers and used it as a medium to generate awareness.

    12.Opposition to western materialism, appreciation for sciences and bringing back spiritualism from our past.

    4) Why is the Indian Regional Navigational Satellite System (IRNSS) needed? How does it help in navigation? (10 marks)

    Straightforward question.

    Approach

    IRNSS constellation of eight satellites, NavIC. Three satellites are located in suitable orbital slots in the geostationary orbit and the remaining four are located in geosynchronous orbits with the required inclination and equatorial crossings in two different planes.

    It is needed for the following

    • Terrestrial, Aerial and Marine Navigation
    • Disaster Management
    • Vehicle tracking and fleet management
    • Integration with mobile phones
    • Precise Timing
    • Mapping and Geodetic data capture
    • Terrestrial navigation aid for hikers and travelers
    • Visual and voice navigation for drivers

    Besides the above applications, it has implications for India’s security. It will help India become self-reliant to keep a close watch on its boundaries and remove its dependence on US-based GPS. Hence, its military applications remain important.

    It is also playing an important role in India’s softer diplomacy by providing services to our neighboring countries.

    It helps in navigation in the following manner

    >It uses the principle of triangulation.

    It requires only three satellites to provide a precise location. The other satellites add to the accuracy.

    <draw a diagram with the intersection of 3 circles>

    If you are positioned somewhere on Earth with three satellites in the sky and if you know how far away you are from satellite A, then you know you must be located somewhere on the red circle. If you do the same for satellites B and C, you can work out your location by seeing where the three circles intersect.

    5) Why is India taking a keen interest in the Arctic Region? (10 marks)

    Similar question from Test Series – Round 3 GS 3. 

    Q2 As the Arctic has continued to warm and the temperature difference relative to the equator has reduced, many strange climate anomalies have been witnessed around the world. Examine. 

    Previously asked mains question on Arctic Council. Since questions are hardly repeated we had left this question.

    Approach

    The introduction can start with the definition

    Arctic Region refers to the polar region located at the northernmost part of Earth. It consists of the Arctic Ocean, adjacent seas, and parts of countries like Alaska, Finland, Greenland, etc.

    Once ignored because of the prevalence of ice, it has started gaining importance due to the melting of ice caps because of global warming. Its implications have caught India’s interest.

    1. Climate change concerns – Global Warming leading to the melting of ice can lead to the release of more methane and CO2 accelerating Global Warming. This can further lead to a rise in sea levels across the globe impacting India as it remains surrounded by water on 3 sides. This concern needs to be addressed.

    2. Navigation routes – New and shorter strategic sea routes that will change the pattern of energy flow on sea lanes of communications (SLOCs).

    3.Oil Beds – Arctic seabed may contain substantial oil fields which may become accessible if the ice covering them melts.

    4. Finally, Arctic Region is not considered as a global common and its discourse remains dominated by the Arctic Five countries and the Arctic Council. This doesn’t work in India’s favor.

    Hence, it’s in India’s interest to make Arctic talks more accessible. With Russia, China already laying their claims on various parts of the region, India should try to push its agenda in the Arctic Council. It should try to ensure that developing countries have a say in the matters of Arctic Region. This will not only ensure that its economic, security and environmental interests are protected but will see India play a leadership role in promoting south-south solidarity.

    6) Define mantle plume and explain its role in plate tectonics. (10 marks)

    Similar question from Test Series – Round1 GS1 

    16. Without magma man’s survival and progress would have been difficult. Comment.

    17. The theory of plate tectonics has greatly contributed to our understanding of the earth. Comment.

    Though not precisely the same question, attempting the test would’ve ensured that you don’t leave the question blank and write some quality points on plate tectonics and mantle.

    7) What are the consequences of spreading of ‘Dead Zones’ on marine ecosystem? (10 marks)

    8) “Caste system is assuming new identities and associational forms. Hence, the caste system cannot be eradicated in India.” Comment. (10 marks)

    Similar question from Test Series – Round 2 GS1 

    Q.18) Caste in its old form is irrelevant and cannot exist in the modern or contemporary Indian society. Comment(15)

    Hope you appreciate the similarities in the questions. We asked Caste in its old form is irrelevant and the question said caste system is assuming new identities and associational forms. Had you gone through the model answer, you would’ve gotten some rich points to attempt this question.

    9) ‘Despite the implementation of various programmes for the eradication of poverty by the government in India, poverty is still existing’. Explain by giving reasons. (10 marks).

    Very general question. Asked across our TS in GS1, GS2, GS3 in various forms linking with lack of female participation, etc.

    10) How the Indian concept of secularism different from the western model of secularism? Discuss. (10 marks)

    Similar question from Test Series Round 2 GS1

    Q.19) India needs a reinvented secularism 2.0 rooted in the complete separation of religion and state. Critically comment(15)

    Approach

    Secularism broadly refers to the separation of religion from state and its confinement to the private sphere. It’s a western construct whose roots can be traced back to the treaty of Westphalia which called for state sovereignty and its separation of religion. However, the relationship between religion and states remain complex.

