Mentor’s comment-
- https://indianexpress.com/
article/opinion/columns/ indian-constitution-rajasthan- politics-congress-ashok- gehlot-sachin-pilot-row-anti- defection-law-6518865/ - In the intro, briefly introduce the 10th schedule.
- In the body, mention the ways like voluntarily giving up the membership by resignation, joining another party, acting against the party, publicly expressing opposition to the party, engaging in anti-party activities etc. In the next part, mention the issue of conducting a floor test in a case where ruling party members are lured. In this case sanctity of test in not maintained, due to luring member can’t exercise his discretion, against the constitutional morality etc.
- Conclude by mentioning the need to the revision of some provisions of 10th Schedule.
Comments
18 responses to “Examine the ways in which a member of the house is deemed to have given up his membership under the 10th Schedule as interpreted in the various judgements. Also, analyse the implications of conducting a floor test in a situation when members of the ruling party are lured with rewards. 10 marks”
Payment ID: #0000230867
Various committee suggests rather than presiding officer the decision to disqualify a member should be made 1.president(in mp)2.governor(mla) on advice of election commission
2.disnesh goswami Committee, anti defection should be applied to only to no confidence motion..
Hi Deepika
Good introduction.
You have explained the ways by which a member can voluntarily give up the membership of the party in a good manner.
First explain what is floor test, you can write that it is a term used for the test of the majority. If there are doubts against the Chief Minister (CM) of a State, he/she can be asked to prove the majority in the House.
Suggested strategy is well explained.
Good conclusion.
Content is good, to the point and well placed.
A decent attempt.
Keep writing !
#0000223024
Hi Taran
Need to rephrase your introduction.
You have deviated from the demand of the question, mention the ways like voluntarily giving up the membership by resignation, joining another party, acting against the party, publicly expressing opposition to the party, engaging in anti-party activities etc.
First explain what is floor test, you can write that it is a term used for the test of the majority. If there are doubts against the Chief Minister (CM) of a State, he/she can be asked to prove the majority in the House.
Way forward is well explained.
Conclusion is missing, conclude by mentioning the need to the revision of some provisions of 10th Schedule.
Work on sentence formation.
Keep writing, you will improve.
Order no. #0000233081
Hi Dakshina
Good introduction.
Work on headings and subheadings.
Write ‘ways of giving up the membership’.
You have explained the ways in a comprehensive manner, give subheadings for better presentation.
First explain what is floor test, you can write that it is a term used for the test of the majority. If there are doubts against the Chief Minister (CM) of a State, he/she can be asked to prove the majority in the House.
You have explained the implications in a decent manner.
Write some way forward, like fix a timeline and establish an independent tribunal as suggested by supreme court.
Good conclusion.
Overall a decent attempt.
Keep working hard !
Kindly Review
# 0000230903
Hi Sneha
Good introduction.
You have explained the ways by which a member can voluntarily give up the membership of the party in a good manner.
Implications of floor test are well explained.
Thumbs up for the way forward.
Content is good and well placed.
A decent attempt.
You have the potential of writing good answers, join our Mains Guidance Program for quality enrichment of your answers.
Keep working hard !
MOJO0204R00N55952566
Hi Chester
Rephrase your introduction.
You have given the heading, ‘following are the conditions’ , it does not make any sense, instead write ‘ways of giving up the membership’.
Mention the issue of conducting a floor test in a case where ruling party members are lured. In this case sanctity of test in not maintained, due to luring member can’t exercise his discretion, against the constitutional morality etc.
Need to add more points in the way forward, you can write fix a timeline of the decision of the speaker and establish an independent tribunal as suggested by supreme court.
Good conclusion.
Avoid grammatical errors.
Keep writing, you will improve.
Please review
Please review.
Hi Sakshi
Good introduction but need to summarise it.
You have explained the ways by which a member can voluntarily give up the membership of the party in a good manner.
Work on space management and adhere to the demand of the question.
Mention the issue of conducting a floor test in a case where ruling party members are lured. In this case sanctity of test in not maintained, due to luring member can’t exercise his discretion, against the constitutional morality etc.
Give some way forward.
Summarise your conclusion or fragment it into two parts- way forward and conclusion.
Avoid using short forms.
Leave proper space between the lines.
Keep writing !
Payment id : #0000237030
Hi Unnati
First thing, improve your handwriting, write neat and legible.
Good introduction.
Give proper headings and subheadings to get better marks.
Give heading ‘ways of giving up the membership’ then write your content under it.
First explain what is floor test, you can write that it is a term used for the test of the majority. If there are doubts against the Chief Minister (CM) of a State, he/she can be asked to prove the majority in the House.
You have explained the implications in a decent manner.
Way forward is missing.
Good conclusion.
Work on presentation and follow a proper structure.
Keep writing, you will improve.
pay_FDALbw6305ZjIX
Hi PS
Good introduction.
Work on space management, summarise or merge your points in the ways part.
You have explained the ways by which a member can voluntarily give up the membership of the party in a good manner.
First explain what is floor test, you can write that it is a term used for the test of the majority. If there are doubts against the Chief Minister (CM) of a State, he/she can be asked to prove the majority in the House.
You have explained the implications in a decent manner.
Way forward is decently explained.
Good conclusion.
Content is good and well placed.
A decent attempt.
Keep writing, you will succeed.