    There are 2 prominent models of secularism regarded as western models

    1.France –> wall of separation model – which calls for a water-tight separation between the religion and state exists. The state actively tries to confine people’s religion to their private spheres and bans public appearances. Eg. banning burkinis, hijab, etc.

    2.USA -> no-preference model – which calls for equal treatment of all religions by the state and no preferential treatment. In USA, you have every right to wear your religion in public.

    The version of Indian Secularism has been a matter of intense debate. Secularism is a part of the Preamble and the Constitution calls for no discrimination on the basis of religion. However, it also allows the state to intervene in matters of religion via Art. 25-30. The DPSP for establishing UCC also goes against the principles of Secularism.

    Some matters where the state has interfered

    1.The Hindu Marriage Act.
    2.The Triple Talaq Ban
    3.Jallikatu, Temple Entry, etc.
    Hence one can see it is neither a wall of separation model nor a no-preference model.
    The Indian Secularism can be best described as that of ‘Principled Distance’. The doctrine of Principled Distance allows states to interfere in matters of religion to stop discrimination and ensure that all religion are treated equally.

    11) The Bhakti movement received a remarkable re-orientation with the advent of Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. Discuss. (15 marks)

    Similar question from Test Series – Round3 G S1

    4.Kabir was one of the chief exponents of the Bhakti movement in the medieval period. Discuss the Relevance of the teachings of Kabir in Contemporary India? (10 marks)

    Instead of Chaitanya, we asked Kabir. We could’ve asked any Bhakti saint like Dadu Dayal, Tulsi Das. We went with Kabir so students could at least attempt Kabir if it was asked in the exam.

    Approach

    Chaitanya – Bengal+Orissa. He takes Bhakti Movement to the east of India where it flourishes.
    Popularised Kirtans
    Founder of Gaudiya Samaj. Gaudiya Vaishnavism.
    Gaudiya Nritya is one of the dances accepted in the UNESCO world heritage.
    Bhidabhida philosophy school.

    Leads to many important cultural developments in east India.

    15) Defining blue revolution, explain the problems and strategies for pisciculture development in India. (15 marks)

    Straightforward question asked in GS3. 

    16) What is the significance of Industrial Corridors in India? Identifying industrial corridors, explain their main characteristics. (15 marks)

    Approach

    Industrial Corridors are envisioned to create a strong economic base with the globally competitive environment and state-of-the-art infrastructure to activate local commerce, enhance foreign investments and attain sustainable development
    Their significance is as follows
    1. The corridor approach is a proven concept to ensure industrial development in under-utilized regions.
    2. Integration between industry and infrastructure
    -World class infrastructure such as high-speed transportation (rail, road) network, ports with state-of-the-art cargo handling equipment, modern airports, special economic regions/ industrial areas, logistic parks/transshipment hubs, knowledge parks focused on feeding industrial needs, complementary infrastructure such as townships/ real estate, and other urban infrastructure along with enabling policy framework.
    3. Opportunities for private sector investment in the provision of various infrastructure projects associated with the exploitation industrial opportunity. Enhancing ‘Make in India’.
    4. Ensure smooth access to industrial production units, decreased transportation, and communications costs, improved delivery time and reduction in inventory cost. The strategy of an industrial corridor is thus intended to develop a sound industrial base, served by world-class competitive infrastructure as a prerequisite for attracting investments into export-oriented industries and manufacturing.
    5. Technological Prowess.
    6. Social Upliftment.

    Write a few unique points about the following, the involvement of foreign organizations, etc.
    Delhi Mumbai Industrial Corridor
    Chennai Bengaluru Industrial Corridor
    Bengaluru Mumbai Economic Corridor
    Amritsar Kolkata Industrial Corridor
    East Coast Economic Corridor

    17) Mention core strategies for the transformation of aspirational districts in India and explain the nature of convergence, collaboration, and competition for its success. (15 marks)

    18) ‘Women’s movement in India has not addressed the issues of women of lower social strata.’ Substantiate your view. (15 marks)

    Approach

    Women’s movement in India has come a long way since the humble efforts of Raja Ram Mohan Roy and Ishwar Chand Vidyasagar to fight for women’s rights.

    In their time, it was the upper social strata who were subjected to inhumane practices like Sati. However, the scenario seems to have changed today. Women of lower social strata either belonging to lower castes, minority religion or economically backward regions continue to face hardships.

    Political sphere
    -elite women with influence occupying offices in governments, panchayats and other bodies.
    Economic sphere
    -glass ceiling breaking in corporations like google, microsoft. But the wage gap remains prominent for semi-skilled and unskilled workers.
    Social sphere
    The worst forms of Patriarchy is more prominent in the lower social strata. Haryana with primarily agricultural economy had the poorest child sex ratio.
    Education sphere
    Access to both lower and higher education remains limited.

    Women empowerment can happen when everyone works towards it – the government, society, families, and individuals.

    The government programs targeted towards women empowerment have started to bear fruits. Beti Bachao Beti Padhao, Dhanlaxmi scheme and others have acted as catalysts to promote behavior and mindset changes.

    The society should be forthcoming to support women. The story of Phogat Sisters tells us how women can bring accolades to the country. All started with a father, an individual questioning established norms.

    19) ‘Globalisation is generally said to promote cultural homogenisation but due to this cultural specificities appear to be strengthened in the Indian society.’ Elucidate.

    Similar question from Test Series – Round 2 GS1

    18. While Globalization has destroyed many traditional practices and Industries in India it has also given new lease of life to some of them who were on the ventilator. Examine. (15)

    We did not ask a question on Globalization and culture as it had been asked by UPSC before. Hence we went with other dimension of Globalization. 

    Approach

    Globalisation refers to the increases interconnected due to technological advancements leading to a shrinking of time and space and flattening of the world. Though thought of as an economic phenomena, it is now accepted to impact all spheres of life – political, social and cultural.

    In its initial days, globalisation was equated with westernisation or americanisation which meant that the culture of the west was spreading across the globe. One could travel to new york and new delhi and find them to be similar in almost all spheres including culture. Thus globalisation was supposed to have a homogenizing tendency.

    However, the relationship between globalisation and culture is a complex one. Globalisation has not been able to replace old existing cultures. Instead evidence suggests that globalisation has strengthened them and even modified them.

    1.Indian cuisines traveling to the west
    Indian food restaurants are now available all around the world. Indian curries and masalas have also become a part of our soft power diplomacy.
    2.Ancient indian practices like yoga and ayurveda being adopted around the globe.
    People are now looking for the most authentic experience.
    3. With the advent of ecommerce, global value chains and internet, local arts and crafts are also
    Top hotels of the world are buying handwoven Indian designs sourced from traditional communities. Ikkat, block painting, etc designs are gaining popularity world over.
    4.Traditional Indian forms of music and communities like the Manganiars are being studied in the Berkeley School of Music.
    5. Contemporary cinema Bollywood has increased its fan following across the globe.

    At the same time, local cultures are modifying western cultures. McDonalds serving a menu catering to Indian taste buds is a case in point. This phenomena has been termed as ‘glocalization’

    From the above, it can be seen that the relationship between globalisation and culture is complex with each impacting the other. The above examples indeed prove that cultural specificities appear to be strengthened in the Indian society.

    20) ‘Communalism arises either due to power struggle or relative deprivation.’ Argue by giving suitable illustrations. (15 marks)

    Communalism in the Indian context refers to the ideology which states that society is divided into different religious communities whose interests differ from, and at times oppose, each other. Historically, Indian society has been regarded as  a melting pot of various religions that have been tolerant of each other. However, the British policy of divide and rule laid the foundations of communalism which the Indian state has found hard to tackle post-independence.

    Communalism indeed arises due to power struggle and relative deprivation

    Power struggle
    -Power struggle between political parties leading to vote bank politics with each trying to garner votes based on identity markers such as religion. Eg. Congress and BJP both trying to appease Muslims and in turn strengthening the Hindu Muslim divide.
    -Between majority and minority groups. Eg. Sikhs and Hindus.

    Relative deprivation

    Deprivation makes groups to fight for limited resources.
    -Case with Assamese and Non-Assamese. Deprivation of the native groups led to movements throughout the state.
    Deprivation makes it easier to influence a group. Rather than self-introspect they blame others for their condition. It causes them to support anyone who can help them marginally move above their misery.
    -Vice President Ansari had pointed out the relative deprivation among Muslims to be the biggest causes of communal tension.

    Long-Term Remedy for Communalism

    1. There is a need to initiate the process of de-communalization of the people at all levels, say, by exposing communal assumptions, by explaining to them the socio-economic and political roots of communalism, and by letting them know that what the communalists project as problems are not the real problem and what they suggest as remedies are not the real remedies.
    2. Communalism of state and of the political elite in power has to be checked because it leads to inaction against communal violence and covert or overt political and ideological support to communalism by the state apparatuses, including the media under state control.
    3. Communalization of civil society also needs to be checked because it leads to more communal roots and other forms of communal violence. It is here that intellectuals, political parties, and voluntary organizations can be the most effective.
    4. The role of education, particularly value-oriented education, both in schools and colleges is important in preventing communal feelings.
    5. The media can prove to be significant in preventing communal feelings. Communal press can be banned and legal action can be taken against communal writers.
    6. 6.   The ideology that economic development, industrialization, the growth of capitalism and the growth of the working class would automatically weaken and ultimately eliminate communalism should not be overplayed.

    Click here to view the schedule + detailed syllabus with sources

    Click here to know the features and enroll.